Search Results
Search this site
1309 results found with an empty search
- Kamala Harris is Poised to Win the American Presidency in 2024
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on August 6, 2024 An Editorial Opinion Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump had senile Joe Biden beaten in the 2024 race for the presidency. To their credit, Democrats recognized this fact after the presidential debate in June and dumped Biden in July. They quickly installed Vice President Kamala Harris as their presidential nominee. Today, Harris is poised to win the American presidency. She has moved ahead of Trump in the latest credible polls. Now, she is laser focused on winning the six swing states that matter. Every advantage Donald Trump had over Joe Biden is gone. Trump’s campaign appears to be stuck in 1st gear, and he only has himself to blame. All Trump has done in the past couple of weeks is called Harris names and questioned her racial identity. This tactic is turning off independent voters. Trump’s attempted character assassination of Harris would work if he had any character, which he does not have. Kamala Harris’ personal relationship with former California political powerbroker Willie Brown pales in comparison to Trump’s adjudicated sexual assault of E. Jean Carroll and his confirmed extramarital affairs with porn star Stormy Daniels and Playboy model Karen McDougal. In America, Harris’ racial identity is determined by law and custom. Under the “One Drop Rule,” Harris’ Jamaican father’s African ancestry makes her "Black." This slavery-era racial classification scheme remains in full force and effect today. Democrats are Rejuvenated Kamala Harris’ presidential campaign has rejuvenated the Democratic Party. It is also affording independent voters a viable option to Donald Trump. My group of independent voter influencers is still assessing the candidacies of Trump and Harris. We will endorse the nominee of our choice after Labor Day. We are also willing to support the endorsed nominee with up to $75 million in Super-PAC donations, if he/she sits for a personal interview. The choice now is whether independent voters want to go back to a period when Donald Trump thinks America was great for his segment of the American population or move forward into a progressive, diversified, and inclusive future with Kamala Harris as president. Do we want an authoritarian form of government under Project 2025 or do we want participatory democracy under Kamala Harris? Do we want politicians and law enforcement officials making medical decisions for women and their bodies or do we want those matters reserved for a woman and her doctor? Do we want the federal judiciary packed with right-wing "political whores" or do we want fair-minded, independent judges who decide cases based upon the facts and applicable law? Do we want the Israeli genocide of Palestinians in Gaza to continue, unabated, or do we want peace with justice in the Middle East? The policy differences between Donald Trump and Kamala Harris are as different as night and day, and they are endless. Thus far, Kamala Harris seems to be making all the right moves against Donald Trump. She has galvanized her base of supporters in record time. She is sticking to the clearly define policy issues. She has raised a gigantic amount of campaign funds in only three weeks. Unlike Trump’s curious selection of boring J.D. Vance, Harris picked an exciting vice-presidential nominee in Minnesota Governor Tim Walz. Governor Walz is a natural born campaigner. J.D. Vance comes across like young child who is lost in a parking lot. Vance is completely useless to the Trump campaign. Determining the Likely Outcome When the 2024 race was between Donald Trump and Joe Biden, I predicted on multiple occasions that Trump would win. The polling and other objective evidence supported this prediction. I predicted Donald Trump’s victory in 2016 and his defeat in 2020. If Trump continues to wallow in mindless name-calling and ignorant racial identity politics, Kamala Harris will become the 47th president of the United States. As a nominee, Harris still has plenty of political baggage to explain between now and Election Day. Independent voters like me are tired of divisive, regressive, political rhetoric. We want Donald Trump and Kamala Harris to focus on presenting and explaining their policy positions on issues of significant public interest – something Trump seems incapable of doing. If Donald Trump cannot shift his presidential campaign out of 1st gear, this race is over. Harris will win, decisively. Remember, political demagoguery has always had a short shelf-life in America.
- Reflections on Easter Sunday in the Midst of a Pandemic
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on April 12, 2020 My understanding of the Bible came from my beloved parents, Levi and Lillian Watkins, and Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., my childhood pastor, Sunday School teacher, and Baptist Training Union instructor at Dexter Avenue Baptist Church in Montgomery, Alabama. My parents didn't just talk the Christian talk; they also walked the Christian walk. In other words, they practiced what they preached and led by example. My mother's father was a well-known Baptist preacher in black American. All that my parents and Dr. King did not instill in my siblings and me was instilled by Rev. Willie Varnado, my maternal grandfather. In his famous April 16, 1963 "Letter from a Birmingham Jail," Dr. King addressed his fellow white clergy who were critical of his non-violent civil rights movement in Birmingham, Alabama and who chastised him as an "outsider" who was fomenting racial conflict between white and black citizens in the city. Dr. King acknowledged that his critics were "men of genuine goodwill" and that their criticisms [were] sincerely set forth." Dr. King reminded his fellow clergy that "[w]e are caught in an inescapable network of mutuality, tied in a single garment. Whatever affects one directly, affects all indirectly." King's quotes in 1963 apply today with equal force to the church and organized religion as the novel coronavirus spreads rapidly across the globe. The death toll from the virus is staggering. It is killing Americans and others around the world on a massive and indiscriminate basis. Prayers on Easter Sunday The COVID-19 infectious disease is visiting death, affliction, and economic destruction on nearly every nation on the globe. In the United States, there have been 533,088 confirmed cases of COVID-19 and 20,580 deaths from the disease, with no end in sight to the disease. There is no cure for COVID-19, and scientists have not developed a vaccine to counteract its effects. President Donald J. Trump labeled the virus a "plague." The World Health Organization called the infectious virus a pandemic. In March, Trump declared a national emergency in the United States because the virus is killing Americans and spreading with impunity. This plague has also caused America to shut down its robust national economy. For the first time since the "Spanish flu" pandemic in 1918, American citizens and our nation are struggling for survival as we recognize Easter Sunday. The Bible chronicles at least 10 plagues. They are referenced in Exodus 12:29-30, 2 Chronicles 6:28, Luke 21:11, Revelations 21:9 and 22:18. According to the Bible, a plague is a disastrous evil, affliction, or epidemic of infectious disease issued by God in Judgment. As scientists and healthcare professionals around the world battle the COVID-19 pandemic, the modern-day church has been reluctant to link this deadly infection to the wrath of God or his Judgment on mankind. This reluctance mirrors the same kind of cowardice Dr. King found in the white clergy of Alabama in 1963. They went along with strictly enforced racial segregation laws in order to get along with the members of their church congregations. Since then, churches of all faiths and ethnic backgrounds have moved from condemning man's inhumanity to man, in accordance with God's teachings, to justifying this inhumanity in politically palatable terms that satisfy the partisan leanings of their congregations. Will God Hear Our Prayers? In America and around the world, respected and well-known members of the clergy are praying for an end to the plague. Will God hear their prayers? According to Proverbs 1:23-33, he will not. Unfortunately, partisan politics has invaded the church and has now firmly nested in the pulpit. Too many religious leaders of all faiths will be harmonizing and packaging their Easter Sunday messages in a way that legitimizes society's mistreatment of the "least of these." In many respects, the church is openly complicit in this mistreatment. This is why the Catholic Church will not condemn in a loud and unified voice its clergy's sex abuse of innocent young children. This is why the Amish Church and community tolerates the sexual abuse of its young girls, which is often perpetrated on the victims by family members and other close relatives. This is why churches in America practiced deafening silence when migrant parents from Central and South American were separated from their young children at America's southern border. This is why there was no outcry from the church when America's president claimed his book on making business deals was second only to the Bible. This is why the church does not speak out when governments around the world brutally persecute the poor and defenseless in the name of national greatness. The prayers of the church this Easter seek only relief from the devastating effects of the COVID-19 pandemic. The church has never addressed the underlying reasons why God is inflicting his wrath on the world and why America is bearing the brunt of God's wrath. Additionally, the church has never prayed for the strength and courage to change society's ways toward the "least of these." Sadly, the church's order of the day is out of order, and God is demonstrating by clear and convincing evidence exactly who is in charge of the world today. It's not Joel Osteen. It's not Pope Francis. It's not popular mega-church ministers like Rev. Dr. J.D. Jakes, or Rev. Creflo Dollar. It's not the Supreme Ayatollah in Iran. It's not the Dalai Lama in Tibet. It's not Billy Graham's son, Franklin Graham. The Church of Scientology, the Mormon Church, Southern Baptist Churches, and Methodist Churches are also powerless to stop the COVID-19 virus. Jewish rabbis and their temples are impotent, as well, in the face of this deadly pandemic. All of the world's religions and churches are powerless to stop the wrath of God, and their spiritual leaders are too embarrassed to admit their failings as members of the international brotherhood/sisterhood of clergy. Until we fundamentally change our ways and get right with God, the death and affliction from COVID-19 will continue. The citizens of the earth will suffer wave after wave of the deadly mutating virus. This is God's wake up call to mankind. We can treat it like a scientific and medical problem, or we can recognize it as the wrath of God for straying from his teachings. God gave us a perfect world and we ruined it. God sacrificed his only son, Jesus Christ, to save us from our sins. We showed our appreciation by engaging in greater and more lavish sins. God is angry, and we are paying the price for our sins. He is not listening to our prayers right now. Proverbs 1:28. Dr. King's Word are Prophetic for Today's COVID-19 Calamity Dr. King ended his Letter from the Birmingham Jail with these prophetic words: "In deep disappointment I have wept over the laxity of the church .... There was a time when the church was very powerful -- in the time when early Christians rejoiced at being deemed worthy to suffer for what they believed. In those days, the church was not merely a thermometer that recorded the ideas and principles of popular opinion; it was a thermostat that transformed the mores of society." Then, Dr. King added these words, as though he was addressing us today: "[T]he judgment of God is upon the church as never before. If today's church does not recapture the sacrificial spirit of the early church, it will lose its authenticity, forfeit the loyalty of millions, and be dismissed as an irrelevant social club with no meaning for the [twenty-first] century." Finally, Dr. King posed this question in 1963 that is reverberating in the midst of today's COVID-19 crisis: "Is organized religion too inextricably bound to the status quo to save our nation and the world?" I think so.
- The Divine Nine: Welcome Back to the Political Gladiator Pit
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on August 2, 2024 For over a century, the Divine Nine has produced the leadership cadre in Black America. I am a life member of Alpha Phi Alpha, the first historically Black fraternity in America and a Divine Nine organization. Alamerica Bank in Birmingham, Alabama, a Black-owned, full service bank I founded in January 2000, provided major funding for the 2006 PBS documentary titled, “Alpha Phi Alpha Fraternity: A Century of Leadership.” The other eight distinguished organizations in the Divine Nine are: Alpha Kappa Alpha Sorority, Delta Sigma Theta Sorority, Iota Phi Theta Fraternity, Kappa Alpha Psi Fraternity, Omega Psi Phi Fraternity, Phi Beta Sigma Fraternity, Sigma Gamma Rho Sorority, and Zeta Phi Beta Sorority. Each one of these nine organizations was founded during a period in our history when Black college students were barred from becoming members of historically White college fraternities and sororities throughout America. The fraternities and sororities in the Divine Nine are great organizations. All of them have made tremendous contributions to racial equality and economic growth in America. The Divine Nine has re-entered the political gladiator pit to rally the Black community's support for Democratic Party nominee Kamala Harris in the 2024 presidential election. They made the difference in Barack Obama's election to the presidency, twice. They delivered millions of newly registered Black and White voters for Obama. They are committed to doing the same for Kamala Harris. Historically, the Divine Nine has long been the driving force for socio-economic progress in America. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., was a member of Alpha Phi Alpha fraternity. Rosa Parks was inducted as an honorary member of Alpha Kappa Alpha sorority in 1988. Once again, the Divine Nine is entering the political gladiator pit to make sure African-Americans are included in the forward progress of this great nation.
- Homicides in Birmingham Will Continue to Rise Until the Police Department is Restored to 900 Sworn Officers
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on August 1, 2024 An Editorial Opinion According to the U.S. Census Bureau, the city of Birmingham, Alabama has a total area of 151.9 square miles. Because of “long lasso” annexations during the Richard Arrington years as mayor, the city is situated in Jefferson and Shelby Counties. The city has 99 historic neighborhoods and communities. At the time of the annexations, city officials recognized that Birmingham would require a police force of 912 sworn officers and 325 professional staff members to provide adequate police protection within 151.9 square miles. The police department’s website acknowledges the required number of officers and support staff needed for adequate police protection. Today, the city has 430 sworn officers providing police services within 151.9 square miles of territory. This number of police officers is grossly inadequate. The police force is understaffed by 482 officers. Throughout the Mayor Randall Woodfin administration, money for these 482 unfilled police positions has been redirected to pet projects for the “over-the-mountain" crowd and questionable consulting contracts for Woodfin’s political friends. The city’s 430 sworn officers work in three shifts of about 143 officers per shift. The department staffs an administrative services division, a patrol division, and an investigative division. Less than half of the police officers employed work in the patrol division. It is physically impossible to adequately patrol Birmingham’s 151.9 square miles of territory with a police department that is 53% understaffed. This understaffing is the greatest contributing factor to the explosion of violent street crime in the city. Street gangs and drug dealers know that the police department is severely understaffed and that police patrols are woefully anemic. The department’s focus has shifted from preventing violent crimes, via robust police patrols, to simply solving crimes, via the work of its investigation division. When Randall Woodfin assumed the mayor's job in 2017, the city of Birmingham was not listed on the Forbes list of the 15 Most Dangerous Cities in the U.S. Today, the city is No. 3 on the Forbes list of the Most Dangerous Cities (and several others). Mayor Woodfin and the city's council members have engaged in a host of PR gimmicks to deflect public attention away from the fact that salary money budgeted each year for unfilled police positions is routinely redirected to support Woodfin's pet projects for the "over-the-mountain" crowd and consulting contracts for his political friends. Birmingham residents are dying on the city's streets of every day because of these misguided political decisions. PR gimmickry at City Hall will not stop the rising death count in the Birmingham's streets. A fully staffed, 900-officer police department will. Mayor Woodfin does not have to worry about adequate police protection for himself. He has up to 10 police officers assigned to his executive protection detail. In contrast, city residents can barely get one officer per shift to patrol each one of the city's 99 neighborhoods. Nothing will change for Birmingham residents until they get sick and tired of dying in the streets from skyrocketing street crime. The current streak of violent crime will continue until 900 sworn officers are working on the police force, once again. Meanwhile, all Woodfin’s pet projects are getting funded, and his political consultants are happily receiving their taxpayer-funded invoice payments.
- The Rules of Engagement for Our Spirited Trump vs. Harris Online Political Debate
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on July 24, 2024 Now that the presidential nominees for the Democratic and Republican Parties have been selected, it is time for me to announce the Rules of Engagement for all postings and comments supporting or opposing the nominees for all political parties on my social media platforms. So that you know, my Facebook page drives less than 10% of the Internet traffic that feeds my www.donaldwatkins.com website. Whether you are a Democrat, Republican, Libertarian, Green Party, Constitutionalist, Socialist, or Independent, you are welcome to present and discuss your political beliefs on my social media platforms! I strongly encourage civil debate regarding each Party’s nominee and political platform. We have a readership of about 260,000 per month across all of my social media platforms. My audience is racially, economically, geographically, and politically diverse. It is also very sophisticated and engaging. Spirited debate about the nominees and political issues is encouraged. This kind of debate is healthy for a democratic society. Here are the Rules of Engagement, effective from today through November 5, 2024: Do not post political ads on my social media platforms. We are not beggars. We do not solicit or accept political ads or sponsored content from anybody, ever. If posted, this content will be deleted. Spam, derogatory/mean spirited memes, and/or misleading posts or comments will be deleted. There are plenty of social media platforms that will accept misleading posts or comments, but we are NOT one of them. Harassment, personal attacks, vulgarity, and profanity will NOT be tolerated. Anyone violating the Rule for respectful, courteous, and honest debate will have his/her/its content removed or deleted. The person submitting this prohibited content will also be permanently banned from my social media platforms. Political cartoons are acceptable, if they conform to these Rules. Guest editorials may be submitted for publication in their entirety, if they are submitted by the Party's nominee with the appropriate disclaimer. I do not want paid political hustlers or designated campaign surrogates submitting content for publication on my social media platforms. My reading audience is too sophisticated for the political hustlers and surrogates who routinely feast off presidential campaign money. My national circle of independent voter influencers read the content posted on my social media platforms on a regular basis to stay abreast on political developments that usually becomes publicly available weeks or months later. They are all highly successful entrepreneurs. About 75 of these influencers are potential mega-donors. Your comments will be taken into consideration by them when we caucus after Labor Day to determine which presidential nominee, if any, will earn our financial support. Please keep this point in mind when writing and posting your comments. We do not want or need government jobs and/or government contracts. We are NOT corporate welfare kings or queens. As self-sufficient political independents, we only want good, clean, transparent government. In fairness to all, polling information will primarily guide our final decision-making in the 2024 presidential race. A nominee's clear and convincing demonstration of electability is crucial for our financial support. My group is NOT in the business of funding political aspirations and/or professional campaign operatives. Our Rules of Engagement are simple and everyone is expected to comply with them, without exception. That said, let's have a good time discussing the nominees and debating the political issues between now and November 5th.
- My Group of Independent Voter Influencers Has Begun the Process of Vetting Donald Trump and Kamala Harris
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on July 28, 2024 An Editorial Opinion My group of independent voter influencers has begun the vetting process on Donald Trump and Kamala Harris. Our analysis of Trump began right after the Republican convention ended on July 18, 2024. This article focuses on GOP nominee Donald Trump. For our group to support Donald Trump, we have to believe the following things: It is okay for rich and famous men to grab women “by the pussy.” It is okay for Donald Trump (or any other man) to refer to women as "fat pigs, dogs, slobs and disgusting animals." It is okay to sexually abuse up to two dozen women, if you are a rich, privileged, and famous businessman in New York City. It was okay for Donald Trump to pal around with pedophile Jeffery Epstein while Epstein was partying with underage girls who served as teenage concubines on his private island in the Caribbean. (Bill Clinton was reportedly doing the same thing on the island as Trump.) E. Jean Carrol was lying about what Donald Trump did to her in the dressing room at in the Bergdorf Goodman department store in New York City. Porn star Stormy Daniels lied when she said Donald Trump had sex with her while Melania was recovering from the birth of Trump's son Baron. She even described his penis in a way he never disputed. Trump did not pay stormy Daniels $130,000 in “hush money.” Playboy model Karen McDougal lied when she claimed Trump cheated on Melania with her. Trump okayed Howard Stern calling his daughter Ivanka a “piece of ass” during a live raido broadcast. Maryanne Trump Barry, Donald Trump’s recently deceased sister and a former federal judge, lied when she said on an audiotape that “Donald’s out for Donald,” “Donald is cruel,” Donald Trump is always “lying,” and Trump cheated to get into the University of Pennsylvania by having Joe Shapiro take his entrance exam for him. Trump is a good Christian leader, who knows and practices the teachings of Jesus Christ. The Trump Bible is the word of God. Trump’s “Art of the Deal” book is second to the King James version of the Holy Bible in worldwide popularity. Trump is endorsed by Jesus Christ, as stated in a Roger Stone tweet. Trump did not commit tax and business fraud with his companies in New York City. Trump does not legitimately owe $400 million in court fines and penalties on his New York City businesses. Trump did not embezzle millions of dollars from his Donald J. Trump Foundation, which he was required by court order to pay back. Trump did not scam his defunct Trump University students out of millions of dollars by promising academic offerings that did not exist. Trump’s four business bankruptcies did not hurt scores of innocent vendors and service providers who worked diligently on Trump’s defunct Atlantic City Taj Mahal casino and three other real estate projects. The 2020 election was stolen from Donald Trump, but was not stolen from the thousands of other MAGA Republican candidates across America who ran for political office in 2020, including dozens of successful top-of-the-ticket Republican candidates in Pennsylvania, Michigan, Arizona, Wisconsin, Nevada, and Georgia who were far more right-wing than Trump. Trump was not complicit in the January 6, 2021, insurrection, including the attempt to hang former Vice President Mike Pence. (No wonder Republican officeholders are afraid of Trump.) Trump did not steal classified documents, which he refused to return to the federal government when he was requested to do so. Trump did not extort Ukraine in 2020 to help him win the 2020 election (which he lost). Trump did not collude with Russia during the 2020 campaign. Trump does not exude adulation for dictators like Russian President Vladimir Putin, Chinese President Xi Jinping, and North Korean Supreme Leader Kim Jong Un. Trump did nothing to justify two Congressional impeachments while serving as president. Trump did not commit the 34 felonies in New York for which a state court jury convicted him. Trump could not have managed America’s response to COVID-19 any better than he did in 2020. Trump's packing of the U.S. Supreme Court with right-wing political zealots is a good thing. Trump’s separation of tens of thousands of young migrant children from their parents at the southern border was a good thing. Trump’s promise to deport 15 to 20 million illegal immigrants using the militaristic tactics first deployed in 1954 during “Operation Wetback” is a good thing. The Supreme Court decision overturning Roe v. Wade was a good thing. Dismantling affirmative action programs that are designed to include women and minorities in the socio-economic progress of America is a good thing, while encouraging and engaging in affirmative action that excludes them is acceptable. Wall Street will take care of Mainstreet. Trump knows nothing about the Project 2025 Manifesto. Trump is not a liar, grifter, bully, rapist, philanderer, thief, tax cheat, fraudster, racist, sexist, and insurrectionist. My legal training causes me to conduct a "preponderance of evidence" analysis on Donald Trump’s “character and fitness” to serve in public office. This analytical approach is more useful to me than simply reviewing an endless parade of political soundbites, memes, tweets, social media posts, and polished campaign ads. Between today and Labor Day, we will conduct (and publish) the same kind of "preponderance of evidence" analysis on Kamala Harris after she accepts the Democratic nomination for president. Personally, I believe that “character and fitness” still matters for those who seek to serve our nation in public office. Republican and Democratic partisans do not seem to care about “character and fitness” attributes, but we do. My group of independent voter influencers will decide who to endorse and financially support (up to $75 million in donations to favorable Super-PACs) after Labor Day. We are not looking for an angel, but we are certainly not trying to elevate a devil to the presidency, either. Our group’s endorsement and financial support will go to either Donald Trump or Kamala Harris.
- Hunter Biden’s Choice of Abbe Lowell Guarantees His Conviction in Delaware Federal Criminal Case
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on December 9, 2023; Updated June 6, 2024 An Editorial Opinion Hunter Biden started his criminal trial on Monday in a Delaware federal courtroom. He is represented in this criminal case by Washington, D.C.-based attorney Abbe Lowell, a partner in Winston & Strawn, LLP. I personally worked with Abbe Lowell in the case of U.S. v. Richard Scrushy, an 85-count healthcare fraud case brought by federal prosecutors in Birmingham, Alabama against former HealthSouth CEO Richard Scrushy from 2003 to 2005. At the time, Lowell was a partner in the Washington/New York law firm of Chadbourne & Parke. Scrushy hired Abbe Lowell early in the case on the strength of his national reputation. I was the lead attorney on Scrushy's criminal defense team -- a choice that did not sit well with Lowell. By 2003, I had won 152 straight courtroom victories in state and federal civil and criminal cases. I did not know of any criminal cases Abbe Lowell had tried that resulted in “Not Guilty” jury verdicts for his clients. In 2004, I allowed Abbe Lowell to take the lead in one of the many pretrial court hearings in Scrushy's case. Lowell was arrogant and awful. Lowell’s arrogance at the courthouse turned off courthouse security officers, courtroom personnel, the judge’s law clerk, and the U.S. Magistrate who was conducting the hearing. What is worse, Lowell wanted to pursue a guilty plea deal even though Scrushy was innocent of all of the charges against him. Scrushy always maintained his innocence, in private conversations and public news conferences. Furthermore, Scrushy never lied to his team of lawyers about any aspect of the case, which made defending him relatively easy. After the pretrial hearing, I consulted with Scrushy and we fired Abbe Lowell. He was stunned by his firing, especially since the decision to terminate Abbe Lowell was made by a black attorney whom Lowell thought was inferior to him in every way. In my view, Abbe Lowell did not possess the knowledge, skills, and trial abilities necessary to win a high-profile, complex criminal case in a situation where losing was not an acceptable option. I ran Scrushy's criminal defense team like a Navy Seals rescue mission. I quickly discovered that Lowell was not capable of performing at the level expected of a Navy Seal. The other defense team members I had assembled could, and they did. I later learned that Abbe Lowell’s national reputation and legal persona had been carefully crafted and widely promoted by Washington public relations firms. It was a mirage. On June 28, 2005, my defense team won Richard Scrushy‘s criminal case by defeating prosecutors on all 85 felony counts, via extensive pretrial motions and our full-court press on government witnesses during a trial that lasted six months. No white-collar criminal defendant before or since Richard Scrushy's case has defeated federal prosecutors on 85 felony charges in a single-defendant case. The Washington Post called the "Not Guilty" verdicts in Scrushy's case a "miracle," while the New York Times referred to them as a "stunner." Fortune Magazine called me,"The Man Who Saved Richard Scrushy." My record-setting victory in Richard Scrushy's case is featured in a May 2020 Netflix documentary titled, “Trial by Media,” Episode 4, “King Richard.” Abbe Lowell's hiring and firing is discussed in the documentary. As expected, Abbe Lowell never congratulated my defense team or me on our landmark courtroom victory in Richard Scrushy's case. Lowell is a little man with a big ego. U.S. v. Hunter Biden Abby Lowell must win Hunter Biden's Delaware case. If he loses, Hunter Biden will face a mandatory minmum 5-year prison sentence for the gun possession charge, alone. Hunter Biden is paying Winston & Strawn a fortune in legal fees for Abbe Lowell’s legal services. Lowell is actually gifted at milking his high-profile clients for legal fees. I believe Hunter Biden will lose this criminal case. Absent a presidential pardon from Joe Biden, Hunter Biden will go to prison because the criminal defense skills needed to win this case are not present. Today, Joe Biden said he would not pardon Hunter Biden, if he is convicted. Finally, President Joe Biden should pardon Hunter Biden while he still has the mental capacity to do so. Hunter Biden, who is a recovering crackhead and powder cocaine addict, will not survive as an inmate in the federal prison system. Illegal and illicit drugs of all kind are plentiful inside the federal prison system. An emotionally fragile and struggling drug addict like Hunter Biden will likely gain access to these drugs again and overdose on them in a prison environment.
- Hunter Biden was Destined to Lose His Criminal Case with Abbe Lowell as His Defense Counsel
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on June 13, 2024 An Editorial Opinion My criminal defense teams of past years could have won Hunter Biden’s 3-count federal criminal cases 10 times out of 10, with our eyes closed. It was a simple case. It was the kind of lightweight case that we would use for scrimmaging before the big games. I personally worked with Abbe Lowell in the case of U.S. v. Richard Scrushy, an 85-count healthcare fraud case brought by federal prosecutors in Birmingham, Alabama against former HealthSouth CEO Richard Scrushy from 2003 to 2005. Scrushy hired Abbe Lowell early in the case on the strength of his national reputation, even though Lowell had been recycled among a number of big Washington law firms. I was the lead attorney on Scrushy's criminal defense team -- a choice that did not sit well with Lowell. By 2003, I had won 152 straight courtroom victories in state and federal civil and criminal cases. I did not know of any criminal cases Abbe Lowell had tried that resulted in “Not Guilty” jury verdicts for his clients. Lowell had represented plenty of big-name clients, but I was not aware of anyone he had freed from the grips of federal prosecutors. In 2004, I allowed Abbe Lowell to handle one of the many routine pretrial court hearings in Scrushy's case. Lowell was arrogant and awful. His arrogance at the courthouse turned off courthouse security officers, courtroom personnel, the judge’s law clerk, and the U.S. Magistrate who was conducting the hearing. What is worse, Lowell wanted to pursue a guilty plea deal even though Scrushy was innocent of all of the charges against him. Scrushy always maintained his innocence, in private conversations and public news conferences. Furthermore, Scrushy never lied to his team of defense attorneys about any aspect of the case, which made defending him relatively easy. After the pretrial hearing fiasco, I consulted with Scrushy and we fired Abbe Lowell. He was stunned by his firing, especially since the decision to terminate Lowell was made by a local black attorney whom Lowell saw as inferior to him in every way. In my view, Abbe Lowell did not possess the knowledge, skills, and trial abilities necessary to win a high-profile, complex criminal case in a situation where losing was not an acceptable option. I ran Scrushy's criminal defense team like a Navy Seals rescue mission. I quickly discovered that Lowell was not capable of performing at the level expected of a Navy Seal. The other defense team members I had assembled could perform at that level and did so consistently. I later learned that Abbe Lowell’s national reputation had been carefully crafted and widely promoted by Washington public relations firms. It was a mirage. Lowell could not litigate his way out of a torn paper bag on a sunny day. On June 28, 2005, my defense team won Richard Scrushy‘s criminal case by defeating prosecutors on all 85 felony counts, via extensive pretrial motions and our full-court press on government witnesses during a trial that lasted six months. No white-collar criminal defendant before or since Richard Scrushy's case has defeated federal prosecutors on 85 felony charges in a single-defendant case. Tuesday’s guilty verdicts in Hunter Biden’s case confirmed that I made the right decision by firing Abbe Lowell in Richard Scrushy’s case. This guy is an expert at getting paid, but a "loser" at winning cases. Once Hunter Biden put his life in Abbe Lowell's hands, I knew he was destined to lose his criminal case. Hunter Biden's Pardon Joe Biden should pardon his son Hunter in this case, but only if he also pardons the thousands of first-time, non-violent offenders who were convicted of violating the same federal statutes.
- Why Democratic Party Delegates Turned Their Backs on Barack and Michelle Obama
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on July 23, 2024 An Editorial Opinion It’s time to take the private conversations about the Barack and Michelle Obama into the public forum. In the waning days of Joe Biden’s presidential campaign, it was an open secret that Barack Obama, Nancy Pelosi, Chuck Schumer, Adam Schiff, Hakeem Jeffries, Michael Bloomberg, James Carville, David Axelrod, and a host of other top Democrats wanted Biden out of the race. He was not physically or mentally fit to compete with Donald Trump. Their plan was to force Biden out of the race and handpick his replacement using the guise of an “open” convention in August. They did not want Kamala Harris as the nominee because they did not think she could win against Donald Trump. The internal polling available to them showed that only Michelle Obama could win against Trump. These big-time politicos pressured Biden with phone calls and the veil threat of removal from office. They also asked mega-donors to cut off Biden’s funding, which the donors did. With Barack Obama leading the effort behind the scenes to oust Biden, these Democratic leaders were sure that they had the collective juice within the ranks of the Party’s convention delegates to handpick Biden’s replacement. Their goal was to engineer a scenario in which the delegates would draft Michelle Obama to run against Trump. An Embarrassing Miscalculation Barack Obama and other Democratic Party leaders miscalculated two things -- (a) the perceived popularity of the Obamas within the Party, and (b) the speed at which Kamala Harris could corral the delegate votes needed to become the presumptive nominee. With the endorsement of an angry, disappointed, and hurt Joe Biden, Harris was able to garner her delegate votes in record time. The handpicking game was over before it started, and Kamala Harris won. While Democrats, and Blacks in particular, admire Barack Obama for winning the presidency in 2008 and 2012, they privately vent about the fact that Obama did nothing to include Blacks in the economic progress that other groups in the Party enjoyed on his watch. Yes, a couple of dozen Black business owners in Chicago, New York, and California fared well from their connections to the Obama administration. However, Blacks, in general, suffered a double whammy from Obama's presidency. First, Blacks endured the brunt of White America’s backlash from Barack Obama’s successive election victories. This backlash has been sustained and brutal. For example, in 2010, the U.S. Supreme Court opened the door for corporations to flow the political scene with corporate money in Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, thereby diluting the value of campaign donations from ordinary citizens. In 2013, the Court gutted Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act in Shelby County v. Holder, thereby rendering the Act virtually meaningless in southern states. Furthermore, affirmative action programs nationwide have been dismantled by federal courts, from top to bottom. Additionally, Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) has become a target on the backs of every Black and woman contractor and employee in the workforce, regardless of his/her/its superior qualifications. Second, Barack Obama subjected Black Americans to the most severe form of benign neglect of any modern-day president. He did absolutely nothing special for Black America, even though he received over 90% of their votes. Since leaving the presidency, the Obamas have enriched themselves with lucrative book deals and speaker fees, as other former presidents have done. Meanwhile, financial security for Black families remains elusive. Publicly, Blacks hold the Obamas in high esteem. Privately, however, they bemoan the fact that Barack Obama did absolutely nothing to improve the plight of Black America. When he was campaigning for the presidency, Barack Obama wrote Black voters an attractive political check. When they tried to cash it, the check bounced. After Joe Biden’s disastrous debate performance in June, White Democratic leaders and mega-donors believed Barack Obama could force Biden from the race and handpick his successor-nominee. They did not realize that Obama’s bank account of political goodwill with Black voters was overdrawn. Barack Obama may not have known this fact, either. Kamala Harris Now Owns the Democratic Party Today, Kamala Harris owns the Democratic Party. If she is successful, Kamala Harris’ election will stop four awful things from happening. First, her election, per se, will kill the implementation of Project 2025. Second, Harris will surely kill any MAGA-sponsored legislation aimed at nationalizing a ban on abortions. Third, a Harris presidency halts MAGA-backed efforts to pack the federal judiciary with out-of-touch, right-wing, political hacks who masquerade as judges. Fourth, Harris will likely: (a) stop further tax cuts for super-wealthy Americans, (b) preserve Social Security and Medicare, as we know it, and (c) stop Big Pharma from gouging patients who desperately need costly prescription medicines. At a minimum, this is what Americans can expect from Kamala Harris, should she win the election. Her minimums, alone, will stop the bleeding among working class Americans. She may not be able to pass any significant legislation, but she can stop bad conditions from getting worse. As for Barack Obama and his cohorts, their days of handpicking candidates in the Democratic Party are over. Kamala Harris engineered a big win over the Obamas, of which she can be proud. No matter what they now say in public, none of the Party’s top leaders wanted Kamala Harris as the Party’s nominee. She beat them all. At this moment, Kamala Harris has the political juice in the Democratic Party, not the Obamas or Clintons.
- Very Bad Things Happen Whenever Angry White Americans Rail Against “Wokeness”
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on July 21, 2024 An Editorial Opinion The Donald J. Trump-led MAGA political movement in America does not want to experience “wokeness.” In fact, MAGA rails against all forms of "wokeness." Based upon American history, very bad things happened to women and minorities whenever angry white Americans railed against “wokeness.” Here are ten examples of such bad things: Between 1942 and 1946, more than 120,000 Japanese Americans were rounded up and place in concentration camps for no cause and without legal recourse. Korematsu v. United States (1944). For over two hundred years in America, women had no rights over their bodies. They were the "property" of men. Married men could rape their wives and beat them with impunity. Doctors could impose forced sterilization upon poor women in mental institutions and prisons. A woman's right to an abortion did not exist. Blacks had no rights that white men were bound to respect. Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857). Native Americans were described as “merciless Indian savages” in the Declaration of Independence and millions of them were slaughtered by colonial militias and armies of white men and vigilantes over a 300-year period from 1612 to 1912. In 1970, the U.S. military prepared a plan for the national internment of Black Americans who were deemed to be militant and a threat to white supremacy. Asian immigrants (i.e., Chinese, Japanese, and any other oriental country) were banned outright or restricted from entering America by the Page Act of 1875, the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882, the Geary Act of 1892, and Immigration Act of 1917. Up to 1.5 million non-white Mexican Americans and other non-white Hispanic migrants living in the U.S. legally and illegally were rounded up and deported in 1954 during “Operation Wetback.” In 1964, the FBI tried to force Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., into committing suicide during the Bureau's infamous COINTELPRO program (1956 to 1971). Today, Dr. King is a national hero. The Montgomery, Alabama-based Equal Justice Initiative documented 4,084 "racial terror lynchings" in twelve Southern states (Alabama, Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, North Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, and Virginia) between the end of Reconstruction in 1877 and 1950. Another 300 "racial terror lynching" occurred in Illinois, Indiana, Kansas, Maryland, Missouri, Ohio, Oklahoma, and West Virginia during this period. In California and the Old West, the lynching victims were usually Hispanic Americans, Native Americans, and Asian Americans. On May 31, 1921, an angry lynch mob of 1,500 white men invaded “Black Wall Street” in Greenwood, Oklahoma, shooting and killing hundreds of black residents on the spot. Later estimates put the death toll as high as 3,000. The mob destroyed 1,500 homes and burned down the Greenwood business district, thereby wiping out over 600 successful black-owned businesses. After two days of mob violence, “Black Wall Street" was gone. What part of this American experience was "great," and for whom? It certainly was not "great" for me while I was experiencing the America depicted in the photo below as a young child and teenager growing up in Montgomery, Alabama. Thankfully, God populated my life with: (a) loving parents who were able to explain this open racial hatred to me while I was a young child, (b) a childhood pastor (Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.) who taught me how to shower my haters with "agape love," and (c) a multiracial constellation of true friends who lifted me up as I traveled life's journey. Of course, it is illegal today to teach these ten historical facts in public schools located in MAGA-controlled, Deep South, "Red States." We all know why.
- American Beach: A Case Study in Black Economic Empowerment
By Donald V. Watkins ©Copyrighted and Published on September 17, 2018; Updated on July 20, 2024 The little girl in the beach resort picture is Claudia Rose Watkins. She is my daughter. This photograph was taken on a vacation trip we took to Amelia Island Plantation resort on Amelia Island, Florida. Claudia was nearly six-years-old when this picture was snapped and I thought it was time for her introduction to an important part of African-American history. While touring Amelia Island, I showed Claudia an area called American Beach. I explained American Beach’s remarkable history in American society. American Beach is a pristine 33-acre beach front area located between the Summer Beach resort, a 450-acre complex that includes homes, a Ritz-Carlton Hotel, and seven condominium buildings to the north and Amelia Island Plantation, a 1,330-acre resort and residential community that includes a hotel and two condominium buildings to the south. Abraham Lincoln Lewis, a black entrepreneur and insurance company owner, developed American Beach for African-Americans during the era of Jim Crow racial segregation. At the time, beaches across the South were designated “For Whites Only” because white men did not want black men and boys to see white women and girls clad in swimsuits. Any black man or boy who looked at a white woman or girl clad in a swimsuit was at risk of being lynched. This history of American Beach is chronicled below: “American Beach, the only beach in Florida that welcomed black Americans and offered safe, secure overnight accommodations during Jim Crow segregation, was founded in 1935 by the Afro-American Life Insurance Company (AALIC), which was established in 1901 to provide the Jacksonville, Florida black community with life insurance. The firm’s Afro-American Pension Bureau purchased a 33-acre piece of property at the beach on nearby Amelia Island, partly as an investment but also to provide it as a resort area for black Floridians who had been excluded from other beaches. Abraham Lincoln Lewis, the President of Afro-American Life, ironically named the area American Beach because he and others felt that in the United States beach access should be open to everyone. Lewis and his partners envisioned a resort that would signify success, self-sufficiency, and respectability for middle-class African American families from Atlanta and Savannah, Georgia. In addition to having beach access, the planned community also allowed for the building of resort and retirement homes. Surveyed and platted on March 12, 1936, the original section of the beach property was added to the US National Register of Historic Places on January 28, 2002 as being worthy of historic preservation and marker designation. Florida’s first black millionaires and largest landowners established homes there and encouraged other blacks to build homes and create the small businesses that they often dreamed of owning. Between the late 1930s and the 1950s, tourists traveled for miles to frequent this black-owned oasis, passing dozens of resorts that were off limits to them, as made evident by the “For Whites Only” signs. Eventually, prominent entertainers made their way to the famous seaside pavilion that, over the years, hosted musicians like Cab Calloway, Ray Charles, and Duke Ellington. For nearly three decades, American Beach thrived as an all-black recreational beach resort whose population swelled greatly in the summer months. With the advent of integration, the beach lost customers to other resorts that were now open to African Americans. Nature, however, played a role in American Beach’s decline as well. In 1964 Hurricane Dora destroyed many homes and businesses and owners either would not or could not afford to rebuild. Consequently, like similar resorts across the nation, American Beach residents often abandoned or sold their properties—or, if they were not property owners, simply stopped visiting. Nonetheless a small loyal group of multigenerational American Beach families kept their properties and, by the 1980s, attracted a new wave of prominent owners including tennis star Leslie Allen, TV actress Barbara Montgomery, and Emory University professor Eugene Emory. Prominent educator Johnnetta Cole also encouraged the revival of the resort. She and her sister, MaVynee Betsch, known locally as the Beach Lady because of her long residence in American Beach, have established the A.L. Lewis Historical Society (as a tribute to their great-grandfather who is the founder of the community) and have developed the American Beach Museum to preserve the beach community’s unusual history.” Today, Claudia is a grown woman who is living and working in London with an international circle of friends and a bright future in global business. Remarkably, American Beach still exists, but it is experiencing a transition. The modest vacation homes from the 1930s share space with vacant lots, abandoned buildings, and newer, more elegant structures. Though small in area, American Beach continues to play a large and important role in African-American history.
- Donna Michelle Wallace: Was Her Death a Suicide or Murder?
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on June 26, 2024 A SPECIAL INVESTIGATIVE REPORT --- Donna Michelle Wallace died on November 26, 2017. Her death brought an end to this 36-year-old Alabama woman’s traumatic journey in life. Was Donna’s death a suicide or murder? Was there a police department coverup in Donna's homicide case? Donna was Repeatedly Raped as a Child Donna Michelle Wallace was repeatedly raped beginning when she was seven years old. Donna’s rapist was her stepfather. He also allowed other men who paid him money to rape Donna -- for years. Donna’s stepfather went to prison, where he died. Her mother was arrested but never charged as an accomplice to her rape. Donna, who suffered psychological and emotional trauma as a child rape victim, began drinking alcohol to escape the pain from her childhood sexual abuse. She was in and out of foster homes because of her rambunctious behavior. The state of Alabama eventually sent Donna to a girl's home in Huntsville, Alabama. Once there, Donna rekindled her relationship with Wanda Pacino, her mother’s half-sister, and Rachel Bolton, Wanda's daughter. Donna considered these two relatives to be her closest blood-related family members – the ones who truly loved her. Donna married several times in her 20s, but none of these marriages worked out. Her first marriage was to Trace Cooper. Then, she married Bryan Wheelock. Donna’s third marriage was to Mario Vizcaino. Then, she married Mike Stevens. Donna’s fifth marriage was to Shawn Sellers. It is unclear whether Donna ever legally divorced Shawn Sellers -- a question that becomes critically important on November 26, 2017. This is the date on which Timothy Keith Wallace, Donna’s sixth husband, approved a recommendation by doctors to take Donna off life support following a gunshot wound to her head in their home four days earlier. Donna’s Eight-Month Marriage to Timothy Keith Wallace By the time Donna reached her early 30s, she met and fell in love with Timothy Wallace, 51, a veteran police investigator with the Huntsville, Alabama Police Department (HPD). Wallace holds Bachelors and Masters Degrees in Pyschology. Unbeknownst to Donna, Wallace had already been entangled in a domestic violence situation that warranted his arrest three years earlier. On June 9, 2014, Timothy Wallace was arrested at his home on a domestic violence charge. It is believed that the “victim" in that case was one of Wallace's sons. Wallace was released from jail on the same day. Wallace’s arrest record for domestic violence and the disposition of his case have since been expunged from the state of Alabama’s criminal court case records. On April 15, 2016, Timothy Wallace’s then-wife, Angela Kaye Wallace, filed for a divorce from him. She was represented by Huntsville divorce attorney Amy Ann Slayden. Timothy Wallace was initially represented in his divorce proceedings by Huntsville attorney Page Ann Banks. Wallace replaced Banks with Robin Leann White, a former Madison County assistant district attorney who has served as an Assistant U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of Alabama since September 2018. For reasons that are not explained in the case, court records in this 2016 divorce case list Ms. White’s Department of Justice email address for contact purposes. The couple was divorced on December 15, 2016. On March 24, 2017, Donna married Timothy Wallace at the “Marry Me of Tennessee.” At the time, there appeared to be no record of Donna's divorce from Shawn Sellers, who refused to sign her divorce papers. Was Donna Physically Abused by Timothy Keith Wallace? On November 17, 2017, Donna Wallace suffered a severe injury to the back of her head while she was with Wallace in the dining room of the apartment where the couple lived. Timothy Wallace took Donna to the Emergency Room. On November 19, Donna sent a photograph of her head injury to Wanda Pacino. Donna told Pacino she blacked out, but she did not know what caused her to blackout. Likewise, Donna did not know what object caused the blunt force trauma to the back of her head. When Donna was alone at the hospital, a staff member asked her whether she thought her husband caused this injury. Donna said she did not think so. Dr. Mathias Allen, an Emergency Room doctor at Huntsville Hospital, diagnosed the injury as “Hemorrhage subdural traumatic w/o LOC Fx skull, unspecified, closed.” In other words, Donna had a skull fracture with bleeding on and around her brain. After Donna was discharged, Timothy Wallace took her home. At the urging of Wanda Pacino, who is a registered LPN, Donna returned to the hospital on November 19th. Donna was experiencing excruciating pain and the concussion had her vomiting alot. Based upon a text Donna sent Pacino that day, she still had blood on her brain. However, she was now resting at home. In an April 2023 meeting between Wanda Pacino, Rachel Bolton, their private investigator (David Hill), and HPD investigator Jay Johnson (who was assigned to Donna's homicide case), Johnson admitted that he was unaware of the incident involving Donna's traumatic head injury. This admission was strange given the fact that the blunt force trauma to Donna's head occurred only five days prior to the shooting. Furthermore, Donna's "head injury" is specifically mentioned in the first line of the "Narrative" section of the HPD Incident Report. Johnson's shocking admission occurred after he claimed HPD looked into all of the pertinent facts and circumstances surrounding Donna’s death and noted that he had 25 years of experience as a homicide investigator. Was Donna Wallace Murdered? On the morning of November 22, 2017, Timothy Wallace reported that he found Donna in their bedroom with a gunshot on the right side of her head. The bullet came from Wallace’s registered service gun -- an “Automatic Handgun.” Timothy Wallace claimed he slept in another bedroom with his children on the night of November 21, 2017, because the couple had been arguing over Donna's drinking that night. Wallace told Wanda Pacino he did not hear a gunshot after he left Donna to go to bed for the night. Wallace told Pacino he was awaken by a call from his boss at 9 a.m. After the call, he went into the bedroom and found Donna with a gunshot wound to her head. There is no reference in the Incident Report to Timothy Wallace making a 911 call. Such a call would have recorded Wallace's voice, shed light on his demeanor, and captured any emotional distress in his voice at the time. It appears that Wallace may have called his sergeant back to report the shooting. After this call, HPD officers came to the scene to investigate the shooting. It appears that no outside agency joined HPD at the scene to conduct an independent investigation into this officer-related shooting. At the time of the shooting, Timothy Wallace was well-connected in the HPD, from top to bottom. There is no indication in the Incident Report as to who called an ambulance to the scene and when this call was made. Likewise, there is no indication as to how long a critically wounded Donna remained at the scene before she was taken to the hospital. HPD Officer Christopher L. Wellman prepared the Incident Report on this shooting incident. Wellman noted the presence of nine additional HPD officers at the scene. The HPD investigators and other officers at the scene were friends or colleagues of Timothy Wallace. They retrieved four guns, several notes, a cell phone, and one fired bullet from the scene, which they logged-in as evidence. During the investigation, HPD officers treated Timothy Wallace more like a friend and fellow co-worker than a possible suspect in the shooting of Donna Wallace. Wallace told Wanda Pacino that investigators only asked him the most basic questions about what had happened. Nothing in the Incident Report indicates that the HPD investigators tested Timothy Wallace’s hands and clothes to determine if he fired the shot that gravely wounded Donna and eventually caused her death. The Report is also silent on whether investigators tested Donna’s hands and clothes for gunpowder residue. Furthermore, there is no reference to any kind of blood spatter analysis at the scene. In one of his conversations with Wanda Pacino, Timothy Wallace admitted that he picked up the gun used in this homicide case after he found Donna in the bedroom. Wallace claims he placed the gun back where he found it. This unusual action by a trained law enforcement crime scene investigator assured that Wallace’s finger prints were most likely the last ones on the gun that was used to shoot Donna. The Couple Had Been Arguing Before the Shooting “Tim states that he and [his] wife were in disagreement about her drinking while she was recovering from a head injury,” said the Incident Report. The use of Wallace’s first name only in the narrative portion of an official police report is indicative of how close Timothy Wallace was to Officer Wellman. No name is used for the "wife" in that sentence. The couple had been arguing on the night of November 21st, and Donna left her house to get away from Wallace. She threatened to go to Birmingham but went to a local bar instead. The couple continued to argue over the phone after Donna left their apartment. According to Wanda Pacino, Timothy Wallace and his son Austin went out and found Donna. Timothy and Donna rode home together, while Austin drove Donna’s car home. Upon arrival at their apartment, the couple continued to argue. Wallace told Pacino he eventually went into another bedroom where most or all of Wallace's nine children were located and fell asleep. Donna tried to call Wanda Pacino at 3:34 a.m. on November 22nd, but Pacino was asleep and missed the call. This indicates that the shooting occurred that morning between 3:34 a.m. and 9:00 a.m., when Timothy Wallace said he woke up and found a gravely wounded Donna in her bedroom. There is conflicting evidence as to whether Timothy Wallace heard the gunshot. In the 2023 meeting between Investigator Jay Johnson and Donna's family members, Johnson said Wallace heard the gunshot. Wallace, however, told Wanda Pacino he did not hear it. When apprised of this contradictory fact, Investigator Johnson then said one of the children at the apartment must have heard the gunshot. In any event, no one at the crowded apartment called 911 immediately after hearing the gunshot. The HPD classified the shooting as an “Attempted Suicide." The investigation was closed on December 1, 2017, after Jay Johnson and his team of investigators determined that Donna's death was a "Suicide." On November 26, 2017, Timothy Wallace, acting in his capacity as Donna’s lawful husband (a material fact that is in dispute), approved the medical team's recommendation to take Donna Wallace off life support. With this action, Donna died from the injuries she sustained as a result of the gunshot wound to her head. No autopsy was performed on Donna’s body. Her remains were promptly shipped to Birmingham for organ donation purposes and then returned to Huntsville for cremation. The So-Called "Suicide Notes" In the 2023 meeting between Investigator Jay Johnson and Donna’s family members, Johnson said HPD arrived at the “Suicide” classification based upon what he characterized as “suicide notes” that were found at the scene. After repeated requests for them, the "suicide notes" were eventually provided to Rachel Bolton in April 2024 in response to her attorney's request to the local district attorney and city officials for these records under the Alabama Open Records Act. The so-called “suicide notes” were addressed to Timothy Wallace and three of his children. They were also written in two different inks. Based upon the Incident Report, investigators at the scene did not seize the blue and black ink pens used to write the notes so they could be subjected to fingerprint and DNA testing. The “suicide note” to Timothy Wallace, which referenced Donna’s “brain injury” and “eternal pain,” said, “At this point honey, I just want to die.” The entire note appears below. Nowhere in this note, or in the three notes to Wallace's children, does Donna threaten to take her own life or express a desire to kill herself. Likewise, Donna did not express a desire for Wallace to execute a "mercy killing" of her. In fact, immediately after the separate notes to Wallace's children, Donna made an extensive listing of food items for a hearty family Thanksgiving dinner and desserts on November 23rd. This food listing appears below. After this notation, Donna prepared a forward-looking, work-related note regarding “The Sale of Devonshire,” the company where she worked. This note contained a breakdown of the bonuses and other tangible benefits flowing to Donna and her team from the expected sale of Devonshire. Again, there is no indication in the Incident Report as to whether HPD tested these notes for the presence of Timothy Wallace's DNA on them. This testing would have been highly relevant to the investigation, especially with respect to the note about Donna's bonus money from the expected sale of Devonshire. Has HPD Stonewalled the Family’s Search for the Truth Regarding Donna’s Homicide? Wanda Pacino and Rachel Bolton have not been able to gain access to the full HPD investigative file in Donna's homicide case, despite their repeated requests for access to the file. Donna's homicide case has been closed since December 1, 2017. Since her death, HPD and city's Legal Department have only made the first two pages of its Incident Report and the so-called "suicide notes" available to Donna's family. As late as the April 2023 meeting, Investigator Jay Johnson was still referring Donna's family to the city's Legal Department for access to the investigative file even though (a) the statute of limitations for any possible civil wrongful death lawsuit against the city expired four years earlier and (b) Johnson had previously asked the Legal Department to NOT provide any case-related information to Donna's family. During the 2023 meeting, Investigator Johnson inadvertently referred to Donna’s death as a “murder” before quickly correcting himself after he realized the implications of using the word "murder" in front of family members of the deceased in a homicide case involving a fellow police officer. There is no public record that Donna Michelle Wallace's homicide case was ever presented to a Madison County grand jury for an independent review of the pertinent facts and circumstances surrounding her death. Furthermore, Wanda Pacino and Rachel Bolton obviously possess highly pertinent information and documents about Donna's homicide case. Yet, they were never interviewed by Jay Johnson or any other homicide investigator. Likewise, they were never called as witnesses before a Madison County grand jury that was investigating Donna's homicide. Regardless, Donna's family never stopped fighting for justice in her case. They continue to believe in Alabama's criminal justice system and want a fair, impartial, and independent investigation into Donna's death. There is no statute of limitations for murder in Alabama.











