Search Results
Search this site
1309 results found with an empty search
- My Case is Ready for Appeal
By Donald V. Watkins ©Copyrighted and Published on July 16, 2019 This afternoon, we finished the sentencing phase of my criminal trial. The prosecution requested a sentence of 210 months, or 17.5 years in prison. The trial judge sentenced me to 60 months. My son received a sentence of 27 months. My case presents several threshold questions of law that are ripe for an appeal. These are questions of first impression in the Eleventh Judicial Circuit: 1. Whether an executed purchase contract that was negotiated at arms-length between sophisticated business parties who were represented by financial and legal professionals is subject to a prosecutorial override 10 to 12 years later solely because the purchasers’ refreshed recollection of the nature and scope of the commercial transaction differs from the written purchase agreement they signed? 2. Whether introductory emails between Charles Barkley and me regarding three loan transactions trump (a) the plain language of the promissory notes that were specifically approved by the lender’s financial advisor and (b) the authorized uses of proceeds that are specified in the applicable corporate operating agreements that govern the business relationship? 3. Whether a bank fraud conviction can be sustained in a case where I, as a bank “insider,” complied with the plain language of a Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation regulatory provision that expressly permitted a loan transaction by a business partner (Dr. Richard Arrington, Jr.) in a "bona fide transaction" where the loan proceeds were used to acquire “goods”, “services,” and “property” from the insider? The background facts for these questions are set for the in “Why I Must Fight,” which was published on March 15, 2019. I am reporting on the sentencing phase of my case because The Birmingham News’ coverage historically portrays civil rights activists like me in the most negative light possible. This is a time-honored tradition at the News that started with its willing participation in J. Edgar Hoover’s infamous COINTELPRO program in the 1950s. I want to especially thank Olayinka O. Arowolo and Jessica A. Findley for volunteering to tell the truth about the status of my international businesses in their sworn Declarations, which were exhibits to my Sentencing Memorandum. Both of these entrepreneurs are pioneers in their areas of operation and highly respected within the energy services industry. Olayinka’s Declaration is Exhibit A to my Sentencing Memorandum. Jessica’s is Exhibit E to my Memorandum. To this day, the Government has never questioned the legitimacy of Nabirm Energy Services (Pty) Ltd., an oil and gas energy services company based in Windhoek, Namibia, or Masada Resource Group, LLC, a waste-to-energy technology company. Each company works every day to successfully implement its business plan. This case is a long way from being over. We will now turn our attention to prosecuting our appeals from the guilty verdicts. As an experienced litigator, I feel very good about our chances on appeal. In the end, justice is not a sprint; it is a marathon. I sincerely thank my readers for understanding the larger issues in my case and for supporting me throughout this ordeal. PHOTO: Donald V. Watkins is ready to appeal his case.
- Thank You, Olayinka and Jessica!
By Donald V. Watkins ©Copyrighted and Published on July 15, 2019 The Birmingham News’ job in Birmingham, Alabama is to portray civil rights activists like me in the most negative light possible. This is a time-honored tradition at the News that started with its willing participation in J. Edgar Hoover’s infamous COINTELPRO program in the 1950s. It continues today. I want to thank Olayinka O. Arowolo and Jessica A. Findley for presenting the truth about the status of my international businesses in their sworn Declarations to my Sentencing Memorandum. Both of these entrepreneurs are pioneers in their respective fields and are highly regarded within the energy services industry. Olayinka’s Declaration is Exhibit A to my Sentencing Memorandum. Jessica’s is Exhibit E to my Memorandum. Both of them volunteered to tell the truth under penalty of perjury. Regardless of what happens at my sentencing hearing tomorrow, I am very proud of what our leadership teams at Masada Resource Group, LLC, and Nabirm Global, LLC, have been able to accomplish on the international stage. Each of these businesses continues to work every day to successfully implement its business plan. Thanks to online journalism, my readers can review Olayinka’s and Jessica’s sworn testimony on an unfiltered basis. PHOTO: Founding President of the Republic of Namibia, Dr. Sam Nujoma (right), accepts a donation of thousands of public school textbooks from Nabirm's CEO, Olayinka Arowolo (left).
- The Sun Always Rises
By Donald V. Watkins ©Copyrighted and Published on July 14, 2019 My sentencing hearing is scheduled for Tuesday morning at 9 a.m. CST in Birmingham, Alabama. This day has been set aside for the trial judge in my criminal case to impose her sentence after a federal court jury found me “guilty” of one count of conspiracy, seven counts of wire fraud, and two counts of bank fraud. I am innocent of those charges. I respect the jury system. Jurors try to do the right thing, more often than not. However, my 46-years of active participation in the American judicial system has shown me (and the world) that well-meaning jurors often convict innocent defendants. The most famous Alabama case that demonstrates this fact happened to be my first case out of law school – the pardon for Mr. Clarence Norris, the last known surviving Scottsboro Boy. In 1931, nine innocent black teenagers were arrested for raping two white women on a freight train passing through Paint Rock, Alabama. The rape charges were fabricated. The defendants were tried by a jury, convicted of rape, and sentenced to death – three times. The U.S. Supreme Court saved the Scottsboro Boys from the administration of Alabama’s death penalty each time. Forty-five years after their arrest, the Alabama Pardons and Parole Board conferred upon Mr. Norris the first and only pardon ever issued to a death row inmate on the basis of his proven “innocence” of the crime for which he was convicted. Mr. Anthony Ray Hinton experienced the same injustice in Alabama. Hinton was charged with the murder of two Birmingham area restaurant managers in 1985. He was convicted by a jury and sentenced to death. Hinton spent nearly 30 years on death row before the State of Alabama dropped the criminal charges against him in 2015 -- several years after prosecutors knew he was innocent of the charges. The Central Park Five case in New York represents a present-day example of innocent defendants who were falsely accused, criminally charged, tried, and convicted of assault, rape, robbery, and other charges. They were subjected to a horrific experience inside the criminal justice system. It took the Central Park Five years to correct this injustice, which finally occurred when the State of New York dismissed the charges against these innocent teenagers, vacated the convictions, and paid them $41 million for their wrongful incarceration. Their case is dramatized in the miniseries, “When They See Us,” which is presently airing on Netflix. These cases also demonstrate why innocent defendants must wage an enduring fight for their freedom. The judicial system rarely corrects injustices on its own; the innocent defendant must become the drum-major for justice in his/her case. The Support in My Case Has Been Overwhelming The support I have received from those who studied the objective evidence in my case has been overwhelming. These supporters know my true character, and they know it is good. Legendary UCLA basketball coach John Robert Wooden said this about character: “Be more concerned with your character than with your reputation. Your character is what you really are while your reputation is merely what others think you are.” Coach Wooden’s statement on character has been my mantra in life. My good character is the glue that holds my family together and secures my rightful place in the world of law and business. The test of character is adversity. It does not build character; it reveals character. One's strength of character is measured by the devotion of those who stand by his/her side in times like these. I have been very blessed in this regard. Freedom is a State of Mind Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. taught me as a child that freedom is a state of mind. He was jailed repeatedly for refusing to surrender his manhood to those who did not see him as a human being. Yet, he was a free man in his mind throughout his entire life. Nelson Mandela suffered a similar fate for the right to be respected as a human being. He was charged with crimes against the Republic of South Africa, tried in court, convicted, and sentenced to a term of 27 years in prison. Mandela served his time in isolation at the infamous Robbins Island prison. Yet, he was a free man in his mind throughout this entire ordeal. Both men were labeled as “criminals” and “con artists" by those who imprisoned them. Both of them sacrificed their physical freedom so that tens of millions of people around the world would be respected as human beings. Both of them are national heroes today. Many people are physically free to move around in the world, but a lot of them are serving lifetime sentences in the prison of psychological inferiority. They have willingly subordinated themselves to a life of subservience. They will never be free. Will Justice Be Served on Tuesday? Our judicial system provides the tools to achieve justice in every case. This is particularly true within the federal system where judges hold lifetime appointments. A sentencing judge has broad discretion to craft a fair and reasonable sentence. Each side has filed a sentencing memorandum with the court on a recommended sentence in my case. This matter is now in the hands of the trial judge. The law allows me to appeal the jury verdicts in my case after the judge sentences me on Tuesday, and I fully intend to do so. My Work is Far From Done The sun always rises each day, and so do I. I enjoy my advocacy work for those who have no effective voice in society. I will continue to be that voice. I love my brand of independent journalism, which presents the cold, hard truth without fear or favor. It will continue, no matter what happens. And, I still have challenging business goals I am striving to achieve. I love attaining goals that people say are impossible to reach, especially for an African-American. Wherever I go and whatever I do, I will always follow John Wooden’s words of wisdom: “Do not let what you cannot do interfere with what you can do.” “Things turn out best for the people who make the best of the way things turn out.” “Make each day your masterpiece.” Talent is God given. Be humble. Fame is man-given. Be grateful. Conceit is self-given. Be careful. “It's what you learn after you know it all that counts.” “It's the little details that are vital. Little things make big things happen.” “Never mistake activity for achievement.” “Ability may get you to the top, but it takes character to keep you there.” “You cannot live a perfect day without doing something for someone who will never be able to repay you.” PHOTO: Donald V. Watkins, Jr. (Left) and Donald V. Watkins, Sr. (right) standing tall in the sunshine of life.
- I Can't Support Joe Biden for President
By Donald V. Watkins ©Copyrighted and Published on July 2, 2019 I cannot support Joe Biden’s candidacy for President of the United States. As Chairman of the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee in 1991, Biden had the power to kill Clarence Thomas’ nomination to the Supreme Court, but he did not do so. As a result, Clarence Thomas became one of the five worst Supreme Court Justice in American history. Biden’s failure to kill Thomas’ nomination is a deal-breaker for me. “I do not share the certainty of some who are voting against Judge Thomas that he will be as extreme as some of his statements could lead one to believe he might be,” said Biden in 1991. Well, Joe Biden, you were wrong. Very Wrong! Because Clarence Thomas is so extreme in his disdain for African-Americans, women and gay Americans, the other conservatives on the Supreme Court often have to distance themselves from his hostility towards these Americans. For example, in May 2016, the Justices voted 7 to 1 to overturn the conviction of Timothy Tyrone Foster, a black death-row inmate who was convicted of murdering an elderly white woman. Foster’s conviction was reversed because the Georgia prosecutors in his case deliberately kicked African-Americans off the jury, in clear violation of prior Supreme Court decisions that potential jurors cannot be struck from jury service because of their race. On June 21, 2019, the Supreme Court ruled that Curtis Flowers, a Mississippi prisoner who was tried six times for murder, deserved a seventh trial because of the prosecutor's well-documented discrimination against potential black jurors. District Attorney Doug Evans engaged in prohibited racial discrimination in each one of Flowers' six trials dating back two decades. Evans eliminated 41 of 42 potential black jurors for whom he used peremptory strikes that required no explanation when exercised. Clarence Thomas saw no problem with Evans’ flagrant discrimination against potential black jurors. In February 2015, Thomas blasted his fellow U.S. Supreme Court Justices for refusing, on a 7-2 vote, to block a ruling that struck down Alabama’s ban on same-sex marriages. Later that day, same-sex couples in the state were granted marriage licenses for the first time ever. In his concurring opinion in the 1995 case of United States v. Lopez, Clarence Thomas expressed his view that federal minimum wage laws, overtime rules, anti-discrimination protections for workers, and even the national ban on whites-only lunch counters are all unconstitutional. Thomas is the only current member of the Supreme Court who has explicitly and openly embraced the reasoning of Lochner Era decisions (from 1897 to 1937) that struck down nationwide child labor laws and made similar attacks on federal power. Clarence Thomas Hurts Millions of Innocent Americans Because Hates Himself During his nearly 28 years on the High Court, Clarence Thomas has vigorously and forcefully opposed equal rights for minorities, women, and gay Americans. Ironically, every break Thomas has received in life, including his post-secondary educational opportunities and his current job on the Supreme Court bench, has been the result of affirmative action based upon his race. Thomas has never distinguished himself in life based upon any intellectual acumen. What little praise he receives as a Supreme Court Justice usually comes from far right-wing conservatives, extremist groups, and corporate titans who admire his fierce loyalty to the preservation of their way of life. Over the decades, I have come to believe that Clarence Thomas hates the fact that he was born a black man. Thomas likely feels that he is a white man trapped in a black man’s body much like a transgender male or female feels trapped in their bodies. Fortunately for transgender males and females, they can free themselves from this bodily prison by having sex reassignment surgery (male-to-female and female-to-male). Unfortunately for Clarence Thomas, no race reassignment surgery is available to him. He is hopelessly trapped in a black man’s body, forever. Serving a life sentence as a black man must be agonizing for Thomas. This genetic condition, I believe, is why Thomas constantly finds new and creative ways to undermine the Constitutional rights of blacks, women, gays, and other minority groups. This is his way of cursing God for his genetic condition. Even though his skin color is black, Thomas has found that by casting votes against these minority groups in a highly visible way he can endear himself to other extremists who oppose equal rights under the law. Joe Biden Had the Power to Kill Thomas’ Nomination, but He Did Not Use It. Joe Biden knew in 1991 that Clarence Thomas was nothing more than a “pack mule” for far right-wing extremists. Biden had the power to kill Thomas’ nomination, but he did not use it. As a result, Thomas has used his position on the Supreme Court to inflict unimaginable pain and suffering on millions of innocent Americans. It is true that Biden voted against Clarence Thomas on the floor of the Senate. However, Biden’s “no” vote was cast only after he knew that Thomas had secured 52 “yes” votes for confirmation. In my view, Joe Biden committed a profound error in judgment in allowing Clarence Thomas’ nomination to survive certain political death in his Senate Judiciary Committee. Thomas’ embarrassing presence and record on the High Court are a constant reminders of how Joe Biden failed Americans who believe in equal protection under the U.S. Constitution for African-Americans, women, gays, and other minority groups. For these reasons, I cannot support Joe Biden for President of the United States. PHOTO: Joe Biden (left) confers with Clarence Thomas (right) during Thomas' Senate confirmation hearings in 1991. At the time, Biden chaired the Senate Judiciary Committee and held the power to kill Thomas' nomination to the High Court.
- Don’t Blame APF Funding Disparity on “White Racism”
By Donald V. Watkins ©Copyrighted and Published on June 30, 2019 On June 28, 2019, I published an article about the Alabama Power Foundation, Inc. (APF). The article highlighted the “winners” and “losers” in APF’s award of grants to community service organizations, churches, and educational institutions in 2017. An analysis of APF’s IRS Form 990-PF for 2017 graphically illustrated the disparity in funding between recipients that serve mainstream Alabama communities and those that serve the needs of the state’s Black Belt counties, minority communities, and underserved rural areas. The disparity in grant awards was not a one-time glitch for 2017. It is a part of a trend that is reflected in APF’s IRS Form 990-PF for tax years 2016, 2015, and 2014. APF is funded by donations from Alabama Power Company shareholders. Because Alabama Power sets its own rates, the ratepayers in Alabama indirectly contribute their fair share of money to APF as well. Alabama Power enjoys a protected monopoly position within the state’s regulated utilities industry. Blacks in Alabama make up 26.2% of the state’s population and nearly 25% of Alabama Power Company’s retail customer base. Yet, APF awarded less than 5% of its direct grants to non-profit organizations that serve the needs of the black community. APF's Funding Disparity Results from a Failure of Black Political Leadership, Not White Racism Alabama Power Company is led by CEO Mark Crosswhite. He is a smart, ethical, fair-minded, and progressive corporate executive with proven skills in leading and growing a $6 billion a year publicly-owned, monopolistic utility giant. Crosswhite has also done a lot to advance equal employment opportunities for blacks and women within the upper ranks of Alabama Power Company’s senior management team. Additionally, APF funds hundreds of deserving community-based, service-oriented non-profit organizations around the state. Myla Calhoun, a Tuskegee native and highly accomplished attorney from a very distinguished family, is the overly qualified and very capable president of APF. Ms. Calhoun is a graduate of Spelman College in Atlanta, Georgia, and The University of Alabama School of Law. She is the perfect person to head APF. The disparity in APF’s award of grants, when compared to the racial breakdown of Alabama Power’s “captive” retail customer base, is a direct result of the failure of Alabama’s black elected officials to perform their job in an effective manner. For decades, these officials have advanced and protected Alabama Power’s monopoly position in the state, while seeking virtually no community reinvestment from the company for their political constituents. Typically, these public officials DO NOT study Alabama Power’s 10-Q and 10-K regulatory filings with the U.S. Exchange and Securities Commission to track the company’s financial growth and net profits. Likewise, they DO NOT study APF’s annual IRS Form 990-PF to see how much money APF allocates to various categories of deserving recipients. These insightful documents are published online and can be easily accessed with the click of a button. Yet, these officials appear to be too lazy or disinterested to access them. So many deserving organizations in political districts represented by black elected officials missed out on equitable funding from APF over the past four years because too many of these public officials spent their time and energy pressuring APC for campaign cash and jobs for their friends, lovers, mistresses, and relatives, instead of APF grants for deserving service-oriented organizations that would lift the quality of life in the communities they represent. Black public officials are elected to serve the interests of their constituents within the halls of government and in the boardrooms of corporate America. However, most of these officials abandon the political interests of their constituents as soon as the swearing-in ceremony ends. Too many of today’s black public officials are preoccupied with traveling to conferences in America and abroad, begging for free tickets to concerts and sporting events, issuing feel-good proclamations on symbolic subjects, and posting photos on Facebook, Snapchat, and Instagram in an effort to project an image of perceived power. When they do fight for something, it is usually a battle for front-row seats at entertainment events, or skybox tickets at major sports events, or VIP treatment at commemorative events that celebrate the courage of civil rights icons from the 1950s and 1960s. As a result, black communities in Alabama and across the nation are suffering terribly from a lack of effective leadership, a lack of basic government services, and a lack of corporate reinvestment in the black community. In Alabama, this lack of leadership has resulted in APF funding animal welfare programs in an amount that is greater than its funding for social services in Alabama’s poorest Black Belt counties. For example, the Selma and Black Belt Region Abuse Sanctuary, which is a shelter for victims of domestic and sexual violence, received only $300 in 2017. In contrast, funding for animal safety and welfare programs for dogs, cats, horses, fish, and wildlife in open habitats and in zoos totaled $222,775 in 2017. The disparity in APF’s funding for colleges and universities was even more glaring. Auburn University, The University of Alabama at Birmingham, and Samford University were awarded nearly all of the money allocated for institutions of higher education. Their collective grants represented more than 25% of the $9,679,493 APF awarded to all recipients in 2017, not just colleges and universities. In addition, APF has committed $2,500,000 in funding for Auburn University and UAB in future years. In contrast, the aggregate amount of money awarded to Alabama State University, Alabama A&M University, and Tuskegee University, which are Alabama’s flagship HBCUs, was only $100,000 in 2017. Spelman College, which is a flagship HBCU in Atlanta, received $5,000. The total funding for the Selma and Black Belt Region Abuse Sanctuary and the flagship HBCUs in Alabama and Georgia was a mere $105,300. In contrast, the animals at the Birmingham Zoo, alone, received $113,000 in 2017. Furthermore, the Birmingham Zoo animals are guaranteed another $300,000 in APF funding in future years, while the flagship HBCUs are not guaranteed any grant funding. My Message to Alabama's Black Public Officials My message to Alabama’s black elected and appointed officials is this: Please stop using “white racism” as an excuse for your dismal failure to adequately represent the political interests of your constituents, educational institutions, and communities. No white person is stopping you from preparing yourself for a productive, constituent-focused, mission-oriented meeting with Alabama Power Company CEO Mark Crosswhite or Alabama Power Foundation President Myla Calhoun. Stop complaining and start helping qualified and deserving non-profit organizations in your communities compete for APF grants. If you can find the time or interest to request a meeting with Mr. Crosswhite or Ms. Calhoun, please have something of substance to say to them that positions your constituent organizations as genuine “partners in progress” with Alabama Power Company. Otherwise, you are wasting their time and yours. Above all, please stop “hustling” Alabama Power Company for trinkets for yourself and tangible economic benefits for your relatives, lovers, and mistresses. When you engage in this type of irresponsible political behavior, your constituent organizations lose out every time. PHOTO: Alabama Power Foundation President Myla Calhoun (left) with Alabama Power Company CEO Mark Crosswhite (right).
- Alabama Power Foundation Awards: Winners and Losers
By Donald V. Watkins ©Copyrighted and Published on June 28, 2019 In 2017, the Alabama Power Foundation, Inc. (APF), awarded $9,679,493 in grants to deserving entities. APF reported total net assets of $133,330,302 for 2017. APF offers grants to nonprofit organizations in Alabama and elsewhere that are working in the following areas: (a) educational advancement, (b) civic and community development, (c) arts and cultural enrichment, (d) health and human services, and (e) environmental stewardship. According to APF, “priority is given to projects that address underserved segments of the population, such as racial or ethnic minorities, people experiencing poverty, or underprivileged communities with fewer opportunities.” APF is funded by donations from Alabama Power Company shareholders. Because Alabama Power set its own rates, as discussed below, the ratepayers in Alabama indirectly contribute their fair share of money to APF, as well. I recently reviewed APF’s IRS Form 990-PF for 2017, dated November 9, 2018, to determine the winners and losers in APF’s funding sweepstakes. The results stunned me. Alabama Power Company is in a Class by Itself Alabama Power Company generated $6 billion in gross revenues in 2018. The company’s net income after payment of operating expenses and shareholder dividends was $930 million. This amount represents an increase in net income of $82 million, or 9.7%, over the previous year. According to Advanced Energy Economy’s Power Portal database, which tracks ROE for over 100 publicly-owned utilities across the country, the highest ROE allowed by a public utility commission belongs to Alabama Power Co., at 13.75%. This ROE places Alabama Power in a class by itself. Furthermore, Alabama taxpayers guarantee Alabama Power a five percent minimum annual return on the company’s equity. If there is a shortfall in this guaranteed minimum return on equity, taxpayers must make up the difference. Instead of making a case for rate increases, Alabama Power Company uses a formula-based ratemaking process (called the “Rate Equalization and Stabilization” formula) to effectively adjust its rates each year without any public evidentiary hearings and without any participation by ratepaying consumers. In 2015, Alabama Power overcharged its customers by $146 millionthrough a fee used to cover fuel costs. Instead of issuing refunds to customers, as required by law, Alabama Power simply reduced its energy cost recovery in 2016 by $120 million dollars. The company’s last rate decrease was in 2016. Its last rate increase was in 2017. APF Winners and Losers The first thing I noticed was the salary paid to Myla Calhoun, who works 24 hours per week as APF’s president and who made $164,078 in 2017. The average Foundation Director salary in Alabama is $132,592 as of May 31, 2019, but the range typically falls between $108,692 and $164,446. Myla Calhoun is definitely a WINNER. Second, since 1991, APF has operated a scholarship program for the children of employees of Alabama Power Company. Each recipient receives an award of $2,500. In 1995, APF expanded the program to include Presidential scholarships. These scholarships provide 4 years of undergraduate tuition and mandatory fees at one of Alabama’s colleges and universities. The employees/parents of APF’s scholarship recipients are big-time WINNERS. Third, the Auburn University Foundation received $2,475,324 from APF in 2017, which dwarfed the amounts received by Alabama State University ($50,000), Alabama A&M University ($25,000), Tuskegee University ($25,000), and Spelman College in Atlanta, Georgia ($5,000). Historically black Oakwood College in Huntsville, Stillman College in Tuscaloosa, Miles College in Birmingham, and Talladega College in Talladega were left out in the cold. The Auburn University Foundation received 25.5% of the total $9,679,493 in grants awarded in 2017, The University of Alabama at Birmingham (UAB) Educational Foundation received $200,000, and Samford University in Birmingham received $60,605. APF has committed another $2,000,000 in future funding to Auburn University. UAB was assured of $200,000 for its capital campaign and $300,000 for its athletics program. Auburn University and UAB are clear WINNERS. Fourth, the Crimson Tide Foundation received $10,000, while the Miles College Booster Club received $2,500. The Crimson Tide Foundation is a WINNER. Fifth, the Eagles Landing Christian Academy, which was founded under the name of McDonough Christian Academy in 1970 as a private school for white students fleeing public school desegregation in McDonough, Georgia, received $1,172 in 2017. Given its troublesome history, this school is a WINNER. Sixth, the Hispanic Interest Coalition of Alabama, which is headquartered in Birmingham, received $31,000, while the Mexican Orphans Missions in Birmingham received $45,000. These organizations are WINNERS. Seventh, mega-churches in the Birmingham area fared very well. For example, Canterbury United Methodist Church in Mountain Brook received $10,000 in 2017. The Church of the Highlands in Birmingham received $5,000. Dawson Memorial Baptist Church in Birmingham received $15,000. Meadowbrook Baptist Church in Birmingham received $10,000. The Sixteenth Street Baptist Church in Birmingham, which was the site of the 1963 church bombing that killed four little girls during the Sunday School hour, received $10,000. These churches are WINNERS. Eight, the Alabama Special Olympics received $1,000. The Alabama Institute for the Deaf and Blind received $1,500. The Association for Retarded Citizens received $140. Arts ‘N Autism, Inc. received $1,000. Alabama Senior Olympics received $500. These organizations, which help physically and mentally impaired children/adults/seniors, are clear LOSERS in the funding sweepstakes. Ninth, the Congressional Black Caucus received $10,000. Dr. Martin Luther King’s Southern Christian Leadership Conference received $50,000, while the Martin Luther King Center for Non-Violent Social Change received $10,000. The NAACP received $1,000, while the National Council of Negro Women received $100. The National Voting Rights Museum and Institute in Salma received $5,000. The United Negro College Fund received $10,000. Given the meager amounts APF awarded to these important social justice organizations, they must be viewed as LOSERS. The Sickle Cell Disease Association, which fights the Sickle Cell disease that primarily affects black people, received $500 in 2017. The Association is a LOSER in the APF funding sweepstakes. The National Society of Black Engineers in Alexandria, Virginia received $50,000. It is a WINNER. Tenth, the Selma and Black Belt Region Abuse Sanctuary is a shelter for victims of domestic and sexual violence. It received $300 in 2017. The funding allocation for this critical sanctuary organization is shameful, especially when compared to the $1,172 APF awarded to a former segregationist academy in McDonough, Georgia. The Selma and Black Belt Abuse Sanctuary is a LOSER in the APF awards. In contrast, funding for animal safety and welfare programs (i.e., dogs, cats, horses, fish, and wildlife in open habitats and in zoos) totaled $222,775 in 2017. The animals in these programs are clear WINNERS, especially when compared to the anemic funding for organizations with missions dedicated to advancing and protecting the safety and welfare of African-Americans. This is especially true in light of the fact that APF has committed another $300,000 in future funding to the Birmingham Zoo. Are APF’s Awards Equitable? Alabama Power enjoys a protected monopoly status in the state’s utilities industry. Blacks in Alabama make up 26.2% of the state’s population and nearly 25% of Alabama Power Company’s retail customers. Yet, APF awarded less than 5% of its direct grants to non-profit organizations that serve the needs of the black community. This disparity is not a one-time glitch for 2017. It is a trend that is reflected in APF’s IRS Form 990-PF for tax years 2016, 2015, and 2014. This is not “Happy News.” This is the cold, hard truth. PHOTO: Alabama Power Foundation logo.
- Brenda Lee Thompson Carter: One of God’s Greatest Gifts to Humanity
By Donald V. Watkins ©Copyrighted and Published on June 27, 2016, Updated on June 27, 2019 Three years ago today, I drove to Montgomery, Alabama to attend the funeral of Brenda Lee Thompson Carter. God’s angels came to Montgomery on June 16, 2016 to escort Brenda to her Heavenly home. She was 69-years old and died after a long battle with Alzheimer's disease. I first met Brenda in 1974, and said my final goodbye to her three years ago this month. Brenda’s home-going celebration was one of the most difficult moments of my life. This remarkable woman was my former law partner Billy Carter’s loving wife of 42 years. She was also the mother of two wonderful, highly intelligent and well-mannered children, Bryan and Brooke Carter. Brenda was my former wife DeAndra’s best friend. She was also the unsung hero who quietly lifted up countless individuals and institutions in America during their most challenging times. In short, Brenda was one of God’s greatest gifts to humanity. She was the epitome of class, character, love and strength. Every family member and friend who gathered in the packed Montgomery church to say goodbye to Brenda had been impacted in a favorable way by his/her interaction with Brenda. Her departure to Heaven has left a huge void in our lives and the world as a whole. Brenda and DeAndra were the solid rocks that formed the foundation for the small law practice Billy and I started in 1979. Both of us had previously worked with legendary civil rights attorney Fred Gray from 1974 to 1978. With little money and only the support of our spouses and families, Billy and I ventured out on our own on January 1, 1979. Brenda and DeAndra banked every penny they had saved on their collective belief that Billy and I could develop and run a successful law practice. DeAndra and I had four small kids – Donald, Jr., Light, Drew, and Dustin -- when we started our law practice in Montgomery. Brenda and Billy would not have Bryan and Brooke until several years later. As such, they always had more money than DeAndra and me and shared what they had with us. Brenda regularly cooked French fries and breaded fried shrimp for the four of us at their home on Friday nights where we gathered to watch TV and reminisce about the week. Billy and Brenda were always trying to ease the financial crunch on DeAndra, my four sons, and me. Brenda was born to the late John Halsey Thompson and Eugene Walden Thompson on June 27, 1947 in West Palm Beach, Florida. Her parents were truly great people. They were working-class Americans who loved and supported their children. Brenda was raised with her younger brother, John Wendell Thompson, in West Palm Beach where she attended John F. Kennedy High School and graduated as valedictorian of her class in 1965. After graduating from high school, Brenda relocated to Washington, D.C. to attend Howard University. She graduated with her Bachelor of Science degree in Microbiology in 1969. While studying at Howard, Brenda met Billy Carter and married him on June 15, 1974, following a six-year courtship. Brenda and Billy moved to Montgomery in November of 1974 and Brenda began her professional career as a clinical technician with two public health agencies. In 1978, Brenda earned her Master’s Degree in Public Administration from Auburn University at Montgomery and began a long and distinguished career at the Alabama Commission on Higher Education (“ACHE”) where she served as ACHE’s Director of Academic Programs until her retirement in 2006. Brenda’s work at ACHE directly contributed to the meteoric rise of academic programs at historically black Alabama State University and Alabama A&M University (among other colleges and universities in Alabama). Her courageous and pioneering work at ACHE paved the way for Alabama State University to break the last color barrier in higher education by attaining the Level-Six accreditation status that had been held exclusively in the state by the University of Alabama and Auburn University. Billy, Brenda, John and their parents were cornerstones in the life of our family. They were good and decent people. Their integrity was beyond reproach. If there are finer people in the world, I have not met them. I salute Billy, Bryan, Brooke and John for personally taking care of Brenda during her long battle with Alzheimer's disease. Brenda’s journey along the road to Heaven was filled with the unconditional love that only Billy, Bryan, Brooke and John could have given her. The outpouring of love she received from them during this difficult period in her life was as great as the geyser of love Brenda showered on them and all of us. One measure of the magnitude of Brenda’s impact on society is embodied in the incredible story of John’s historic rise in corporate America. Brenda was John’s big sister, best friend, mentor, childhood protector, life coach and biggest cheerleader during his ascent to the top of the corporate world. In 2014, John, a graduate of Florida A&M University with a Master’s Degree from MIT in Management Science, succeeded Bill Gates as the chairman of Microsoft. John is a former vice-president at IBM and the former CEO of cyber security giant Symantec. John led the search for Microsoft CEO, Satya Nadella. Today, John, who is 70-years-old, is one of the most powerful corporate executives in the world and he reached the top without denying his heritage or cultural upbringing. Throughout the reign of her greatness, Brenda never sought recognition for her daily good works. Humility was her calling card. Making a positive difference for humanity was her legacy. The world was Brenda’s family and she loved it with all of her heart. Three years after her death, I still miss Brenda dearly and I thank God for allowing my life to be touched by her greatness. I will never forget Brenda and her positive impact upon the world. In the end, she lifted us all. PHOTO: Brenda Lee Thompson Carter (1947-2016).
- Rural Customers Win Major Concessions from Alabama Power Company
By Donald V. Watkins ©Copyrighted and Published on June 26, 2019 Yesterday, Perry County, Alabama Commissioner Albert Turner, Jr., announced the successful outcome of his meeting with Alabama Power Company. The meeting was requested by Turner to address his concerns about Alabama Power’s plan to close 40 of its 86 local offices around the state by August 16, 2019. The closures targeted offices in Black Belt counties and rural communities, and reduced customer services in these areas. Turner is a longtime human rights activist and one of the few elected officials in Alabama who is “unbossed” and “unbought.” Like his mother and father, who were nationally-recognized human rights icons in West Alabama, Commissioner Turner stands up for poor people, middle-class Alabamians, senior citizens on a fixed income, and small business owners whenever he sees an injustice inflicted upon them. Turner saw such an injustice when Alabama Power Company announced the office closures earlier this month. The office in Marion, which is the county seat for Perry County, is on the list of closures. Turner understands the articulated business case for closing these offices, but he denounced Alabama Power’s practice of allowing its authorized privately owned and operated payment centers to charge customers a processing fee of $1 to $3 for each bill payment made in person at these locations. In Turner's view, these transactional fees gouge Alabama Power's "pay in person" customers and effectively constitutes an unauthorized rate increase that is borne solely by the affected customers. Commissioner Turner believed the transactional fees should be borne exclusively by Alabama Power Company. This was Alabama Power's custom and practice in the late 1990s and early 2000s when the company began the gradual shift to privately operated payment centers. During his meeting Tuesday with Alabama Power Company executives and local public officials, poor people, rural customers, senior citizens on a fixed income, and small business owners won major concessions from the utility giant. Below is a list of Commissioner Turner’s concerns and the concessions won during the meeting: 1. Alabama Power customers are being charged transaction fees for bill payments by its authorized third-party payment center operators: Alabama Power Company agreed that all authorized payment centers will cease collecting these service fees by August 16, 2019. However, non-authorized payment centers will continue to charge customers for their transactions. 2. Authorized payment centers are not allowing same-day credits (shadow payments) on the day the payments are made: Alabama Power Company agreed that all authorized payment centers will provide same-day credit immediately upon payment. In fact, Alabama Power officials noted that an aggressive education of its authorized payment centers began after Commissioner Turner voiced his concerns publicly on June 11, 2019. Company officials noted that several authorized payment centers were not well versed in the payment process, but that situation is changing. 3. Social service agencies did not have access to privately operated payment centers for the purpose of making payment arrangements on behalf of their clients: Alabama Power Company officials promised that a dedicated phone number will be provided in order for social services agencies to call area managers to make payment pledges and arrangements. This number will be available prior to the August 16 closing date. 4. The fate of local Alabama Power Company office buildings: This issue is being discussed in-depth to get values on each property, according to Alabama Power Company Vice President Leslie Sanders. The company’s desire is to transfer ownership of these properties via a sale to local governments at a market or below market price. 5. Community support from Alabama Power Company has been anemic in Black Belt counties and rural communities: Alabama Power officials acknowledged that the Alabama Power Foundation, Inc. has not made its presence felt in rural communities, particularly in Black Belt counties. However, that will change immediately. Area managers will aggressively begin educating communities on the Foundation's mission and encouraging deserving entities to seek funding from the Foundation. Company officials made a firm commitment to show more corporate reinvestment and social responsibility in the Black Belt communities, via the Foundation. After the meeting, Commissioner Turner said, "this meeting was needed, and the results were all on point. This is what happens when you sit down with corporate officials and discuss issues of importance that affect the citizens. We get positive results." Alabama Power VP Leslie Sanders applauded Commissioner Turner for bringing his concerns to the table in a frank and honest fashion. She also thanked all of the local officials who were concerned enough about their communities to join in and work as partners-in-progress with Alabama Power Company on these concerns. Among those who were present and who participated in Commissioner Turner’s meeting were: Aubrey Carter, Area Manager at Alabama Power, Mike Jordan, Manager of Southern Division, Leslie Sanders, Vice President Southern Division, Latonia Tisdale, Office Supervisor for Marion and Selma, Hale County Commission Chairman Arthur Crawford, Hale County Commissioner Donald Anderson, City of Greensboro Clerk Gay Nell Singleton, State Representative Prince Chestnut, Melissa Williams from the Office of Congresswoman Terri Sewell, Margret Hardy from State Senator Malika Sander's office, Perry County DHR Director Ms. Dorothy Carson, Frances Ford of Perry County Sowing Seeds of Hope, and Colonel David J. Mollahan of Marion Military Institute. PHOTO: Perry County, Alabama Commissioner Albert Turner, Jr. (center) is surrounded by local officials who attended his meeting on Tuesday with Alabama Power Company executives. PHOTO: Alabama Power Company Vice President Leslie Sanders.
- Gov. Bentley Asked ALEA to Investigate Watkins, Shuler
By Donald V. Watkins ©Copyrighted and Published on June 20, 2019 Deposition testimony from former Gov. Robert Bentley and former Alabama Law Enforcement Agency Chief Spencer Collier in a recently settled lawsuit between the two men confirmed that Bentley viewed me as a “political enemy" and asked Collier to investigate me for criminal wrongdoing as a means of discrediting me. The other online journalist who was targeted for destruction is Roger Shuler. Schuler and I published a series of articles in 2015 that exposed Gov. Bentley’s secret love affair with his mistress and lover, Rebekah Caldwell Mason. The publication of my “Forbidden Love” and “Executive Betrayal” series of investigative articles in September/October 2015 infuriated Bentley. Once First Lady Dianne Jones Bentley confirmed that Rebekah Mason was her husband’s paramour, she sued Gov. Bentley for a divorce and exited their marriage. Gov. Bentley had already exited the marriage, emotionally and otherwise. He was hopelessly in love with Rebekah Mason, a married mother of three children who served as his senior political advisor. Mason's sexual seduction of Bentley gave her complete control of the governor’s office. Roger Shuler’s Recent Articles Expose Bentley’s Violations of Law Roger Shuler published two recent articles that exposed Bentley’s sinister and unlawful plan to use federal and state resources to launch criminal investigations against Shuler and me in retaliation for our news reporting on the Bentley-Mason love affair and sex scandal. Bentley was not worried about the state’s mainstream news media organizations because he regarded them as too weak, too compromised, and too afraid to report on his “sex-for-power” scandal. He was right. These media outlets did not join the fray until seven months later when audiotapes surfaced of phone sex between Bentley and Mason. Shuler’s July 17, 2018 article reported the deposition testimony of Bentley. According to his testimony, Gov. Bentley felt threatened by my articles. Here is what he had to say on this point: “Spencer and I talked two or three times about all these things that had transpired, you know, the things that were on blogs and things like this. The thing about Donald Watkins, so much of that had been fed to him by, obviously, somebody, and so he was one of the ones that was putting out some of this material that I felt was somewhat threatening. So Spencer told me -- I remember on three occasions, Spencer said, "Now, Governor, you're not telling me to investigate this, because I don't know how they investigate things," but he said, "I am going to investigate this." He investigated -- I don't know how much they did on Donald Watkins, I don't know what they looked into on it, I don't know what they used, but he was one of the ones that we talked about. The guy at Legal Schnauzer, whatever his name is, he was one of the others. I also gave Spencer some e-mails from my former accountant that Spencer felt like were extortion. So Spencer investigated some things. I don't know exactly how much was investigated, though.” Bentley lied in his deposition when he claimed that he did not know what became of the investigations. They, in fact, continued. Roger Shuler’s July 17th article links to the entire Bentley deposition for the convenience of his readers. In his June 19, 2019 article, Shuler presents Spencer Collier’s version of the same events. According to Collier’s sworn deposition testimony: “Bentley had, and continues to have, a pattern and practice of using ALEA equipment, facilities, and labor for his own personal reasons, including using and attempting to use ALEA law enforcement officers to try to dig up dirt on people that Bentley disliked or became upset with.” When asked to elaborate, Collier stated: “Governor Bentley on several occasions requested either myself or special agents -- other special agents either in executive or protective services, dignitary protection, to access law enforcement-sensitive databases to obtain information on individuals that he viewed were political enemies of his…. Governor Bentley requested myself and another special agent to try and gather information on Donald Watkins. He also requested it on a blogger out of Shelby County. I don't know the gentleman -- recall the gentleman's name, he ran a blog. On another occasion, the governor asked us to use law enforcement sensitive information to discredit Donald Watkins. I don't know Donald Watkins, I didn't know him. I don't necessarily know what it was about, but obviously Mr. Watkins had said some negative things about the governor, and the governor wanted us to discredit him in general. I again explained to the governor that NCIC, ACJIS, all of that was law enforcement sensitive, and we had to have criminal justice purpose to utilize it.” Spencer Collier was right about the use of the federal NCIC criminal database and state ACJIS information system for political and personal reasons. It is a crime to use these databases for political and personal reasons . In 2000, former Jefferson County Sheriff Jimmy Woodard and Birmingham Attorney Albert Jordan were charged, tried, and convicted in federal court for using the NCIC and ACJIS databases for political and personal reasons. Their convictions were upheld on appeal. As evidenced by his deposition testimony, Gov. Bentley engaged in the same politically motivated and retaliatory conduct in 2015. Yet, Bentley was not prosecuted by federal or state law enforcement authorities for these criminal acts. Spencer Collier Refused to Investigate Watkins, but Others Did Spencer Collier refused to use federal and state resources to launch politically motivated criminal investigations against Roger Shuler and me. Because of this refusal, Collier was fired. Undeterred, Gov. Bentley’s efforts to use federal and state resources to harass me continued under the leadership of David Byrne, the governor’s legal adviser/consigliere, and Stan Stabler, Bentley’s replacement for Collier. Byrne also worked closely with John D. Harrison, the former Superintendent of the Alabama Banking Department, to run me out of the banking business. To date, these efforts have not been successful. Harrison allowed Bentley to hijack his office and use the state Banking Department to administer retribution against the governor’s targeted political enemies. The number one target on the governor’s list of enemies was me. Prior to this targeting, I had been successfully operating Alamerica Bank on Birmingham’s Southside since its founding in January 2000. The bank is one of only 19 African-American banks in America and holds the only bank charter ever issued by the state of Alabama to an African-American. The bank has always been well capitalized and did not require taxpayer bailout money during the Great Recession of 2008. Prior to Bentley’s retaliation, the bank had never experienced problems with its regulators. The Banking Department’s abusive regulatory oversight of Alamerica Bank was so severe and harsh that it was an open secret within the industry that the Department was trying to administer the “death penalty” to the bank. The disparate and unfavorable regulatory treatment of Alamerica Bank, when compared to the treatment of other state chartered banks in Alabama, was shocking to our peers in the industry. Everyone knew that I had been singled out for destruction. What is more, the Banking Department cajoled the FDIC’s Atlanta region office to go along with its regulatory retaliation program. Collier’s Ordeal is Ending Spencer Collier sued Bentley for his wrongful termination. The case was settled last week with Collier receiving a reported $700,000 under the settlement agreement. Thereafter, the case will be dismissed. Collier’s ordeal is ending, but mine continues. Gov. Bentley resigned his office in disgrace in April 2017. Today, Bentley and Rebekah Mason are still lovers and they work together in Bentley's private medical practice. The mainstream reporters who were afraid to publish articles on the Bentley-Mason secret love affair during the first seven months of the scandal in 2015-16 eventually won praise for their work from pundits on national TV. One of them won a Pulitzer Prize for regurgitating and repackaging the journalistic work performed by Roger Shuler and me under the most threatening, harmful, and retaliatory conditions. The rest of the story is history. PHOTO: Former Gov. Robert Bentley (left) and former ALEA Chief Spencer Collier (right) settled Collier’s wrongful termination lawsuit last week.
- Alabama Power to Meet with Albert Turner Over Shabby Treatment of Rural Customers
By Donald V. Watkins ©Copyrighted and Published on June 19, 2019 Yesterday, Perry County, Alabama Commissioner Albert Turner, Jr., announced that he will meet with Alabama Power Company officials on June 25, 2019 at 10:00 a.m. in the board room of Marion Military Institute. The meeting will address recent concerns voiced by Turner about a planned reduction in Alabama Power's customer service in Perry County. Turner is a longtime human rights activist and one of the few elected officials in Alabama who is “unbossed” and “unbought.” Like his parents, who were nationally-recognized civil rights icons in West Alabama, Commissioner Turner stands up for poor people, middle-class Alabamians, senior citizens on a fixed income, and small business owners when he sees a glaring injustice in the way these people are treated. Turner found such an injustice two weeks ago when Alabama Power announced that it was closing 40 of its 86 business offices across the state by August 2019. As expected, these offices are located in West Alabama’s Black Belt counties (including Alabama Power’s office in Marion, the county seat for Perry County) and other rural communities around the state. Turner understands the business case for closing these business offices, but he decries Alabama Power’s policy and practice of allowing its authorized, privately operated payment centers to charge customers a processing fee of $1 to $3 for each bill payment made at these locations. This fee gouges the customers who choose to pay their bills at the payment centers and it effectively constitutes a rate increase that is borne solely by these customers. Commissioner Turner points out that this transactional fee should be borne by Alabama Power Company, as was the case in the late 1990s and early 2000s when Alabama Power began the shift to privately operated payment centers. Turner’s announcement stated: “The Southern Company, which is the parent company of Alabama Power Company, will send Leslie Sanders, the Vice President of the Southern Division, to Marion, Alabama. Leslie is responsible for the company’s operations in parts of 19 counties in South Central Alabama, including Montgomery and Marion. The Southern Division’s 660 employees serve approximately 220,000 customers. She has been in her current role since August 2011. Commissioner Turner called for a meeting shortly after being informed that the company will close the Marion office, as of August 2019. The news was not received well by Commissioner Turner. In an effort to address several issues that were forwarded to [Alabama Power’s] Sr. Vice President Quentin Riggins, a meeting has been planned to solve those concerns. The Commissioner acknowledged that Alabama Power Company is working through two friends -- Leslie Sanders and Quentin Riggins. Turner said, ‘with those two individuals, the public can be assured that a People's plan will be presented. I have all the confidence in the world that the meeting will be about a solution to common sense problems.’” After we published an exclusive article on June 11, 2019 about Commissioner Turner’s concerns, Alabama Power promptly called for a meeting with him to address these concerns. Turner's has requested the elimination of the $1 to $3 service charge for bill payments at authorized third-party payment centers in each of the cities on the closure list. He has also requested that at least one payment center in each city have the ability to post same-day credits to customer accounts upon payment. Finally, he has requested that indigent clients who receive assistance from family services agencies have the ability to communicate directly with a manager to credit those accounts immediately upon approval by the agency that a payment will be made. Commissioner Turner is not demanding that Alabama Power’s local offices remain open. Instead, he simply wants the level of customer service provided at the company's local offices to remain the same at the privately operated payment centers. Turner said, “[Alabama Power] is a [publicly traded] company and if they want to close offices, that's their decision. However, they are assured a profit by the [State of Alabama’s] government of a minimum 5% annual return on equity, so I feel that their customer service should not be a cost to a customer unless the customer wants to pay for it. There should be an option available to customers to [avoid paying] a service fee [at the third-party payment centers] just as it is with their online payments. Rural customers should not be punished because they don't have internet and poor people shouldn't be punished because they can't purchase a computer. The elderly shouldn't be punished because they don't know how to use a computer.” Commissioner Turner expressed confidence that Leslie Sanders, Quinton Riggins and Alabama Power will resolve this matter to his satisfaction. A number of elected officials are expected to attend this meeting, including District 7 Congresswoman Terry Sewell (or her representative) to small town mayors from surrounding areas. The meeting is open to the public, but seating is limited to invited guests. The meeting is credited, in part, to a successful and engaging corporate roundtable Commissioner Turner formed in Perry County several years ago. Alabama Power’s area manager is a member of the roundtable. The meeting is also the result of Turner's willingness to stand up and speak out on behalf of poor people, middle-class customers, senior citizens on a fixed income, and small business owners. His advocacy in this regard is a Turner family legacy and core value. When asked what will happen if Alabama Power does not adequately address his concerns, Turner replied, “I don't meet just to meet, or for photo ops. I have assurances that the company is working sincerely to ease the inconveniences that I have mentioned to them. Think about it, Alabama Power doesn't want to make it harder for them to collect their money." Alabama Power Enjoys Booming Revenues Although Alabama Power has proposed to cut customer services in Black Belt counties and rural communities around the state, the company’s cost-cutting measures do not apply to Alabama Power’s high-flying corporate lifestyle and mind-blowing executive perks. Alabama Power continues to sponsor extravagant game-day events at college football games in Tuscaloosa and Auburn. Its corporate jets are still ferrying executives and dignitaries back and forth to exotic ports of call. Its presence is still felt at the Masters golf tournament in Augusta, Georgia, at Regions’ golf tournament in Birmingham, at national NCAA championship football games around the nation, at NLF Super Bowls, at “March Madness” games, and at ritzy air shows in Paris and London. Last year, Alabama Power agreed to pay $500,000 per year for a naming rights sponsorship package for the new UAB football stadium in downtown Birmingham and for the luxury skybox that goes with it. The list of over-the-top corporate perks paid for by ratepayers in Perry County and elsewhere in the state is endless. Alabama Power Company generated $6 billion in gross revenues in 2018. The company’s net income after payment of operating expenses and shareholder dividends was $930 million. This amount represents an increase in net income of $82 million, or 9.7%, over the previous year. According to Advanced Energy Economy’s Power Portal database, which tracks ROE for over 100 publicly-owned utilities across the country, the highest ROE allowed by a public utility commission belongs to Alabama Power Co., at 13.75%. This ROE places Alabama Power is in a class by itself. Furthermore, Alabama taxpayers guarantee Alabama Power a five percent minimum annual return on the company’s equity. If there is a shortfall in this guaranteed minimum return on equity, taxpayers must make up the difference. In 2015, Alabama Power overcharged its customers by $146 millionthrough a fee used to cover fuel costs. Instead of issuing refunds to customers, as required by law, Alabama Power simply reduced its energy cost recovery in 2016 by $120 million dollars. The Alabama Public Service Commission characterized this reduction as a “rate cut” in a press release issued by the agency. The Commission’s press release made it look as if Alabama Power was doing its customers a favor rather than giving them back their own money, as required by law. Locations of Alabama Power Business Office Closures Alabama Power’s business office closures will occur in Columbiana, Gardendale, Leeds, Aliceville, Carbon Hill, Dora, Greensboro, Hamilton, Linden, Livingston, Sulligent, West Blocton, York, Clayton, Daleville, Slocomb, Alexander City, Ashville, Attalla, Blountsville, Heflin, Jacksonville, Wedowee, Bayou La Batre, Brewton, Butler, Citronelle, Flomaton, Grove Hill, Jackson, Prichard, Theodore, Fort Deposit, Georgiana, Marion, Tallassee, Wetumpka, Ashford, Florala, and Geneva. Commissioner Turner is the only public official in Alabama who publicly complained about the adverse impact of the planned office closures on poor people, middle-class consumers, senior citizens on a fixed income, and small business owners in these locations. No other public "watchdog" barked. PHOTO: Perry County, Alabama Commissioner Albert Turner, Jr., pictured below, will meet with Alabama Power Company officials Leslie Sanders and Quinton Riggins on June 25, 2019 in Marion, Alabama to address recent customer service issues in his political district. PHOTO: Alabama Power Company Vice President Leslie Sanders is pictured below. PHOTO: Alabama Power Company Vice President Quinton Reggins is pictured below.
- Glynn Wilson: Another Hustler Pushing a Donald Watkins Book Deal
By Donald V. Watkins ©Copyrighted and Published on June 15, 2019 On May 31, 2019, I published an article about Kyle Whitmire’s effort to write an unauthorized biography about my life. Whitmire is a Birmingham, Alabama-based reporter with the Alabama Media Group, which owns The Birmingham News and the website AL.com. Whitmire covered my criminal trial on wire fraud, bank fraud, and conspiracy charges in February and March 2019. Whitmire’s slanted coverage of the trial fed a steady stream of negative news articles to Google and local TV news outlets. Thursday night, I learned that Glynn Wilson is also researching my life for a possible book deal. Wilson publishes articles on a website called the New American Journal. He is a former reporter for several daily newspapers. In 2005, Wilson went independent on the web and started blogging with the publication of the Locust Fork News-Journal. In 2014, Wilson developed and launched the New American Journal as a national news site from Washington, D.C. I do not know Glynn personally, but he reached out to me in July 2006 and again in February 2016 to hustle money from me for both of these financially struggling media ventures. I declined his requests for money on each occasion. On March 10, 2019, Wilson wrote a scathing article about my business dealings titled, “ The Cautionary Tale of Donald Watkins and the Icarus Complex.” This article represents a radical departure from the truth about me and my business dealings. For example, Wilson claims Voter News Network, which was an Internet-based news service I founded in 2001 for independent voters, took in millions of dollars which I used for my personal benefit. In truth, this entity never sought or received any money for publishing news. However, it did award 32 college scholarships to deserving high school students, which I funded out of my own pocket. Wilson also says I am “clearly a little unhinged, making one bad investment after another, a children’s book company, an airline, at one point entering into an agreement with the government of Namibia to mine and sell uranium.” For starters, I have never had a children’s book business. I did operate The Children’s Bank for several years. This entity provided seed funding ranging from $5,000 to $20,000 to deserving young entrepreneurs 16-years old and younger. This venture was a huge success for the recipients of its loans/grants. Next, the airline Wilson referenced was named TradeWinds Airlines. It was purchased by me in 2008. Wilson conveniently leaves out two critical facts about this transaction. First, I secured a February 15, 2008 offer letter from Federal Express to fly its cargo between the U.S. and the Caribbean on TradeWinds’ cargo jets. Second, two Detroit pension funds provided the business loan used for this transaction. Shortly after the TradeWinds purchase transaction was closed, several key trustees pressured me to pay them kickbacks for their support of the deal. I refused to do so. As a result, the pension funds manufactured events of "default" and prematurely called the loan. I voluntarily reported the trustees' kickback requests to a federal grand jury. These individuals, including the general counsel of the pension funds, were eventually indicted, tried, and convicted on unrelated bribery charges. I lost the airline to public corruption but I preserved my integrity in business in the process. Wilson left all of this pertinent information out of his article. Next, Wilson discussed an energy services company I formed in 2011. On March 27, 2012, this company was awarded a uranium concession by Epangelo Mining Company (Pty) Ltd., which is the Republic of Namibia’s national mining company. The Namibian government lifted a national moratorium on uranium concessions for nuclear fuels so that my company could compete for this concession against Iran’s state-owned Iranian Foreign Investment Company and others. My company worked closely with the U.S. State Department to make sure that we had the best chance of winning this uranium concession and keeping this strategic asset out of the hands of the Iranians, who were desperately trying to develop a nuclear weapons program at the time. Two months later, my energy services company won a concession from the Namibian government for an offshore oil block. In October 2015, independent and highly qualified geotechnical oil and gas experts concluded their data interpretation on the 2D seismic geotechnical work program for the company’s oil block. A report authored by a world-class, Texas-based geophysics firm confirmed the presence of 522 million barrels of oil and 583 billion cubic feet of carbane methane gas within our oil block. In July 2018, we renewed our oil block license for another two years. Despite these remarkable achievements for an Alabama-based business, Wilson cites this Namibian business venture as evidence of a “bad investment.” Wilson, Whitmire View My Businesses in a Negative Light Like Kyle Whitmire, Glynn Wilson views my businesses in a negative light. In contrast, respected European and African media outlets view them in a positive light. For example, on January 16, 2015, Upstream magazine featured an article about the completion of our company’s 2D geotechnical work program for its Namibian oil block. Upstream is a UK-based trade magazine for subscribers in the global oil and gas industry. Nobody in the industry thought our small company could get this expensive 2D seismic work done without outside financing, but we proved them wrong. Our energy services company is now preparing for its 3D stage of petroleum development activities, followed by the drilling of test wells. We are the only private, African/African-American-owned oil company that is developing a confirmed “unrisked” oil resource in the Walvis Basin. Upstream called us a “minnow.” Yet, we are working in the Basin alongside Exxon Mobile, French-based oil conglomerates Total and Maurel Prom, Madrid-based Repsol, and other well-known publicly traded international oil companies. Glynn Wilson’s articled also criticized my leadership as CEO of Masada Resource Group. Masada is a recognized global leader in the waste-to-energy industry. In 2015, Masada was one of the recipients of the Governor’s Trade Excellence Award, which recognizes Alabama companies for excellence in exporting goods or services. In 2012, Masada executed a Polyfuels licensing and distribution deal with Sustainable Technologies & Environmental Projects Pvt. Ltd. (“STEPS”) in Mumbai, India. This deal enabled Masada to beat out the Birmingham-based Drummond Company and win the Alabama International Business Alliance's 2012 International Deal of the Year (Large Deal Category) Award. Masada’s waste-to-energy work in Sub-Saharan Africa was featured in the July 2014 edition of the London-based International Finance and Legal Review, a prestigious subscription publication for European and African business leaders, and in a February 9, 2012 guest appearance on CNBC for Africa. Yet, Glynn Wilson, Kyle Whitmire, and other U.S. journalists of their ilk tend to omit these pertinent facts because outstanding business achievements of this kind undermine the negative racial stereotypes they spew on a regular basis. Wilson says I am a “taker, not a giver.” Yet, he failed to mention in his article that I have never taken a dime of the $7,500 per month salary (per market location in 47 international markets) that Masada authorized for the CEO position prior to my assumption of the job 13 years ago. Furthermore, my real estate company has never taken a penny of the $17,000 a month in office rent that Masada was obligated to pay me on a 10-year office lease signed by my predecessor. My deferral of this money (a) allowed Masada to survive the Great Recession of 2008 that tanked over 100 of our global competitors and (b) facilitated the company’s growth as a global leader. Like Kyle Whitmire, Glynn Wilson wants to commercialize my life story in a book deal for his personal financial benefit. Wilson's article demonstrates that it is far easier for me to succeed in the global energy marketplace than it is for me to conquer negative racial stereotypes at home. Maybe Glynn Wilson and Kyle Whitmire can team up with each other and co-author a bestseller titled, “The Donald Watkins Story: Hopelessly Trapped in Negative Racial Stereotypes in the Deep South.” When I finish climbing the mountain of life, I will tell my own story in my own words. PHOTO: Glynn Wilson is trying to commercialize my life story in a book deal for his personal financial benefit.
- They Tried to Jail George Wallace, Gerald Wallace
By Donald V. Watkins ©Copyrighted and Published on June 12, 2019 I received a flurry of calls this morning in response to my article yesterday about Alabama Power Company’s shabby treatment of its Black Belt and rural retail customers. This treatment, which centers arounds Alabama Power’s plan to close 40 business offices in Black Belt counties and rural communities in order to reduce operational expenses, is described in detail in my article. I thought Alabama Power would be appreciative that I brought a very solvable customer service problem to its immediate attention. I was wrong. Within hours after yesterday’s article was published, Alabama Power’s governmental affairs executives began calling Perry County officials and telling them to ignore the facts presented in my article about the company’s impressive financial condition, even though these facts came directly from the company’s filings with regulatory agencies, Wall Street institutions, and utility industry research organizations. They called me a “blogger,” even though I am a dues paying member of the Society of Professional Journalists and I have an online readership of more than 20,000 people. Alabama Power reminded these public officials that I was convicted in March on hotly contested federal criminal charges. This news event was reported in a March 9, 2019 article titled, “We Feel Your Love.” I will be sentenced in this case on July 16, 2019, after which I will file an immediate notice of appeal and ask the Court for permission to remain free on bond during my appeal like former Alabama House Speaker Mike Hubbard. I have been informed on good authority that Alabama Power Company operatives are looking for ways to get my bond revoked. If Alabama Power is successful in this regard, a revocation of my bond would land me in jail immediately and would prevent me from publishing future investigative articles about the company. Alabama Power views me as its lone credible media critic in Alabama. The utility giant neutered other media organizations in Alabama years ago through a combination of advertising dollars, financial contributions from its non-profit foundation, event sponsorships, and consulting fees for seminar participants affiliated with media entities. Now, these media outlets only report “Happy News” about Alabama Power and its business operations. Jailing Critics to Silence their Voices This is not the first time Alabama Power has tried to jail its critics. The company tried to do the same thing with Governor George Wallace and his brother, Gerald Wallace, in 1972. Starting in his second term of office in 1971, Wallace took direct aim at Alabama Power and its frequent fights with the Alabama Public Service Commission over rate increases. Wallace hired lawyers to oppose Alabama Power’s exorbitant rate increases, one of which was 18%. Alabama Power thought that jailing Wallace was its best option. As the 1972 presidential election approached, Alabama Power Company and other power-brokers were able to persuade President Richard Nixon to have George and Gerald Wallace investigated by the U.S. Department of Justice on federal charges that they rigged state bidding procedures, solicited and received illegal campaign contributions, and accepted kickbacks. Nixon went along with the scheme because he thought Wallace’s candidacy as an independent party nominee would take votes away from his re-election campaign. The Internal Revenue Service expanded the criminal investigation to include Wallace advisor Seymore Trammell. After Governor Wallace announced that he might seek the Democratic Party nomination in 1972, rather than run as a presidential candidate on the American Independent Party ticket (as he did in 1968), the Justice Department dropped its investigation of the Wallaces. However, Seymore Trammell was eventually charged, convicted and jailed. Based upon Alabama Power’s mistreatment of the company's ratepayers and the nefarious scheme with the Justice Department, Governor Wallace never trusted the company. Wallace fought Alabama Power Company and its requested rate increases for more than a decade in office. He was determined to protect poor people, middle-class consumers, senior citizens on a fixed income, and small business owners from Alabama Power’s outrageous rate increase requests. For reasons that are hard to understand, Alabama Power Company views any public attention on its monopoly status and its self-determined rate adjustments as an “attack” on the company. As Governor Wallace learned in 1972, no one is allowed to “attack” Alabama Power by standing up for ratepayers, unless he/she is prepared to face harsh adverse consequences. Our Watchdogs are not Barking As I pointed out in yesterday’s article, Perry County Commissioner Albert Turner Jr. appears to be the only public official in Alabama who is demanding that Alabama Power treat its "captive" customers in Black Belt counties and rural communities as well as it treats the company's executives and its biggest customers. After all, ratepayers in these communities are paying for a host of executive perks, including (a) extravagant game-day events at college football games in Tuscaloosa and Auburn; (b) corporate jets that fly executives and dignitaries to and from exotic ports of call, (c) event packages to (I) the Masters golf tournament in Augusta, Georgia, (ii) national championship football games, (iii) “March Madness” basketball games around the nation, (iv) NFL Super Bowls, and (v) ritzy international air shows in Paris and London. The list of Alabama Power's over-the-top corporate perks that are paid for by ratepayers is endless. The silence of Governor Kay Ivey, the Public Service Commission members, state legislators, county commissioners, and other public officials regarding Alabama Power’s shabby treatment of its customers in the black Belt counties and in rural communities shows the degree of control and dominion Alabama Power exerts over these neutered officeholders. The company's endless supply of campaign cash, its strategic awards of non-profit grants, its facilitation of jobs and contracts for the friends, girlfriends, boyfriends, wives, husbands, mistresses, lovers, and relatives of state legislators, and its monetary inducements for mainstream media organizations have drowned out any thoughts of public service that these officials might have been inclined to render on behalf of their constituents. This silence is one of the reasons why Alabama Power was able to overcharge its customers by $146 million, as of November 2015. In closing, remember this: The loud silence of public officials who serve in "watchdog" roles is usually the first sign that the general public is in deep trouble. When only one of the several hundred public "watchdogs" in Alabama is barking about Alabama Power’s shabby treatment of its ratepayers in Black Belt counties and rural communities, this means the other “watchdogs” have abandoned the public interest in favor of their undisclosed private interests. PHOTO: Former Alabama Governor George C. Wallace was the public’s best “watchdog” over Alabama Power Company. Wallace zealously protected poor people, middle-class consumers, senior citizens on a fixed income, and small business owners from Alabama Power’s outrageous rate increase requests.











