Search Results
Search this site
1309 results found with an empty search
- Gang Warfare Caused Saturday Night Massacre in Five Points South
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on September 29, 2024 An Editorial Opinion Birmingham, Alabama is caught up in the deadly grip of gang violence. Presently, two heavily armed drug trafficking street gangs are fighting for control of Birmingham’s revitalized, predominantly white Southside and the area surrounding the University of Alabama at Birmingham. This territory is considered a “honey pot” for competing drug trafficking gangs in Birmingham. In 2006, the city closed its South precinct station in the Highland Avenue area. A few years later, the city closed its Five Points South police sub-station, which was directly across the street from where the Saturday Night Massacre occurred a week ago. Today, Birmingham’s Southside is virtually unprotected, thanks to a police force that employs only 400 of the 912 sworn officers needed to provide adequate public safety within Birmingham’s 151 square miles of territory. Lame-duck President Joe Biden, Vice President Kamala Harris, and Birmingham Mayor Randal Woodfin met in Washington last week to announce a presidential executive order that restricts machinegun conversion devices and un-serialized, 3D-printed firearms. This presidential initiative will NOT make a dent in Birmingham’s gang-related homicides, mass shootings, and street massacres. Birmingham’s problem is NOT complicated: The city lacks the police officers needed to protect its residents. The police department is understaffed by 56% (or 512 officers) . Police patrols within the city's 99 neighborhoods and communitiesare are virtually non-existent. Presently, rival gangs are putting more heavily armed thugs on the streets of Birmingham than Mayor Woodfin provides in sworn police officers. What is worse, these gang members are willing to give up blood in order to get blood from rival gang members. Because the city's police force is so severely understaffed, rival gangs rule the streets of Birmingham and engage in murder, mass shootings, and massacres at-will. Mayor Woodfin has no plan of action to restore the city's police force to 912 sworn officers . Instead, salary money that is earmarked in the annual city budget for the unfilled police positions is routinely redirected by Woodfin to pet projects for the “over-the-mountain” crowd and his political friends who provide vendor services without deliverables. In addition to the Saturday Night Massacre in Five Points South a week ago, the bodies of homicide victims continue to pile up daily on the streets of Birmingham. Gang warfare in Birmingham is also killing residential and commercial property values in the city and surrounding suburbs. Tren de Aragua is Here Tren de Aragua , a powerful transnational criminal gang that originated in a Venezuela prison, has made its way to Birmingham, Alabama. This gang is much more violent than the Bloods, Crips, MS-13, and Disciples who ruled the streets of Birmingham during the last seven years. They are wreaking havoc in the city. Having overrun Birmingham's streets with ease, the very gangs that glorify cop-killing and engage in murder as a right of passage for gang initiation are now eying Birmingham’s Southside, Lakeview nightlife district, and suburban communities as fertile territory for expanding their criminal enterprises. These gangs view Birmingham’s dwindling law enforcement response to their increasingly violent drug dealing, robberies, carjacking, theft-rings, murders, drive-by shootings, and massacres as weak, timid, and reactive. Unfortunately for Birmingham residents, they are right. Law enforcement personnel, state and federal prosecutors, and many state and federal judges in the Birmingham-metro area are afraid of these increasingly violent street gangs. The gang that was targeted and hit in the Five Points South Saturday Night Massacre is already planning its retaliation. The only question is when, where, and how many innocent victims will be killed during this retaliatory strike. Mayoral press conferences in Birmingham, White House visits, and slick PR gimmicks on social media will not make Birmigham safe. More police boots on the ground will.
- Clarence Thomas: A "Pay-To-Play" Scheme at the U.S. Supreme Court?
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on April 7, 2022 An Editorial Opinion Clarence Thomas has been a huge embarrassment on the U.S. Supreme Court for more than 31 years. President George H.W. Bush nominated Thomas to replace Justice Thurgood Marshall, the Supreme Court's first African-American justice. Prior to his appointment to the nation's highest court, Justice Marshall had achieved an outstanding record as a civil rights attorney. He had also argued several landmark cases before the Court, including Brown v. Board of Education, the 1954 case that ended legally enforced racial segregation in public schools. Prior to joining the Supreme Court, Clarence Thomas had no significant achievements in the field of law beyond graduating from law school and serving in several patronage jobs in Washington government agencies that were reserved for black Republican political hustlers and their home-bred "Uncle Toms." Thomas is widely regarded in the nation's African-American community as the ungrateful beneficiary of an endless series of affirmative action initiatives, starting with his admission to law school and ending with his appointment to the Supreme Court bench. Throughout his lackluster legal and judicial career, Clarence Thomas, who is weak on intellectual acumen, has prided himself on his outstanding ability to serve as an ingratiating, subservient "bellhop" for far right-wing conservative groups in America. Thomas has gleefully assumed the mantle as the nation's premier "Uncle Tom." Legal scholars have rated Clarence Thomas as one of the four worse Justices in the history of the Supreme Court. He joins the company of former Chief Justice Roger B. Taney, who authored the famous 1857 ruling in the Dred Scott case holding that black Americans, whether freed or slaves, had no rights that white men were bound to respect. Clarence Thomas has taken the Dred Scott ruling to heart. In researching this article, I did not find a single case in which Clarence Thomas ruled in favor of a black plaintiff in a civil rights or voting rights case during his 31 years on the Supreme Court. What is worse, Clarence Thomas has voted to impose the death penalty on black defendants in criminal cases where all eight of the white justices on the Court (progressives and conservative alike) ruled that intentional prosecutorial misconduct and overt racial bias tainted the legal proceedings in the trial court. Does Clarence Thomas Sell His Vote on the Supreme Court? Clarence Thomas is in the news, again. Recent media reports have surfaced that call into question Thomas' misconduct as a Supreme Court justice. Apparently, various conservative advocacy groups with an interest in cases pending before the Supreme Court have hired Thomas' wife, Virginia, to serve as a "consultant" in these cases. Virginia Thomas worked behind the scenes to achieve the desired outcome in these cases, and she was paid handsomely for her work. Clarence Thomas never disclosed this glaring conflict of interest, and he never recused himself from these cases. It is unclear how much of the money that was paid to Virginia Thomas in these cases found its way into Clarence Thomas' pocket. What we know for sure is this: The money found its way into the Thomas's household. A review of the cases tainted by this highly suspect arrangement reveals that Clarence Thomas always voted with the side that lined Virginia Thomas' pocket. At its core, this shady financial arrangement is the judicial version of a "pay-to-play" scheme at the U.S. Supreme Court, and it happened on multiple occasions. It is unethical judicial conduct that is criminal in nature. Today, nobody is policing this ongoing and unsavory "pay-to-play" scheme where Virginia Thomas rakes in the money for the cases of interest to the couple, while Clarence Thomas: (a) participates in judicial conferences on these case, (b) lobbies fellow justices for the votes needed to achieve the desired outcome, and (c) casts his vote as directed by Virginia. Virginia Thomas is Clarence Thomas' Publicly Acknowledged "Best Friend" and "Other Leg" In describing his loving relationship with Virginia Thomas, Clarence Thomas uses an apropos analogy that a "one-legged man cannot run." He openly concedes that Virginia Thomas is his "other leg" and "best friend," and this is why he has been so successful (in his mind) as a Supreme Court justice. It is clear that Clarence Thomas loves his wife dearly and that she is the driving force in his life. Clarence Thomas strives to implement Virginia's right-wing activist political agenda from his seat on the Supreme Court. The two legs in this interracial marriage are running hard and fast for far right-wing conservatives in the "political thicket" and on the federal bench. It is equally clear that Virginia Thomas controls Clarence Thomas' vote on the Supreme Court. Virginia's power over Clarence Thomas is derived from (a) his undying love for his wife and (b) his engrained, life-long, racial inferiority complex, which Clarence Thomas tries to mask under the cloak of conservative jurisprudence. The spousal love between Clarence and Virginia Thomas is a beautiful thing. However, Clarence Thomas' growing pattern and practice of selling his vote on the Supreme Court is not. Does Clarence Thomas' "Uncle Tom" Status Elevate Him Above the Law? Clarence Thomas' solid credentials as an "Uncle Tom" appear to elevate him above the nation's criminal laws and above any obligation to comply with judicial ethics. If Clarence Thomas had not been the greatest living "Uncle Tom" in America today, he would have already been indicted, tried, convicted, and sentenced to federal prison for his part in the couple's ongoing "pay-to-play" scheme. It is obvious that Clarence Thomas has no personal integrity, or regard for judicial ethics, or appreciation for the integrity of the Supreme Court. Thomas is a longtime political hustler who has been highly successfully in hustling white right-wing conservatives in Washington for personal gain. This is how and why Thomas became a Supreme Court justice 31 years ago. Someone will have to clean up Clarence Thomas' public corruption and ethical mess. Remarkably, Thomas has single-handedly soiled the Supreme Court's stellar reputation for independence, integrity, and judicial ethics, for the first time ever. In the process, Clarence Thomas has also defecated on judicial ethics and the rule of law. The stench from Clarence and Virginia's unlawful "pay-to-play" scheme is unbearable. Epilogue The irony of Clarence Thomas' twisted world of far-right conservative politics is this: Thomas claims to be an "originalist" who interprets the U.S. Constitution as it was originally written more than 250 years ago by the Founding Fathers, all of whom were rich white men. Some of these men were notorious slave owners and physical abusers of women of all colors. There is no express right in the Constitution that gives a black man the right to marry a white woman. In fact, blacks and women of all colors had no rights in the original version of the Constitution. Blacks came within the ambit of the Constitution's protections in 1865, 1866, and 1868. Women came within its ambit in 1922. Interracial marriages between blacks and whites like the one Clarence and Virginia enjoy were unlawful and outright criminal in this country until 1967. Fortunately, a forward-looking U.S. Supreme Court struck down all prohibitions on interracial marriages in the case of Loving v. Virginia (1967), thereby freeing Clarence Thomas to bask in the warm glow of Virginia Thomas' love. Under Clarence Thomas' expressed "originalist" judicial philosophy, the Loving v. Virginia case, which benefitted the Thomases personally, was incorrectly decided because it rests on the principle of judicial activism. Clarence Thomas and many southern conservatives also hold the same "originalist" judicial view about Brown v. Board of Education. Obviously, there is nothing in the Constitution, or its amendments, that says black students have a constitutional right to attend the same public school with white students and sit in the same classrooms with them. In Plessy v. Ferguson (1896), the Supreme Court held that blacks did not enjoy a Constitutional right to end racial segregation in public schools and public accommodations. In 1954, Brown v. Board of Education overruled Plessy v. Ferguson. Adhering to his "originalist" philosophy and consistent with his demonstrated disdain for protecting the civil and constitutional rights of black Americans, Clarence Thomas would have voted with the majority of justices in the Plessy v. Ferguson case. Likewise, in Clarence Thomas' "originalist" view, the right of blacks (and other racial minorities) to vote, hold office, and otherwise participate in the electoral process does not exist, as was the case from 1619 to 1865, and is unenforceable under the Fifteenth Amendment, as was the case during the racially oppressive Jim Crow era from 1877 to 1965. In 2013, Clarence Thomas proudly joined a 5-4 majority of justices on the Supreme Court who gutted the 1965 Voting Rights Act and ushered in a renaissance period of disenfranchisement for black and brown Americans that continues to the present. In the end, Clarence and Virginia Thomas have revealed who and what Clarence Thomas really is -- a run-of-the mill crook with solid and trusted "Uncle Tom" credentials who hustled his way to a seat on the U.S. Supreme Court. Far right-wing conservatives created this embarrassing "pay-to-play" tar-baby. In the eyes of an increasingly frustrated public, Clarence Thomas has undermined the independence of the U.S. Supreme Court and stained its stature, forever. All articles are shared on Facebook and Twitter. If you would like to follow Donald Watkins, please click on these links and hit the follow button: https://www.facebook.com/donald.v.watkins https://twitter.com/donaldvwatkins
- DOJ: Bribery is Okay for Clarence Thomas, But Criminal for NYC Mayor Eric Adams
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on September 28, 2024 An Editorial Opinion This week, the Biden/Harris Department of Justice (DOJ) charged New York City Mayor Eric Adams with bribery and fraud offenses as part of a "long-running" scheme that has upended politics in America's largest city. Adams is alleged to have accepted illegal gifts worth over $123,000 from Turkish citizens and at least one government official, which he did not disclose on his annual ethics forms. In exchange, Turkish officials are alleged to have sought favors from the mayor, including help skirting safety regulations to open a consulate in New York, according to prosecutors. In Washington, Justice Clarence Thomas has been selling his vote on the U.S. Supreme Court for 32 years. In the last 20 years, alone, Thomas received over $4,000,000 in undisclosed "gifts" for himself, his wife, his mother, and his adopted son from billionaire “friend” Harlan Crowe. It is no coincidence that Crowe is closely tied to the litigants who benefitted from Thomas's vote on the Court. The "gifts" to Thomas, which were undisclosed at the time of the "gifting" but unearth through investigative reporting over the last three years, have made Thomas a proud and arrogant multimillionaire. Biden/Harris-appointed prosecutors at the DOJ have given Clarence Thomas a prosecutorial "pass" on his proven bribery and fraud conduct . Yet, they are prosecuting Adams over $123,000 in alleged bribery and fraud conduct. This is a classic example of weak political leadership and selective prosecution . The White House and Vice President Kamala Harris (who touts her credentials as a former prosecutor) must explain, right now , why Clarence Thomas is immune from criminal prosecution, but Eric Adams is not. In America, we cannot have two vastly different standards of justice for bribery and fraud offenses involving public officials.
- What Daily Life Looks Like for "Diddy" in the “Hole”
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on September 22, 2024 An Editorial Opinion Sean “Diddy” Combs is in the “Hole” at the federal detention center in Brooklyn, New York. Here is what daily life looks like for Diddy in detention: Diddy is not wearing his designer clothes and eyeglasses. He is wearing a prison uniform and a pair of nasty, used prison-issued underwear. Diddy can change underwear following each one of the three showers he is allowed to take per week. Diddy is handcuffed whenever he is taken to the shower. He is escorted to the shower by two guards, each one of whom must hold one of his arms. The face clothe and towel provided to Diddy are just as nasty and unsanitary as his prison underwear. His shower stall is a small, filthy, unsanitary coffin-like cell with a nozzle for the water. He cannot adjust the water’s temperature. The toilet in Diddy’s cell is metal and it can only be flushed from the outside by a guard. Until his toilet is flushed, Diddy must endure the smell of his urine and bowel excrement. Despite bullshit presidential campaign slogans about “ America First ,” the Bob Barker Company in Fuquay-Varina, North Carolina uses its 29-year business monopoly with the Federal Bureau of Prisons (BOP) to supply all 122 federal prisons, detention centers, and transfer facilities with the low-quality, high-price, foreign-manufactured goods that Diddy uses in the "Hole" every day. These items include toothpaste, toothbrushes, razors, shaving gel, body wash, soap, deodorant, handwash, shampoo, conditioner, grooming products, combs, brushes, nail clippers, lotion, hand sanitizers, toilet paper, over-the-counter medicines, inmate uniforms, underwear, socks, shoes, sheets, blankets, towels, wash clothes, writing paper, pencils, mailing envelopes, and a host of other foreign-made products on the commissary list. The sacred monopoly contract between the BOP and the Bob Barker Company cries out for a federal criminal investigation. Yet, nobody will touch it. Diddy’s family and friends cannot call him on the phone. Diddy may only call individuals who are on his list of approved contacts. Because Diddy did not have advanced warning of his arrest, he probably did not memorize the phone numbers of the family and friends he wants to call. Diddy may write family members, if he has their mailing addresses and stamps. They may write him, but their correspondence must conform to a litany of strict BOP rules governing incoming inmate mail or it is rejected. The BOP falls under the supervisory jurisdiction of the U.S. Attorney General. No Attorney General since Janet Reno has had the “balls” to reform the federal prison system. Fans of former Attorney General Eric Holder , the first Black Attorney General, should know that he did absolutely nothing to improve the nasty, filthy, and overcrowded conditions of the federal prison system that now houses Diddy. Diddy's commissary pledges are extremely limited and will not begin until an inmate account has been set up for him, which could take weeks. If Diddy becomes mentally unstable during his stay in the "Hole," detention facility officials will simply strap him down on an evaluated slab and assign inmate orderlies to sit outside his cell door to watch him all day and night through the small window in his cell door. They will use force to feed Diddy, if necessary. BOP officials will disrespect Diddy’s lawyer because most lawyers do not raise hell with trial judges about the horrific conditions their clients experience in federal detention centers and prisons. My Experience in the “Hole” was Somewhat Different from Diddy’s Because I was Prepared for It. The BOP placed me in the filthy, rat-infested, black-mold-spewing, dirty drinking water "Hole" at three of its facilities from May 2020 to March 2021 and January and February 2022 . Their stated goal was to stop me from (a) writing and publishing my articles on corruption within the federal criminal justice system and (b) helping inmates win their freedom. I never stopped writing and publishing these articles. BOP officials let me out of the "Hole" only AFTER senior management officials determined that I could not be "broken." Each time I was released back into the general prison population, I was applauded by inmates and prison guards alike. There were three reasons why I was able to survive my time in the "Hole.” First, I had survived the longest and loneliest 3 years of my life when I desegregated the University of Alabama's law school from 1970 to 1973. At the time, the university was infested with hardcore racists who exhibited their non-stop racism to those of us who were desegregating the law school. My challenging experience at the law school gave me the inner strength I needed to survive 3 years of the harshest treatment anyone could mete out to me anywhere. Second, in 2012, I visited the tiny cell where Nelson Mandela spent 18 of his 27 years in prison in the “Hole.” Mandela slept on a thin mat on a concrete floor and used a bucket for a toilet. Mandela survived this inhumane treatment and became president of South Africa. The memory of my visit to Mandela’s cell enhanced my inner strength throughout my ordeal in the "Hole." Third, I stayed very busy in the “Hole” writing dozens of articles for publication on my Internet platforms, including “ The Miracle at USP Atlanta . ” The officers who guarded me made sure these articles were mailed out to my editor for publication. I also handled the legal work that freed over a dozen prisoners from the “Hole” and dozens more from the prisons that housed me. The last of 48 inmates I freed during my three years of captivity as a federal prisoner is Alphonso Woodley, Sr. , a former inmate at the Federal Prison Camp at La Tuna, Texas who was subsequently transferred to a federal prison in Kansas. On June 30, 2024, Forbes Magazine profiled Alphonso Woodley’s landmark case. The BOP miscalculated Woodley's release date and held him in captivity beyond his release date . The Forbes article explains how and why a brave federal judge in Kansas ruled in Woodley's favor. Woodley’s case has cleared the way for the release of thousands of wrongfully detained federal inmates. This level of activism from the “Hole” showed prison officials that they NEVER had power over my mind; they only had custody of my body. “Freedom” is a state of mind. It is the absence of fear. I was NEVER in the prison of fear. All of my heroes in the international civil and human rights movement were imprisoned for far longer periods of time than me. Some of them were tortured in prison. Some were assassinated after they were released from jail. Imprisonment in the “Hole” is survivable when your mind is strong and your spirit is free.
- The Prison of Fear
By: Donald V. Watkins © Copyrighted and Published on December 1, 2019. The 1991 Nobel Peace Prize winner, Aung San Suu Kyi, is a human rights activist in Myanmar (formerly known as Burma). She survived detention, house arrest, and attacks on her life after she joined her country's political resistance in 1988 to fight military rule in Myanmar. The Nobel Prize made her the world's most prominent dissident at the time. "The only real prison is fear," Suu Kyi famously wrote, "and the only real freedom is freedom from fear." No truer words have been spoken. Suu Kyi never feared prison. We all know about dissidents who have been persecuted and jailed. The most famous dissident of all time was Jesus Christ. He was accused of parading without a permit, practicing medicine without a license, making wine without a permit, obstructing the stoning death of an adulterer, trespassing on synagogue property, destruction of gaming property, walking on water without permission, and treason against the recognized Jewish religious hierarchy. Jesus was tried, flogged, and crucified for these crimes. Yet, Jesus never feared imprisonment. Nelson Mandela was targeted by South Africa's all-white government in the early 1960s and charged with treason and other felonious crimes. In 1964, Mandela was sentenced to life imprisonment at the notorious Robben Island prison. Mandela's only real crime was his life-long crusade to secure human and civil rights for black South Africans. After he was freed from prison in 1990, Mandela was awarded the Nobel Peace prize in 1993 (as well as the US Presidential Medal of Freedom and various other awards). He quickly went on to become the first black President of South Africa in 1994. Mandela never feared imprisonment. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., led America's civil rights movement of the 1950s and 60s. Like Aung San Suu Kyi and Nelson Mandela, Dr. King was also the winner of a Nobel Peace prize for his non-violent protest during the civil rights movement. Dr. King was hated and vilified by the FBI in his leadership role. The FBI proclaimed King as the "most dangerous Negro in America" because of his ability to mobilize the masses of black Americans. Dr. King was assassinated in 1968. Dr. King was arrested on trumped up criminal charges countless times during the civil rights movement, often at the behest of federal agents. Yet, Dr. King never feared imprisonment. Too many national leaders today fear persecution and imprisonment by the forces that oppose human and civil rights for the unprotected classes in our society. This fear controls everything they say and do. It makes them docile, complacent, and self-centered about the important things that matter in life. There will always be those among us who occupy what the Bible calls the "Pharaoh" position in our lives. They will always sit high, but look low. They will always persecute and punish dissidents in the name of administering law and order. These "Pharaohs" have successfully instilled a fear of imprisonment in modern-day dissidents. This is particularly true in the black community where imprisonment has become the "Pharaoh's" politically palatable substitute for the government's acknowledged and documented 1970 national plan to intern black dissidents in concentration camps around the U.S. Implementation of the government's modified internment plan works as follows: The federal government's criminal justice system targets black dissidents; it accuses them of trumped up crimes; it railroads them in federal courts; and it imprisons them, all while telling the white community these dissidents are ordinary criminals. This internment program has been very effective. It is one of the reasons blacks constitute 37.5% of all inmates in federal prisons, while accounting for only 13% of the U.S. population. Sadly, at the time of his death in 1968, 75% of white Americans disliked Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. The FBI had successfully demonized Dr. King to white America by portraying him as a "thug", a "filthy animal” and an “evil, abnormal beast". Today, Dr. King is the only non-U.S. President who has a National Memorial dedicated to his life's work on the National Mall in Washington. Ironically, Dr. King never had the opportunity to smell the roses while he was alive. The "Pharaohs" of his time made sure of that. Freedom is a state of mind. The only real prison is fear and too many Americans are serving a life sentence in that prison.
- What Sean Combs Should Know About Winning a Criminal Case Where Losing is Not an Acceptable Option
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on October 15, 2013 (via Facebook); Updated and Republished on February 27, 2024; Updated on September 19, 2024 An Editorial Opinion Long before Sean "Diddy" Comb’s indictment was unsealed in a New York federal court on Tuesday, a lot of readers had asked me to describe the strategy for winning high-profile criminal cases where losing is NOT an acceptable option. Here was my strategy for winning such cases when I actively practiced law: These difficult cases require a different attitude and a non-traditional roadmap to victory. Representing a public scoundrel or celebrity outcast forces the legal advocate to sail against the prevailing winds to reach safe passage and freedom for the accused. The legal knowledge, skills and abilities for this journey are not found in law books and are not taught in law schools. They come solely from a lawyer’s baptism under fire in the courtroom. The journey to freedom begins by comprehending the full dynamics of the forces being leveraged against the accused. These forces combine to form a complex blend of political, social, and media spin. This blend, together with the ambitious personal agendas of prosecutors and judges, prejudicially stacks the deck against the outcast defendant. Prosecutors and judges alike seem to feel obligated to eagerly and frequently dispense a steady stream of lessons to this class of defendants. Most criminal defense lawyers are merely technicians, not strategists. You cannot win a high-profile criminal case without a strategist on your defense team. There is no exception to this rule. A strategist, who may or may not be a lawyer, focuses solely on identifying those human factors necessary to influence twelve ordinary citizens sitting as trial jurors to allow an accused stranger to walk out of the courtroom as a free man or woman, no matter what the prevailing public opinion is, nor how poisonous the atmosphere in the courtroom may be. Jurors are human beings. They make their ultimate decision based on what seems to be fair and makes common sense to them. Human emotion and behavior always have a more lasting impact on jurors than courtroom evidence or jury instructions. A Practical Guide for Winning High-Profile Criminal Cases Where Losing is NOT an Acceptable Option Favorably impacting human emotion and behavior begins in the court of public opinion. The criminal process and media coverage typically demonize the high-profile defendant. This must be quickly neutralized through a series of steps. Netflix presented an abbreviated version of my strategy for winning a high-profile criminal case where losing is not an acceptable option in a May 11, 2020 documentary series titled, " Trial by Media ," Episode No. 4 " King Richard ." Here is the full strategy. First, the accused must be made available and accessible to the media for frank talks about the case. In Diddy's case, his communications with the media must be in writing and must be plentiful. Diddy's pretrial detention limits his ability to communicate with the outside world. Despite this limitation, Diddy can write and mail letters to various media organizations five days per week. He should do so. Testifying in the court of public opinion is much easier than testifying in the court of law. While the accused may not win complete vindication in the media, he/she can negate much of the ill-will generated in the sea of hate. This is the only forum available to the accused where he/she can openly humanize himself/ herself. This forum is also the first place where his/her advocate can effectively undermine the government’s theory of the case, attack the government witnesses, and criticize prosecutors, law enforcement officials, and others working in concert with them. Prosecutors and judges are very limited in what they can say and do in the court of public opinion. There are no evidentiary or procedural rules in the court of public opinion. This works to the benefit of the accused. In this court, the outcast has the most advantages. He/she must use them or risk losing them. Second, victory for the outcast defendant only comes when the defense puts the government under the glaring light of a public microscope. The government will always look worse under the microscope than any outcast defendant. Americans know that their government will mislead them, lie to them, abuse its power, act in the political interests of high-ranking political officials, and mistreat ordinary citizens. Officials often bend the rules and frequently cheat to win in high-profile cases. Exposing this nasty government underbelly will propel the accused along the long road to victory. Third, defense counsel must exploit the obvious targets of opportunity in the government’s case. For example, prosecutors must cut disgusting deals with unsavory characters. These people eventually become cooperating government witnesses. In Diddy's case, some of them are unindicted co-defendants. The question is never whether these witnesses are lying, but how many lies they have told and to whom they have told them. Openly count the lies in front of the trial jury. I always started the count with the question, “Have you ever lied to anybody about anything?” The answer is always, “Yes." It is easy to get this type of witness to admit to a pattern and practice of lying to a variety of people about material aspects of the case on hundreds of occasions (which I would always depicted and count on a flip chart in front of the jury). Once the witness establishes his/her solid credentials as an accomplished liar, nothing else they have to say matters. Fourth, contrary to what they say publicly, prosecutors always shape their case strategy and evidence to get the man or woman at the top of an organization. The skilled advocate must demonstrate how they target people, not crimes. This demonstration requires more courage than brainpower. Fifth, audio and video evidence will always be more beneficial to the accused than the government. These recordings are always selective and never complete. Simply focus on what is not recorded and why. Incomplete recordings are akin to books with missing pages or chapters. They have little real value to the reader within this context. Sixth, FBI interview techniques are a goldmine for a criminal defendant. Jurors are usually shocked when they learn that the FBI does not tape record its interviews with witnesses. Instead, the FBI relies upon agents to make notes (called “302” statements) that are not shared with the witness at the conclusion of the interview, meaning the witness cannot ensure their accuracy. Over time, the agent’s 302 notes tend to mutate in the government’s favor, especially in cases where there are multiple interviews with the same witness. Seventh, the cozy relationship between prosecutors and trial judges is compounded by their political ties to high-ranking public officials, which ultimately provides enough fertile ground for questioning the integrity of any case when properly developed first in the media. Eighth, the best defense is always a relentless offense . The accused must start this offense as soon as he/she is the target of a criminal investigation. The accused must go public first, fast and hard. He/she must convey his or her side of the story in the court of public opinion. He/she must make the government the enemy by exposing everything he or she knows about the investigation and questioning its legitimacy. Prosecutors have little experience in playing defense in the court of public opinion. Remember, this is a campaign for the accused’s freedom. This campaign is a long and hard process, not a one-time press conference where the defendant’s lawyer simply denies the charges after an indictment is announced. Ninth, the outcast defendant must use the media to define his or her humanity -- it is important that the public to knows the accused on a personal level. Who is the private person? Everybody knows the public persona; after all, PR experts carefully crafted this public image over many years. Define the accused’s personal value system, people skills, circle of family and true friends (who may not be rich and well-known), and acts of kindness (not tax-deductible charity) to ordinary people. Downplay charitable acts and foundation giving for privileged groups like the arts community, opera, symphony, zoo, botanical gardens, and museums. Highlight examples of kindness where money was not the lynchpin for support and generosity. Finally, the accused should spend no time worrying about his/her social or professional redemption. It will not occur, even when he/she is acquitted. The sole focus must be on freedom. It is the only outcome that matters. Epilogue Of course, the successful implementation of my Guide for winning high-profile criminal cases where losing is not an acceptable option depends upon the accused having a trial judge who is NOT on the take or is not otherwise compromised. Today, the scales of justice are rarely balanced. What is more, a growing number of state and federal judges have zero integrity or respect for the law. Many of them are nothing more than “ political whores ” who will gladly railroad an accused person in a “ rigged ” trial for the pure thrill of carrying out a courtroom lynching. That said, many judges will still give an outcast defendant a fair shot at winning his/her case.
- Winning Criminal Cases Where Losing is Not an Acceptable Option
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on October 15, 2013 (via Facebook); Updated on February 27, 2024 An Editorial Opinion Long before Donald Trump’s first criminal indictment in March 2023, a lot of readers asked me to describe the strategy for winning high-profile criminal cases where losing is NOT an acceptable option. Here was my strategy for winning such cases when I actively practiced law: These difficult cases require a different attitude and a non-traditional roadmap to victory. Representing a public scoundrel or celebrity outcast forces the legal advocate to sail against the prevailing winds to reach safe passage and freedom for the accused. The legal knowledge, skills and abilities for this journey are not found in law books and are not taught in law schools. They come solely from a lawyer’s baptism under fire in the courtroom. The journey to freedom begins by comprehending the full dynamics of the forces being leveraged against the accused. These forces combine to form a complex blend of political, social, and media spin. This blend, together with the ambitious personal agendas of prosecutors and judges, prejudicially stacks the deck against the outcast defendant. Prosecutors and judges alike seem to feel obligated to eagerly and frequently dispense a steady stream of lessons to this class of defendants. Most criminal defense lawyers are merely technicians, not strategists. You cannot win a high-profile criminal case without a strategist on your defense team. There is no exception to this rule. A strategist, who may or may not be a lawyer, focuses solely on identifying those human factors necessary to influence twelve ordinary citizens sitting as trial jurors to allow an accused stranger to walk out of the courtroom as a free man or woman, no matter what the prevailing public opinion is, nor how poisonous the atmosphere in the courtroom may be. Jurors are human beings. They make their ultimate decision based on what seems to be fair and makes common sense to them. Human emotion and behavior always have a more lasting impact on jurors than courtroom evidence or jury instructions. A Practical Guide for Winning High-Profile Criminal Cases Where Losing is NOT an Acceptable Option Favorably impacting human emotion and behavior begins in the court of public opinion. The criminal process and media coverage typically demonize the high-profile defendant. This must be quickly neutralized through a series of steps. Netflix presented an abbreviated version of my strategy for winning a high-profile criminal case where losing is not an acceptable option in a May 11, 2020 documentary series titled, " Trial by Media ," Episode No. 4 " King Richard ." Here is the full strategy. First, the accused must be made available and accessible to the media for frank talks about the case. Testifying in the court of public opinion is much easier than testifying in the court of law. While the accused may not win complete vindication in the media, he/she can negate much of the ill-will generated in the sea of hate. This is the only forum available to the accused where he/she can openly humanize himself/ herself. This forum is also the first place where his/her advocate can effectively undermine the government’s theory of the case, attack the government witnesses, and criticize prosecutors, law enforcement officials, and others working in concert with them. Prosecutors and judges are very limited in what they can say and do in the court of public opinion. There are no evidentiary or procedural rules in the court of public opinion. This works to the benefit of the accused. In this court, the outcast has the most advantages. He/she must use them or risk losing them. Second, victory for the outcast defendant only comes when the defense puts the government under the glaring light of a public microscope. The government will always look worse under the microscope than any outcast defendant. Americans know that their government will mislead them, lie to them, abuse its power, act in the political interests of high-ranking political officials, and mistreat ordinary citizens. Officials often bend the rules and frequently cheat to win in high-profile cases. Exposing this nasty government underbelly will propel the accused along the long road to victory. Third, defense counsel must exploit the obvious targets of opportunity in the government’s case. For example, prosecutors must cut disgusting deals with unsavory characters. These people eventually become cooperating government witnesses. The question is never whether these witnesses are lying, but how many lies they have told and to whom they have told them. Openly count the lies in front of the trial jury. I always started the count with the question, “Have you ever lied to anybody about anything?” The answer is always, “Yes." It is easy to get this type of witness to admit to a pattern and practice of lying to a variety of people about material aspects of the case on hundreds of occasions (which I would always depicted on a flip chart in front of the jury). Once the witness establishes his/her solid credentials as an accomplished liar, nothing else they have to say matters. Fourth, contrary to what they say publicly, prosecutors always shape their case strategy and evidence to get the man or woman at the top of an organization. The skilled advocate must demonstrate how they target people, not crimes. This demonstration requires more courage than brainpower. Fifth, audio and video evidence will always be more beneficial to the accused than the government. These recordings are always selective and never complete. Simply focus on what is not recorded and why. Incomplete recordings are akin to books with missing pages or chapters. They have little real value to the reader within this context. Sixth, FBI interview techniques are a goldmine for a criminal defendant. Jurors are usually shocked when they learn that the FBI does not tape record its interviews with witnesses. Instead, the FBI relies upon agents to make notes (called “302” statements) that are not shared with the witness at the conclusion of the interview, meaning the witness cannot ensure their accuracy. Over time, the agent’s 302 notes tend to mutate in the government’s favor, especially in cases where there are multiple interviews with the same witness. Seventh, the cozy relationship between prosecutors and trial judges is compounded by their political ties to high-ranking public officials, which ultimately provides enough fertile ground for questioning the integrity of any case when properly developed first in the media. Eighth, the best defense is always a relentless offense . The accused must start this offense as soon as he/she is the target of a criminal investigation. The accused must go public first, fast and hard. He/she must convey his or her side of the story in the court of public opinion. He/she must make the government the enemy by exposing everything he or she knows about the investigation and questioning its legitimacy. Prosecutors have little experience in playing defense in the court of public opinion. Remember, this is a campaign for the accused’s freedom. This campaign is a long and hard process, not a one-time press conference where the defendant’s lawyer simply denies the charges after an indictment is announced. Ninth, the outcast defendant must use the media to define his or her humanity - it is important that the public to knows the accused on a personal level. Who is the private person? Everybody knows the public persona; after all, PR experts carefully crafted this public image over many years. Define the accused’s personal value system, people skills, circle of family and true friends (who may not be rich and well-known), and acts of kindness (not tax-deductible charity) to ordinary people. Downplay charitable acts and foundation giving for privileged groups like the arts community, opera, symphony, zoo, botanical gardens, and museums. Highlight examples of kindness where money was not the lynchpin for support and generosity. Finally, the accused should spend no time worrying about his/her social or professional redemption. It will not occur, even when he/she is acquitted. The sole focus must be on freedom. It is the only outcome that matters. Epilogue Of course, the successful implementation of my Guide for winning high-profile criminal cases where losing is not an acceptable option depends upon the accused having a trial judge who is NOT on the take or is not otherwise compromised. Today, the scales of justice are rarely balanced. What is more, a growing number of state and federal judges have zero integrity or respect for the law. Many of them are nothing more than “ political whores ” who will gladly railroad an accused person in a “ rigged ” courtroom trial. That said, many judges will still give an outcast defendant a fair shot at winning his/her case.
- Sean Combs is Jailed. Diddy's Chances of Regaining His Freedom are Bleak
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on September 18, 2024 An Editorial Opinion Tonight, Sean “Diddy” Combs is spending his third night in a New York federal detention center. Diddy is charged in a three-count federal indictment with racketeering conspiracy, sex trafficking, and transporting sex workers across state lines to engage in prostitution. Yesterday, the U.S. government released a " Detention Letter " that lays out a summary of the criminal case against Sean Combs. The charges against him are very serious. The criminal investigation in Diddy’s case is ongoing. Combs, who is 54 years old, may spend the rest of his life in federal prison if he is convicted on the charges against him. Right now, Diddy is losing every legal battle in the case. Combs is represented by New York Attorney Marc Agnifilo, who has represented a lot of companies and people. However, Agnifilo only lists two acquittals in criminal cases and one non-prosecution agreement on his résumé . Agnifilo’s win-loss record in jury trials cannot be ascertained from his published résumé. Diddy was denied bail by the magistrate judge assigned to his case, as well as his trial judge. He will remain in detention pending a trial. Diddy is housed in a segregated part of the detention center called the “Special Housing Unit” or the “Hole.” This is a horrible place to be detained. Many of Diddy’s high-profile friends, employees, and business associates have received so-called "Kastigar Letters" of immunity from prosecution in exchange for their grand jury testimony against him. Diddy's vast network of friends, employees, and associates are fleeing his friendship circle at Olympic speeds. All the recipients of Kastigar Letters have lawyered up. Some of them are unindicted co-conspirators. Whatever loyalty they had to Diddy before his indictment is now gone. Diddy’s chances of experiencing freedom again are bleak. The mountain of evidence gathered during the raids on his Miami and Los Angeles mansions was massive. The cooperating government witnesses against Diddy are plentiful. The electronic evidence is damning. Diddy has legal representation that, in my opinion, is woefully inadequate for the level of courtroom fighting that is required to win his case. Diddy’s life is on the line, but I doubt whether Diddy knows his lawyer’s win-loss record in jury trials. Most criminal defendants NEVER ask this simple question. Instead, they rely on professional reputations that are crafted and enhanced by highly-paid slick PR firms and meaningless word-of-mouth referrals from others in their inner circle. In the end, I expect Diddy’s lawyer to negotiate a plea deal for 10 to 15 years in federal prison after Diddy has been paid tens of millions in legal fees. A desperate and dejected Diddy will likely take this deal rather than gamble on a life sentence.
- For the Love of Jewish Campaign Money, Harris and Trump are Supporting Genocide in Gaza
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on September 17, 2024 An Editorial Opinion There has never been a war in history where 80% of the country has been destroyed, 100% of the population displaced, and 50% of the deaths are children. By any definition of war, this is genocide. I also agree with Prof. Noam Chomsky’s statement of the Israel-Hamas War : “The Israeli decision to rain death and destruction on Gaza, to use lethal weapons of the modern battlefield on a largely defenseless civilian population, is the final phase in a decades-long campaign to ethnically- cleanse Palestinians. Israel uses sophisticated attack jets and naval vessels to bomb densely- crowded refugee camps, schools, apartment blocks, mosques, and slums to attack a population that has no air force, no air defense, no navy, no heavy weapons, no artillery units, no mechanized armor, no command in control, no army... and calls it a war. It is not a war, it is murder.” Of course, Prof. Chomsky is a highly respected Jewish scholar. The problem in the Israel is not the Jewish people. For the most part, they are wonderful human beings who are demanding an end to the War. The problem in Israel is Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. He is a ruthless, corrupt, “thug” who is despised by many Jews inside and outside of Israel. However, a host of top politicians in Washington fear him. Netanyahu has used a massive amount of Jewish campaign money to place a chokehold on the political positions of Vice President Kamala Harris and Donald Trump with respect to the Israel-Hamas War. There is not a dime’s worth of difference between these two politicians on this subject. Harris and Trump are appeasing an internationally condemned thug who does not deserve anyone's respect. Harris and Trump fully support Netanyahu’s relentless campaign of genocide against the Palestinian population in Gaza. Both of them are on Netanyahu’s political leash and Netanyahu walks them like he walks his dogs. The U.S. government has confirmed and documented the genocide that America funds and supports with military equipment. For the right amount of Jewish campaign money, Harris and Trump are committed to supplying the weapons of war that Netanyahu needs to slaughter tens of thousands of Palestinian children. For critics who say Israel’s campaign of genocide is necessary, I remind them of Israel’s conduct in “ Operation Wraft of God ” (1972 to 1979). This Israeli campaign of retaliation against the terrorists who massacred Israeli athletes at the 1972 Olympic Games in Munich confirms that Israel knows how to neutralize terrorists without inflicting massive collateral damage upon innocent civilians. “Operation Wraft of God” had only one innocent civilian casualty in its 7 years of operation, and it was 100% effective. To be clear, Israel has an absolute right to exist in the territory once known as “Palestine.” It also has a right to defend itself from terrorist attacks. However, Israel doe NOT have a right to commit war crimes, crimes against humanity, and genocide. At the end of the day, it is important for me to be on the right side of history regarding the Israel-Hamas war. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., was on the right side of history with respect to the Vietnam war long before it was popular in the U.S. to oppose the war. Dr. King caught pure hell from Americans in 1967 for opposing the war. The passage of time showed that Dr. King was right on the Vietnam war issue. As Israel's campaign of genocide continues in Gaza, I am reminded that the flow of Jewish campaign dollars to top American politicians is more important than human lives, particularly when the lives are Palestinian children of color. I knew that Donald Trump would tolerate genocide because he does not care about anybody other than himself. If Trump has a conscience or soul, nobody has found it. I also knew that Joe Biden would tolerate genocide because he is nothing more than an old, senile, cadaver-like, shell of a man whose time on the Washington political scene has come and gone. I now know that Kamala Harris will tolerate genocide in Gaza because she is hustling for campaign money. As such, Harris does not want to offend her Jewish campaign donors by working to stop Netanyahu's campaign of genocide. As for me, genocide is not a political issue. It is a human rights issue. I have never compromised my values on human rights issues. And, I have never been "for sale."
- The Harris-Trump Race for the White House May Be the Closest One in U.S. History
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on September 15, 2024 An Editorial Opinion The external and internal polling data available to my group of independent voter influencers suggest that the 2024 race for president may be the closest election for the White House in U.S. history. To date, there is no clear leader in the national polls. This is particularly true in the seven swing states. Endorsements by celebrities like Taylor Swift, Martha Stewart, and George Clooney have done little to move the needle in Kamala Harris's favor. Likewise, Donald Trump's numbers and percentages in the polls appear to be stagnant. Our group of independent voter influencers has developed a unique political infrastructure to deliver a decisive block of undecided independent voters in the seven swing states (i.e., Michigan, Pennsylvania, Georgia, Arizona, Nevada, North Carolina, and Wisconsin) to the presidential candidate of our choice. Our state-of-the-art “block voting” delivery system is next generation political infrastructure. We are confident that it will serve as a model voter delivery system in the November election, as well as close presidential elections in the future where losing is not an acceptable option. There are more than 90 electoral votes across these seven swing states we have targeted. These states will determine whether Kamala Harris or Donald Trump will become the 47th President of the United States. Due to the closeness of the race, our group of independents has decided to conduct one more round of internal polling in the seven swing states before announcing our preferred candidate for president. As such, we are deferring our planned presidential endorsement announcement until the end of September.
- Don Cornelius’s 2012 Suicide Devastated Me
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on September 12, 2024 Don Cornelius died from a gunshot wound to the head on February 1, 2012, at the age of 75. His death was the first time I had lost a close friend to suicide. It hurt me deeply. Don called me the night before he died. I was taking a shower in my Atlanta condo and missed his call. After I exited the shower, I saw that Don had called me. I meant to call Don back immediately, but I got distracted by a litany of other incoming calls as I was getting dressed for an event I had to attend that night. When I got home from the event later that night, I forgot to call Don before falling asleep. When I awoke the next morning, it was all over the news. Don Cornelius had killed himself. I was shocked and angry at myself for not calling Don back the night before. I had talked Don out of his emotional despair and depression on three prior occasions and knew I could have done it again. I could always tell from the tone of Don’s voice and the subjects we discussed whenever he was depressed. I failed in my friendship with Don when I did not call him back after I exited the shower. By 4 a.m. PST the next morning, Don sank into a deep state of depression over his deteriorating health issues and ended his life. How We Met Don and I met in 2002 while I was trying to buy the Anaheim Angels Major League Baseball team from the Disney Company. At the time, Don was raising $300 million to launch SoulTrainCybervision.com and the Soul Train Channel . UBS Paine Webber (Beverly Hills Office) represented Don in his $300 million capital raise. UBS Paine Webber (New York Office) had committed to raising $150 million of the $200 million I needed to buy the Angels. I agreed to participate in Don’s capital raise because he was taking the bold steps necessary to launch his Soul Train channel on Cable TV at a time when Blacks deemed themselves lucky if they had a show on TV. Don had already developed an impressive array of diversified programming content for his proposed Soul Train channel, which would run 24 hours per days, seven days per week. Don needed one of the major cable carriers to platform his Soul Train channel. Don approached Charter Communications, Comcast, Liberty Media, and Adelphia Communications with his Soul Train channel. All of them eventually turned him down. They were willing to put a Black TV show in their programming lineup, but they unwilling to give a Black content creator like Don access to his own 24-hour cable channel. Don also gave me a draft of his autobiography titled, “ Soul Train Memoirs ,” an original story and screenplay by Don Cornelius. We intended to co-produce a movie from Don’s screenplay. From 2007 to 2009, Don helped me to advance in the competition to acquire the St. Louis Rams National Football League team (now known as the L.A. Rams). He was one of my business advisors and biggest cheerleaders. Why We Bonded The friendship between Don and me was birthed out a deep and abiding respect for each other’s achievements in business. Don shared his knowledge of the professional sports world with me and I shared my institutional knowledge of the cable TV industry with him. Even though Don was 12 years older than me, we developed a close business and personal friendship. Don was a Chicago native who grew up in the city during Black Chicagoan’s push for diversity, equity, and inclusion in employment opportunities and business enterprises. He was a TV news reporter who focused on Black economic empowerment issues before he launched Soul Train in 1970. Soul Train evolved into the longest-running program in TV history. Don created it, owned the intellectual property associated with the show, executive produced the show, and successfully syndicated it around the world. I attended Southern Illinois University from 1966 to 1970. I also lived and worked in Chicago during the summer months while I was in college. The Chicago connection between Don and me was deep. We both knew all the Black powerbrokers in Chicago during the late 1960s. After our initial meeting in Los Angeles, I chilled out with Don every time I was in L.A. between 2002 and 2012. I turned down all of Don’s offers to go with him to the annual Soul Train Awards event and other celebrity outings. I preferred to hang out privately. When we hung out, it was just the two of us. We talked about our families, our business operations, and our pursuit of three high-profile commercial projects that broke the color barrier. I counseled Don through a couple of high-profile legal matters and several health issues in his life. One was a domestic abuse situation involving his second wife. Don claimed she was cheating on him. I convinced him to end the marriage and let her go, which he did. I also hooked Don up with my brother Levi to give him a famous and well-respected advocate within the medical community. This hookup gave Don readily available, 24-hour access to the best doctors in the world to work on his health issues. Don’s legal and health issues took a heavy emotional toll on his personal and business life. My Pain from Don's Suicide Has Never Ended My pain from Don’s suicide has never ended. I have never forgiven myself for the lapse in my friendship with Don. I should have called him back before I fell asleep on the night he callled me. To this day, I miss Don and the special friendship bond we shared. He was a great American, a visionary, a multimedia business icon, and a wonderful human being. As a final tribute to this great man, I will bring Don's " Soul Train Memoirs " to life as a feature film . I still have my copy of the screenplay that Don sent me. It's his story in his own words.
- Violent Crime is Rising in America
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on September 13, 2024 Yesterday, the U.S. Department of Justice released its " National Crime Victimization Survey .” The survey found that violent crime in America was up 37% from 2020 to 2023, rape was up 42%, robbery was up 63%, and stranger violence was up 61% . No public official has claimed that these crime statistics are inaccurate. No public official is willing to accept the blame for the rise in violent crime. As expected, no public official has advanced a basket of practical and effective solutions for curbing violent crime. In the 25 years since the school shooting at Columbine High School, more than 338,000 students in the U.S. have experienced gun violence at school. Yet, we are still waiting for a practical solution to school massacres. Today, banning books in public school libraries appears to be a more important priority than protecting the lives of our school children. The law enforcement function in America has become more politicized and weaponized today than ever before. This paradigm exists whether the U.S. president, governor, U.S. attorney general, state attorney general, local district attorney, and mayor in power is a Republican or Democrat. Anyone who claims otherwise is bullshitting the public. Meanwhile, Americans are suffering from rising violent crime that is undeniable. The rise in violent crime seems to be uncontrollable.











