Search Results
Search this site
1309 results found with an empty search
- Judge Matthis W. Piel: In the End, Justice Prevailed
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published January 13, 2022 An Editorial Opinion In 1974, I was a young associate in the civil rights law firm of Gray, Seay, and Langford. At the time, there were less than a dozen black lawyers working in Alabama. All of us litigated cases. The frontlines in the raging battle for equal justice for African-Americans in Alabama were located in local, state, and federal courtrooms. Young black lawyers like me did not have the luxury of apprenticing for years under the firm's senior trial lawyers -- Fred D. Gray, Solomon S. Seay, Jr., and Charles D. Langford. They were bogged downed handling massive class action cases. Fred was working feverishly to secure justice for 623 black plaintiffs in the Tuskegee Syphilis Study. Solomon was swamped with major school desegregation cases throughout Alabama. Charles was handling a lot of the firm's non-civil rights cases. I was sent straight to the frontlines to represent individual clients like Mr. Clarence Norris, the last surviving "Scottsboro Boy," Elizabeth Williams, a black woman who was sentenced to 218 years in prison for aiding her boyfriend in stealing three chickens, and Bernard Whitehurst, an unarmed and innocent black man who was fatally shot in the back by a racist white Montgomery police officer after he was mistakenly identified as a robbery suspect. I was taught to stand tall for my clients and unload all of my evidence in every case. I was also taught that my real adversary in my cases would be the trial judge since all of them were white and almost always hostile towards our clients and us. One of the worst judges in Alabama at the time was Matthis W. Piel, the chief judge of the Montgomery, Alabama municipal court. Judge Piel was a flaming racist. He presided over the city's misdemeanor court docket. The prosecutors in his court were white. Nearly all of the officers on the city police force in the early 1970s were white. Judge Piel's courtroom was a living hell for black lawyers and their clients. It was also a classic "debtor's court" -- one where black men and women were railroaded, imprisoned, fined, and held in jail until their fines were paid. Wealthy and upper middle-class white offenders could have their cases "fixed" by making a call to the mayor's office or Judge Piel's chambers. Middle-class and extremely poor white offenders would typically be scolded by Piel, but they would not be jailed. During my first trial in Judge Piel's court, I brought law books with U.S. Supreme Court case to support my legal arguments. When Piel saw the Supreme Court law books, he promptly told me, "that shit does not apply in my court." Piel never looked me in the eyes, or called me "Mr. Watkins," or "Counselor," or "Sir," or any name or title that would affirm my humanity. He just held his head down and barked out his remarks to me. It was in Judge Piel's courtroom that I had my first encounter with an arrogant, out-of-control, racist Montgomery police officer. His name was Officer Ronald A. Rambo. He was the chief witness in the case against my client. I crucified him on cross-examination. Once Rambo stepped down from the witness stand, he came up to me and put his finger in my face. Rambo said in a loud voice, "you must be new; you don't know who you are fucking with." I look over at Judge Piel, who did not say a word. Piel did not bang his gavel to restore order in his court, and he did not reprimand Officer Rambo. When I realized that I was on my own, I responded to Rambo in a loud voice by telling him to "kiss my ass." The black folks in the packed courtroom exploded into loud cheers and applause. Rambo backed off and said, "nigger, we're going to teach you a lesson." Piel said nothing. She Was Black, Elderly, Alone, Afraid, Crying, Praying, and Needed My Help One day, I was in Judge Piel's courtroom waiting for my client's case to be called. While sitting on the front row studying my case file and trial outline, I heard Judge Piel and the prosecutor loudly berating an elderly black woman in a maid's uniform. The woman did not have a lawyer representing her. She was alone, afraid, and unprotected in a very hostile courtroom. Piel and the prosecutor were bombarding this woman with questions that she clearly did not understand. In frustration, the woman bowed her head and started crying and praying. I couldn't take it anymore. I jumped from my seat and rushed to this woman's side. I forcefully interrupted the beat-down of this elderly woman and announced to Judge Piel that I was her lawyer. I apologized for not hearing her name called on the docket. In truth, I didn't even know the woman's name and we did not have time to get acquainted. I announced that we were ready for trial and asked the city to call its first witness. I didn't know anything about this woman's case. I put my arms around the woman and told her everything would be okay. The City called one police officer and two civilian witnesses. Out of rage and anger, I obliterated all three witnesses with a blistering, in-your-face, cross-examination of them. The witnesses were intimidated by my aggressive style of cross-examination and their testimony quickly fell apart, leaving Judge Piel with no option but to acquit this woman. She was shocked that we had won her case, but she was very happy. Blacks in the courtroom swarmed the woman and me to celebrate this rare victory and to give us accolades. I walked the woman out of Judge Piel's courtroom. Now, her tears of fear and despair had turned into tears of joy. She was a single mom with five children. She had no car, no money, and no hope of justice. This is why she bowed her head and prayed as Judge Piel and the prosecutor berated her with sarcastic words and questions. She thanked me over and over again, saying God had answered her prayers. The woman told me she had no way to pay me. I told her that a wise janitor at the University of Alabama's law school -- Mr. Ramus Rhodes -- had paid the full price for me to stand up for her in Judge Piel's courtroom and that she owed me nothing. We hugged. I dried the woman's tears with my handkerchief. After we said goodbye to each other, I rushed back into Judge Piel's courtroom for my next battle against the seemingly endless war against white racism. Reversal of Fortunes On October 9, 1979, I was elected to the Montgomery city council. I was the youngest council member in the history of the city. I was one of four black council members on the nine-member Montgomery city council. I was also the only lawyer on the council. Shortly after taking office, Judge Piel's term of office was nearing an end and he desperately wanted reappointment to another six-year term. Judge Piel called for an appointment to see me. I told him I would come see him at his chambers in the municipal court, which I did. When I entered Judge Piel's chambers, he was lying on a couch. Piel's body was too ravaged with cancer for him to sit up during our meeting. He asked for my vote for his reappointment. He desperately needed reappointment to his judgeship to maintain his municipal employee health insurance coverage during this difficult period in his life. The council was split 4 to 4 between Judge Piel and another candidate who was backed by Council President Willie Peake for this judgeship. Peake was an independent, fair-minded white businessman who always voted based upon the best interests of his district constituents and the city as a whole. For over an hour, I listened to Judge Piel pitch his case for reappointment. The entire time Judge Piel was talking, all I could see in my mind's eye were the images of the black defendants Piel railroaded in his courtroom. I saw their tears. I felt their pain. I heard their wailing spirits. I didn't say a word while Piel talked. When Judge Piel finished, he was crying and begging for my vote. I told him I would talk to my neighborhood leaders and district residents to see how they wanted me to vote on his reappointment. A few days later, the all-white local Bar association, Rotary Club, Chamber of Commerce, and several white business groups lobbied me to support Piel's reappointment. These groups had zero interest in how blacks were treated in Piel's courtroom. On the day of the council meeting, the votes were still split 4 to 4, with Peake and three blacks supporting Peake's candidate. The other four whites on the council backed Judge Piel. I asked to speak last before we took the vote. Judge Piel's family and supporters packed the left side of the small council chambers. Piel was present in a wheelchair. His son, Richard, who was a local attorney, was in the audience, as well. My black neighborhood leaders, political constituents, and other black citizens packed the right side of the council chambers. When it was time for me to speak, I told the story of the woman whose case is mentioned in this article. I also told the audience what Judge Piel said to me about U.S. Supreme Court cases not applying in his courtroom. Finally, I mentioned Judge Piel's failure to reign-in Officer Rambo after Rambo verbally assaulted me in Piel's presence. At the end of my speech, I looked at the blacks in the audience and told them, "God knows that you have suffered gross injustice in our municipal courts for over a hundred years; Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., Ms. Rosa Parks, and untold thousands of blacks have been railroaded in this city's court system; God has heard your silent prayers for equal justice in our courts; and He is answering them tonight." With that, I cast the last and deciding vote to get rid of one of the most vicious racists I had encountered in my legal career. Piel's family members wailed loudly as the judge was wheeled out of the council chambers. Once Judge Piel and his supporters were gone, I thanked the blacks who remained in the council chambers for persevering in the vineyards of racial hatred and never giving up on their quest for equal justice. I reminded them that the Montgomery Bus Boycott in the 1950s, the Birmingham church bombing in 1963 that killed four little girls in Sunday School, the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the Selma-to-Montgomery march on "Bloody Sunday," and the passage of the Voting Rights Act of 1965 made this moment possible. The hands that picked cotton, cleaned gutters and sewers, mopped floors and cleaned toilets as maids and janitors, loaded garbage trucks, cut grass, dug ditches, labored in the 120 degree heat on roofing jobs, busted rocks into gravel, cleaned used bricks with meat-cleavers, walked miles to and from work in menial jobs, and languished in Montgomery's notorious debtor's courts, would pick the city of Montgomery's municipal court judges from this day, forward. Epilogue Judge Matthis W. Piel died on January 12, 1980, but his racist spirit lives on in many of today's local, state and federal judges in Alabama. As long as these judicial bigots live and work among us, my work as a "freedom fighter" must go on. "Freedom fighting" is a noble profession. I have always been willing to pay whatever price is necessary to protect the dignity of the "least of these" and to elevate their humanity in every venue. My longstanding commitment to equal justice has made me an extremely controversial figure in Alabama's ultra-conservative white community. In many white circles, I am hated on sight. Today, I am locked in a fierce battle to dismantle Alabama's all-white, 19-judge appellate court system. Joseph W. Perkins, Jr., Alabama Power Company's perennial political "dirty tricks" operator and its paid neutralizer of black political and civil rights leaders, is the chief defender of this modern-day form of judicial apartheid in the Alabama Supreme Court case of Donald V. Watkins, et. al, v. Matrix, LLC, and Joseph W. Perkins, Jr., Case No. 1200892. Alabama's appellate court system was all-white when I started practicing law in 1973, and it is all-white today. This all-white appellate court system is Alabama's shining example to the nation of what white "bloc voting" can accomplish when it is properly motivated to redeem "white supremacy." I am determined to dismantle Alabama's all-white appellate court system in 2022, even if I have to do it alone. IMAGE: Former Montgomery Municipal Judge Matthis W. Piel
- She Was My First Marital Rape Client
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on April 5, 2025 Marital rape was legal in Alabama until 1993. Two months after I graduated from the University of Alabama’s law school, I gave a speech at the Southeastern Association of Colored Women’s Clubs, Inc . In my July 31, 1973, speech, I paid a tribute to my mother, my three sisters, and my female cousins, all of whom were trailblazers and all of whom had blocked for me on the playing field of life since childhood. Because of my lifelong exposure to these powerful women, I revered strong, smart women who were trailblazing in America’s male-dominated society. My law practice for the next 46 years would be dedicated to leveling the playing field for women and Blacks in Alabama and elsewhere. Throughout my career, I would use law as a tool to uplift the downtrodden members of society. She was the Victim of Marital Rape It was the Spring of 1976 when I got a call from my first marital rape victim. I am withholding her name for privacy reasons. The woman called me from the Sand Mountain area in northeast Alabama and asked for an appointment to see me about a divorce. Days later, she drove to my Montgomery office on the day of her appointment. She was an attractive, middle-aged woman who was tired of being raped and physically abused by her husband. He was a high-ranking officer in the Alabama State Troopers. She was my first white divorce client. She was very professional and courteous, but deeply wounded as a woman. Even though I had only been practicing law since 1973, I already had a statewide reputation for standing up for women’s rights. My legal work in the women’s rights movement started immediately after I passed my Alabama Bar exams in September 1973. Divorce cases was one of my specialty areas for the first ten years out of my law practice. I only represented women in these cases. In my divorce cases, I tended to crucify men who did not financially support their children, as well as those who physically abused or raped their wives. I showed no mercy for marital rapists. The more abuse my divorce clients suffered, the harder I worked to crush their abusers. I perfected creative ways for jailing physical abusers on criminal charges and contempt citations. To me, this was the only behavioral modification technique that worked quickly and effectively. In Alabama, marital rape would not become illegal until 1993 when the state legislature repealed the marital rape exemption that prevented husbands from being charged with rape for sexual acts committed against their wives. Meeting My Client’s Husband As a courtesy, I contacted my client’s husband (who worked in Montgomery) and asked him for a meeting before I filed her complaint. He obliged me, but he did not want to meet in my office. Instead, the husband came in his unmarked State Trooper car to pick me up from my office. During our drive around downtown Montgomery, the husband, who was armed, threatened to “ fuck [me] up ” if I represented his wife. He called me an “ arrogant, uppity nigger ” who was getting out of my place. I listened to this man’s racial slurs and profanity-laced rant, without saying much. When my client’s husband finished driving me around, he let me out in front of my office. As I exited the car, I leaned in and told this man I would see him in court. His face turned fire engine red. My client gave me authorization to file the divorce complaint. I loaded the husband down with a detailed divorce complaint and a ton of simultaneously filed discovery requests. I also filed a simultaneous motion for an emergency restraining order to keep him away from my client during the divorce proceedings. The Order was quickly granted after her husband failed to show for the hearing. For the next three weeks, I subjected the husband to a Blitzkrieg technique I would later call “ laser litigation .” It broke him right away and he agreed to the divorce settlement my client wanted. My client was elated. Her physical abuse ended from the moment the husband met me in Montgomery. I did not care about his racial slurs or threats of physical harm, which I had experienced from so many white police officers, white attorneys, and white judges before I met him. I just wanted my client’s dignity and freedom restored. We secured her divorce, her dignity as a woman, and her freedom in record time. Epilogue My client’s case (and others who were similarly situated) went a long way toward ending marital rape in Alabama. Word of her case spread quickly within the ranks of Alabama’s law enforcement community. She was an extremely brave woman. It was an honor to represent her. I stayed in touch with my client, via phone calls, for many years. I will never forget her courage and commitment to ending marital rape for women in Alabama. I ended my divorce practice in 1983 because it was skewing my view of the institution of marriage and making me increasingly hostile toward married men who emotionally, physically, and sexually abused their wives. I was beginning to take great pleasure in punishing these abusers, which I knew was not right. Ten years later, Alabama ended a husband’s legal right to rape his wife. Hopefully, our society, in its quest to "Make America Great Again," will never go back to that place in time.
- Alabama AG Steve Marshall Loses Major Abortion-Related Case
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on April 1, 2025 Steve Marshall (left) shakes the hand of disgraced former Governor Robert Bentley after Bentley appointed him as Alabama's new Attorney General in April 2017. An Editorial Opinion In the aftermath of the U.S. Supreme Court case in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization (2022) that paved the way for states to impose near-total bans on abortion, Alabama Attorney Steve Marshall threatened criminal prosecution of any person or group promoting and/or facilitating out-of-state abortions in states where this medical procedure is legal. Yesterday, a U.S. District Court in Montgomery, Alabama ruled that Marshall’s threat of criminal prosecution constitutes an unconstitutional restriction on the plaintiffs’ right to travel and freedom of speech. The Court’s March 31, 2025, 131-page ruling is linked here. This ruling is a high-profile defeat for Marshall, who is on a losing streak in major constitutional law cases. On June 8, 2023, Marshall lost the Allen v. Milligan voting rights case in the ultra-conservative U.S. Supreme Court. As a result, Alabama gained a second Black Congressional member in the 2024 elections. In yesterday's right to travel case, the Court stated that Marshall’s legal arguments contravened "history, precedent, and common sense . " (Page 67). That’s the Court’s charitable way of saying Marshall’s legal arguments were dumb. Steve Marshall was initially appointed as Attorney General by disgraced former Governor Robert Bentley in April 2017 in the governor's effort to escape criminal liability on ethics charges in his “sex-for-power” scandal. Bentley scoured the state for the weakest and most inexperienced prosecutor he could appoint as Attorney General. The search yielded Marshall County District Attorney Steve Marshall, who possessed a “powder-puff” resume and marginal list of greatly embellished “achievements.” Inside Alabama political circles, Steve Marshall is generally considered to be weaker and dumber than former state Attorney General/U.S. Senator/U.S. Attorney General Jeff Sessions. President Donald Trump fired Sessions in November 2018 after he proved to be dumb and disloyal. Marshall, whose appointment as Attorney General resulted strictly from a pure act of “Good Ol’ Boys affirmative action,” has amassed a distinguished record of (a) avoiding criminal prosecutions of corrupt corporate executives and dangerous street gangs, (b) violating constitutional rights, and (c) losing high-profile civil cases. Marshall rarely stands up for the rights of any person outside of a mother's womb.
- Trump is Not Leaving the Presidency, Voluntarily
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on March 31, 2025 President Donald J. Trump An Editorial Opinion Yesterday, President Donald Trump confirmed that he plans to stay in office beyond his second term, which expires in January 2029. Most people have dismissed the possibility of this event happening. I have not. Political pundits and media voices have consistently underestimated Trump’s dogged ability to reach his political goals, even though he has won the presidency twice -- against incredible odds. They are underestimating him, again. Trump already has a game plan to remain in power and a willlingness to do whatever it takes to accomplish this goal. Trump has remade the presidency into an Imperial Presidency, with no “checks and balances” from Congress and with a grant of immunity from criminal prosecution from his MAGA-controlled U.S. Supreme Court. Donald Trump is not going to leave the presidency, voluntarily. To the contrary, Trump is fully executing a “Manifest Destiny” plan that includes: (a) staying in power beyond his term, (b) seizing the sovereign nation of Canada and the Danish territory of Greenland, and (c) using military force, if necessary, to prevent a regime change in America in January 2029. The Political Infrastructure is in Place for Trump to Stay in Power Beyond January 2029 Sometime in early 2028, Trump will likely declare a national state of emergency due to alleged widespread threats of domestic terrorism, foreign threats of armed conflict against the U.S. interests, and military action Trump is expected to initiate in the Middle East. Against this backdrop, Trump will impose martial law and suspend the Constitution until new elections can be held in 2032. Trump has already seized ironclad control of the governmental bodies he needs to remain in power, via martial law. He has a dictatorial grip over the U.S. military (via Pete Hegseth), the U.S. Attorney General (via Pam Bondi), the FBI (via Kash Patel), Homeland Security (via Christi Noem), the CIA (via John Ratcliffe), the National Intelligence Agencies (via Tulsi Gabbard), the U.S. Congress, the Republican Party, “Red state” governors, the U.S. Supreme Court, Wall Street, Fox News, X (formerly known as Twitter), Facebook, Instagram, and a host of other government agencies and major corporations that form the backbone of America. The heads of these government agencies, media groups, and corporations suck-up to Donald Trump on a daily basis. None of them exercises independent judgment on domestic affairs. Elon Musk, who has shown a propensity to seek and attain “above the law” status in all matters of interest to him, is Trump’s sidekick, enabler, and First Buddy. This South African native, whose family thrived during the country’s apartheid-era “white minority rule” government, is no stranger to supporting unpopular public figures and nefarious governance schemes. America Now Has an Imperial President Running the Country What used to be a democracy in America has morphed into an Imperial Presidency, with a supporting oligarchy. Trump is the Imperial President. Super-wealthy corporations and individuals are the devoted oligarchs. We call them the “One Percenters.” Their wealth is measured every day on Wall Street and is protected by Congress, the U.S. Supreme Court, and every U.S. president. In 2010, in the case of Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission , the U.S. Supreme Court gave wealthy corporations the legal right to buy elected officials in America, which they promptly did. This is why tax laws favor the rich and why wealthy corporations and Wall Street banks always get bailed out in times of great economic crisis. Prior to the outbreak of COVID-19 in America in February 2020, Trump was exploring a proposal to extend his term in office by repealing the 22nd Amendment, which limits a president to two terms in office. Trump was inspired to extend his term in office by the example he saw with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin. Both men ushered in changes to their countries’ constitutions that effectively made them presidents for life. Both men serve as role models for Trump in the art of governing a nation with a dictatorial grip. A Majority of Americans May Support Trump's Martial Law Plan Trump believes his diehard base of MAGA supporters and the “One Percenters” will back his plan to remain in office. To them, the end-result of permanent "MAGA-Rule" on the American political scene justifies the means necessary to achieve it. In addition to declaring a national state of emergency, Trump will likely use federal agents and military troops to enforce martial law in America, particularly in cities and states that are governed by Democrats. Trump has already characterized these areas as hot zones for violence, rioting, and lawlessness. The blueprint for Trump's use of the military for the mass incarceration of American dissenters already exists. A 1970 document written by Louis O. Giuffrada at the U.S. Army War College in Pennsylvania titled, “ National Survival-Racial Imperative ,” provides elaborate details of a federal government plan to round up black Americans and place them in concentration camps across America, if necessary for national security. Giuffrada, who was a full colonel in the Military Police Corps in 1970, later became President Ronald Reagan’s FEMA director. Giuffrada's Plan is chilling in its graphic profile of race relations America. It described a level of white "anger" in 1970 that is eerily similar to the "anti-DEI" anger Donald Trump has tapped into today. Epilogue Donald Trump is predictable. He wanted to transform the presidency, and he did. Republicans and Democrats, alike, are afraid of his Imperial Presidency. America now has an authoritarian ruler who issues presidential edicts (i.e., Executive Orders) every day. On August 1, 2015, I published the first article in America that predicted Donald Trump’s victory in 2016, and explained why. In March 2020, I predicted Trump's defeat due to his mismanagement of the COVID-19 pandemic response. In September 2024, I predicted Trump's victory for a second term in the White House. Today, I am predicting that Trump will not leave office voluntarily when his term expires in January 2029. The ruling oligarchy in America will back his decision to remain in office as the nation's first Imperial President. This experience, like many others during the Trump presidency, will be a first in American history.
- New Trump Anti-DEI Executive Order Targets the National Museum of African American History and Culture
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on March 30, 2025 National Museum of African American History and Culture, Washington, D.C. An Editorial Opinion After only ten weeks in office, President Donald Trump’s blitzkrieg against the national policy of Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) has brought him to the front steps of the National Museum of African American History and Culture (NMAAHC) in Washington, D.C. Trump is not there to learn about the painful experience of Black Americans over the last 400 years -- from slavery to ongoing “ cradle to the grave " racial discrimination, as acknowledged by the U.S. Supreme Court on June 8, 2023, in Allen v. Milligan . No, Trump is there to suppress and erase African American history and culture in his effort to restore what he believes is the greatness of the white European colonists who slaughtered millions of Native Americans and enslaved millions of Africans in their quest to make America great. To accomplish his wholesale suppression and erasure of African American history, Trump issued an Executive Order on March 27, 2025, titled, “ Restoring Truth and Sanity to American History .” The Order specifically targets the NMAAHC. The intent and purpose of this Executive Order is stated as follows: “Over the past decade, Americans have witnessed a concerted and widespread effort to rewrite our Nation’s history, replacing objective facts with a distorted narrative driven by ideology rather than truth. This revisionist movement seeks to undermine the remarkable achievements of the United States by casting its founding principles and historical milestones in a negative light. Under this historical revision, our Nation’s unparalleled legacy of advancing liberty, individual rights, and human happiness is reconstructed as inherently racist, sexist, oppressive, or otherwise irredeemably flawed…..”. The Order directs the Secretary of the Interior to: “take action …. to ensure that all public monuments, memorials, statues, markers, or similar properties within the Department of the Interior’s jurisdiction do not contain descriptions, depictions, or other content that inappropriately disparage Americans past or living (including persons living in colonial times), and instead focus on the greatness of the achievements and progress of the American people or, with respect to natural features, the beauty, abundance, and grandeur of the American landscape.” What History is Trump Trying to Erase from Our National Memory? When America was "founded" in the 1,600s by white European colonists in the pursuit of their "Manifest Destiny," slaves of African descent were deemed “chattel property” that could be bought and sold to third parties and/or willed to heirs upon the death of the slaveowner. They were insured as “property,” and could be used as collateral on bank loans. Millions of Africans were enslaved in America for over 250 years. Trump does not want any of this African American history mentioned or displayed in the NMAAHC or any other museum on federal property or on property listed in the National Register of Historic Places . Like slaves of African descent, women in America had no rights that white men were bound to respect. From the time the first colony was founded in Jamestown, Virginia in 1607 until the late 1870s, a woman's husband enjoyed the legal right to (a) beat his wife with a stick no thicker than his thumb, (b) pull her hair, (c) choke her, (d) spit in her face, (d) kick her about the floor, and (e) inflict upon her like indignities. This inhumane treatment of women came to a fitting end through a series of landmark court cases around the nation. Women did not get the right to vote until 1920. Furthermore, a husband’s legal right to rape his wife did not end until 1979. Trump does not want America's historical treatment of women mentioned or displayed in the forthcoming Smithsonian American Women’s History Museum or any other museum on federal property or on property listed in the National Register . The Declaration of Independence explicitly calls Native Americans “ merciless Indian Savages .” Indian Tribes that stood their ground in the face of "Manifest Destiny" were slaughtered -- by the millions -- in horrific ways. The Declaration of Independence also condemned King George’s refusal to return runaway Black slaves to their owners. Of course, Trump moved the original Declaration of Independence into the Oval Office where he shows it off to friends and visitors. None of the events Trump seeks to suppress and erase constitutes “reconstructed” history. These events are explicitly referenced in the nation’s founding documents and law books dating back to the 1600s. According to Trump, the mere acknowledgment of this documented history “ inappropriately disparage(s) Americans past or living (including persons living in colonial times) .” Trump Has Faced No Meaningful Resistance from Today’s Black Leaders The Trump blitzkrieg to erase Black history and culture has faced no meaningful resistance from Black mega-church preachers who fleece their congregations each Sunday for money to finance their heavenly lifestyle on Earth. Likewise, Trump’s Blitzkrieg has faced no meaningful resistance from any state-supported HBCU president, even though many of these presidents have a battery of lawyers and hefty legal budget at their disposal to challenge Trump’s anti-DEI actions in court. Additionally, Trump’s Blitzkrieg has faced no meaningful resistance from Black mayors and county commissioners around the nation, many of whom have fully staffed law departments and litigation budgets to fight Trump’s non-stop assault on DEI initiatives in their cities/counties. Finally, Trump’s anti-DEI Blitzkrieg has faced no meaningful resistance from the Congressional Black Caucus. The issuance of occasional softball press statements by a couple of conscientious Caucus members means nothing to Trump. The lack of any legal action by state-supported land-grant HBCU presidents to challenge Trump's DEI rollback Orders does not surprise me. Trump sees in them what I see -- pure cowardice , psychological castration, and impotence. For example, all 16 state-supported land-grant HBCU institutions received notices from the Biden administration’s Departments of Education and Agriculture on September 18, 2023, that they were owed $13 billion in equitable state funding. Not one of them took legal action to collect the money that was owed to his/her institution. It's too late to get this money now. For the most part, the nation’s Black mayors and other local officials will not fight for their African American constituents because they do not want to offend the Trump-aligned anti-DEI corporations that finance their campaigns. Sadly, these public officials spend more time posting self-glorification photos and memes on social media than fighting Donald Trump on DEI rollbacks. Trump Preserves Confederate Museums on the National Register Amid his attack on the NMAAHC, Donald Trump has chosen to preserve and protect the First White House of the Confederacy in Montgomery, Alabama. This museum stands enshrined on the state Capitol grounds in Montgomery, Alabama. It is an enduring symbol of states rights, Confederate heritage, and Confederate flag-flying Old South glory. First White House of the Confederacy, Montgomery, Alabama. This museum is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. The National Register is the U.S. Department of Interior's official list of sites, buildings, structures, districts, and objects deemed worthy of preservation for their historical significance. As expected, Trump has taken no executive action to remove the First White House of the Confederacy from the National Register. Apparently, this museum does not " inappropriately disparage Americans past or living." Of course, Black slaves were deemed to be sub-human prior to and during the Confederate era. By law, they were "chattel property" and had no rights that white men were bound to respect.
- Doyal Reed: Birmingham’s Last Warrior
By Donald V. Watkins ©Copyrighted and Published on April 29, 2019 Doyal Reed is Birmingham, Alabama's last warrior for economic justice. Reed's MESBIC produced more economic empowerment for Birmingham businesses in a five-year period during the late 1980s and early 1990s than all city officials and local government-sponsored empowerment programs have achieved during the last 25-years. An Editorial Opinion He has been a close friend, trusted advisor, and staunch ally for more than three decades. He has never flinched on the battlefield. He is keenly aware of the various personalities on Birmingham, Alabama’s political scene. He also knows who will “buck dance” for Birmingham’s traditional power-players, and who will not. As a youngster who grew up in the Powderly Hill community of Birmingham and who marched as a child with Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. and Rev. Fred Shuttlesworth during their 1963 “Birmingham Campaign,” this man has been an advocate for equal opportunity, economic justice, and the fair administration of criminal justice since childhood. Like the other children who marched in the “Birmingham Campaign,” this man was willing to risk his life as a child for the betterment of his community, city, and state. His name is Doyal Reed. He is 6’4” tall, smart, tough, and fearless. He has a backbone of steel and a heart of gold. Doyal is Birmingham's last warrior for economic justice. At 66-years-old, Doyal shows no sign of letting up any time soon. Doyal Reed graduated from Wenonah High School in 1971, where he served as president of the student government association during his junior and senior years in high school. In 1975, Doyal graduated from Alabama A&M University (AAMU) with a Bachelor’s degree in Business Administration. After graduating from AAMU, Doyal worked as an in-house accountant for Dr. Richard Arrington, Jr. at the Alabama Center for Higher Education. He then served as a co-campaign manager and political advisor to Dr. Arrington in his successful quest to become Birmingham's first black mayor. Doyal helped Mayor Arrington win a total of five terms as mayor. While working with the Arrington administration, Doyal Reed, Harold Gilchrist, and Myrtis Myles opened the doors of economic opportunity for hundreds of minorities in Birmingham by forming a minority enterprise small business investment company (MESBIC). This government-chartered venture firm provided much needed access to capital to bona fide minority-owned businesses. During the MESBIC’s five-year run in the late 1980s and early 1990s, minority business owners were able to qualify for and win hundreds of millions of dollars in city, county, and private sector contracts for goods and services. While promoting economic empowerment for companies participating in his MESBIC program, Doyal Reed never sought credit for his work. Likewise, Doyal never sought to cash-in on his personal and political relationship with Arrington or any other politician. Doyal Reed only cared about achieving positive results for Birmingham residents and local businesses by: (a) providing minorities a fair shot at competing for government and private sector contracts for goods and services, (b) improving the quality of education in Birmingham public schools, and (c) making sure Birmingham city government delivered all seven basic city services to each one of the city's ninety-nine designated neighborhoods and communities. When I became Mayor Arrington’s special counsel in 1985, Doyal was fighting for disadvantaged businesses that wanted to contribute to the city's economic growth. He was fixated on improving the quality of life for those who never had a shot at competing on a level playing field. When a three-person delegation from Birmingham’s big banks visited Doyal Reed and Harold Gilchrist at their investment banking firm in the late 1980s and told them to distance themselves from Dr. Arrington and me because we were pushing too hard for fair lending practices, economic empowerment, and community reinvestment, Doyal did not do so. Instead, on the next day, Doyal prominently displayed photographs of Dr. Arrington and me on the walls of his office for all visitors to see. Doyal Reed has always made two things very clear to everyone: First, he does not trade old friends for new ones. Second, no man/woman can intimidate him or cause him to become less than a man. To Doyal Reed, hard work, honesty, true friendship, courage, and dedication to cause of equal opportunity and the fair administration of justice are principled goals and personal attributes, whether they are appreciated by all segments of Birmingham society, or not. Ironically, many of the individuals who serve in Birmingham city government today, including Birmingham's mayor and most of the city’s council members, do not seem to care about economic empowerment for minority and women-owned businesses. They appear to be satisfied with the status quo. For reasons that are difficult for me to understand, today’s city officials have achieved far less economic empowerment for minority business enterprises than Doyal Reed accomplished with his MESBIC during a five-year period in the late 1980s and early 1990s when every move toward economic justice was met with massive resistance from the entrenched “Good Ol’ Boy” power structure that ran Birmingham for most of the 20th century. Earlier this month, Doyal Reed brought to my attention that the mayor, council, and park board members fumbled a “once-in-a-lifetime” opportunity to partner with Major League Baseball (MLB). Doyal was shocked at the way all of these city officials bowed down to the wishes of one council member -- Council President Valerie Abbott. Councilor Abbott’s opposition to MLB’s planned project at George Ward Park caused Mayor Randall Woodfin, the other 8 council members, and all five park board members to get on their knees, crawl towards Abbott, and willingly surrender the political interests of their constituents in the MLB project to her. As I have discussed in my five previous articles, MLB planned to invest $10 million in the construction of four full-size baseball fields and a world-class Youth Baseball Academy at George Ward Park. The project would have placed Birmingham on the world map for something other than the infamous 16th Street Baptist Church bombing that killed four little girls and the shocking images of Bull Connor using firehoses and police dogs to attack peaceful civil rights demonstrators. Because of his strong background in economic empowerment, Doyal Reed realized that a partnership with MLB would have given Birmingham a tremendous competitive advantage over cities that do not enjoy such a relationship. After all, MLB is a multi-billion-dollar enterprise that can deliver tangible economic benefits to neighborhood schools, non-profit organizations, local businesses, and civic organizations. After the MLB debacle, I realized that Doyal Reed is the last warrior for economic justice on the Birmingham political scene. He is a good and decent man who has demonstrated his unwavering commitment to the principles of fair play, economic empowerment, and participatory democracy. This is why I admire and respect Doyal Reed. This is why we are close friends to this day. This is why I am telling his untold story. It deserves to be told so that Doyal Reed can take his rightful place in the annals of recorded history. Doyal Reed with civil rights icon Rosa Parks in 1991.
- Robert Archer Martin: One of the Great Ones
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on March 27, 2025 Robert Archer Martin An Editorial Opinion Robert Archer Martin was one of the greatest men in Alabama history. I knew him as Bob Martin. This is his story. Bob Martin began his newspaper career with The Florence Times of Florence, Alabama (now known as The Times Daily ) while attending Florence State University, (now the University of North Alabama). As a college student, Bob began in the mail room, worked in circulation and started covering high school football games. He became a sports reporter and eventually sports editor. He continued to advance at The Times ultimately becoming its executive editor. In 1972, Bob Martin, with his family in tow, followed newly elected Alabama Supreme Court Chief Justice Howell Heflin to Montgomery where Bob began a 25-year career with the Administrative Office of the Courts (AOC) working under Chief Justices Heflin, C.C. “Bo” Torbert, Sonny Hornsby, and Perry Hooper, Sr. In 1989, Bob earned his Juris Doctor from Jones School of Law. Throughout his career in both the newspaper business and as director of the state courts, Bob became friends with and met many important figures in Alabama and around the nation. I met Bob in the early 1980s. We hit it off right away. Bob was a thinker, a visionary, and a problem-solver. Above all, Bob had a backbone of steel and excellent communications skills. When Bob ran AOC, he played a vital role in passing Alabama's Judicial Article (Amendment 328, which was ratified in 1973). The Article unified and standardized the public’s interaction with Alabama courts. Bob also worked his butt off to end generational judicial bias against black lawyers and their clients in courtrooms around the state. He was relentless in his efforts to level the playing field for Alabama's black citizens. I worked closely with Bob throughout the 1980s and 90s on this goal. What made Bob great was his unique ability to effectuate positive change in the state's judiciary, while minimizing the backlash from those who were resistant to any change in the “Good Ol' Boys” arrangement within the courts. Also, Bob’s word was his bond, which is a rarity in today's world. When Bob gave you his word, you could take it to the bank. After spending 25 years with AOC, Bob Martin returned to the news business. Bob purchased The Montgomery Independent in March 1997 and soon after retired from the AOC to dedicate all of his time to the publication. Bob Martin served as President of the Alabama Press Association (APA) Journalism Foundation in 2008. Bob was also a member of the U.S Army Reserve Unit in Sheffield, the Fighting 336th Army APU. Bob Martin died on September 15, 2020 in Montgomery, Alabama. Looking back on it today, no single person did more to eradicate generational white racism in Alabama's judicial system than Bob Martin. He was truly one of the great ones. I really miss him!
- How Advancements in Medicine at Johns Hopkins University Leveled the Playing Field for Black Lawyers in Alabama Courtrooms
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on March 26, 2025 Dr. Patrick Craig Walsh An Editorial Opinion During my 46-year legal career, I learned that two things meant more to Alabama judges than anything else. First, male judges wanted their penises working on command. Second, all judges wanted the hearts working properly. In the early 1980s, whoever could assist Alabama judges with these two medical concerns had the unique ability to level the judicial playing field inside of their courtrooms for competent black lawyers who often experienced judicial bias from these judges solely because of their race. As explained below, this opportunity zone fell into my lap. Fixing “Dicks” Dr. Patrick C. Walsh is a world-renowned urologist, researcher and writer. He is best known for developing "the anatomic approach to radical prostatectomy," which involved nerve-sparing techniques that reduced the likelihood of impotence and urinary incontinence. In plain language, Dr. Walsh developed a technique for prostate cancer surgery that did not leave men's "dicks" impotent and dripping. Dr. Walsh arrived in Baltimore, Maryland in 1974 to serve as the Director of the Brady Urological Institute at John Hopkins University Medical School. He started performing his innovative prostate surgery in 1982. Today , Dr. Walsh is recognized internationally as a pioneer in the diagnosis and treatment of prostate cancer. Fixing Hearts Dr. Walsh was a friend and professional ally of my oldest brother, Dr. Levi Watkins, Jr., a John Hopkins heart surgeon who co-developed and implanted the first automatic defibrillator in a human being in 1980. More than 3 million patients have this device implanted in their bodies today. For several years, Drs. Walsh and Watkins were the only physicians in the world who could performed their innovative surgical techniques on the body parts that men cherish the most – their "dicks" and hearts. The waitlists to see Dr. Walsh for a radical prostatectomy and Dr. Watkins for an implantable defibrillator were nearly a year long. Men from all over the world and all walks of life wanted the specialized medical services these two trailblazing physicians provided. As a matter of professional courtesy and because of their close personal friendship, Walsh could usher someone to the front of Dr. Watkins’ line, and Levi could do the same for the line of patients waiting to see Dr. Walsh. Judicial Demand in Alabama for Specialized Medical Services Beginning in 1980, people from all over Alabama, including judges, called me in an effort to get a priority spot in the front of the line for my brother’s automatic implantable defibrillator. The calls for medical assistance exploded when Dr. Walsh began performing his pioneering prostate surgical procedure in 1982. For some reason, judges begged to be placed in the front of Walsh's prostate surgery line. Levi and I were extremely close. He desegrated Vanderbilt University's medical school and I desgregated the University of Alabama's law school. We knew, first hand, how widespread and vicious white racism was in Alabama and other southern states in the 1970s and 80s. What is more, both of us were raised to be bridge builders. After I entered the legal profession in 1973 and experienced judicial racism on a Richter Scale of 10, I wanted a level playing field for myself and other black lawyers in the courts of Alabama. The only affirmative action I had seen in the legal system came in the form of white judges cheating in their courtrooms for the benefit of my white opposing attorneys. I could count on that cheating like I could count of the sun rising each morning. By 1980, Levi and I realized we could use cutting-edge medical advancements at Johns Hopkins to level the playing field for competent black lawyers in Alabama. So, we decided to turn the unsolicited requests from ailing Alabama judges into a leveling program for competent black lawyers who were being unfairly railroaded in Alabama courtrooms. We started with the implantable defibrillators in 1980 and expanded the program to include Dr. Walsh's prostate surgery technique in 1982. Frankly, Levi was stunned that white judges in Alabama were leaning on me to get their “dicks” and hearts fixed at Johns Hopkins. He did not think they were worthy of jumping the line. Outside of our de facto courtroom leveling program, they were not. So, from time to time, Levi and I used priority access to the pioneering advancements in cardiovascular and urological treatment procedures at John Hopkins Medical Center to level the playing field for the competent black lawyers who suffered unimaginable racism and abuse in Alabama’s white male dominated courtrooms in the 1980s. Once the judicial playing field was level, these lawyers were able to showcase their legal skills and win the cases they deserved to win.
- Benjamin Bryan Starr: One of the Great Ones
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on March 24, 2025 Legendary NFL quarterback Bart Starr (left) with his father Benjamin Bryan Starr (right). An Editorial Opinion Most people knew Benjamin Bryan Starr as the father of legendary NFL quarterback Bart Starr. I knew him in a totally different way. When I met Benjamin Bryan Starr, the judges, court personnel, and attorneys in the Montgomery County, Alabama Courthouse called him “Chief Starr.” The former World War II Air Force veteran served as a bailiff in the courthouse following his retirement as a labor foreman with the state highway department. Chief Starr, who was of Native American descent, took a special interest in me during his years as a bailiff in the courthouse. He admired my work in the high-profile Bernard Whitehurst and Scottsboro Boys cases in the 1970s. A Powerful Ally In his own way, Chief Starr blocked for me within the walls of the Montgomery County courthouse during the early 1980s much like Mary Griffin Auburtin blocked for me in the Perry County courthouse during the 1970s. Both courthouse icons made it their mission to minimize the amount of bigotry and racism I experienced from judges and court personnel in their courthouses. Like Auburtin, Chief Starr was openly friendly with me. He was also very knowledgeable about courthouse politics, and he freely shared this knowledge with me. Chief Starr loved to walk me into the judge’s private chambers right before the start of my trials. There, he would announce that I was a good guy and a friend of his. Like Auburtin, Chief Starr was a powerful and dependable courthouse ally. He truly believed in equal justice. Chief Starr attended my trials whenever he could. Through his body language and other visible courtroom gestures, the well-known father of Bart Starr made sure the jurors in my cases knew that he had a favorable opinion of me. These actions mattered in winning my cases in the Montgomery County courthouse. They also contributed significantly to my ability to amass a 217-8 overall win-loss record in trials during my 46-year legal career. As was the case with Mary Griffin Auburtin, Benjamin Bryan Starr asked nothing in return for his friendship. All he wanted was a level playing field for me within the walls of the Montgomery County courthouse, and Chief Starr did his best to level it. I did the rest. Chief Starr died on April 26, 1985, at age 74. He was one of the great ones. Benjamin Bryan Starr fought for America in the Pacific Theater during World War II and fought at home as a courthouse bailiff to level the playing field within the Montgomery County, Alabama Courthouse.
- FEC Money Laundering Case Against Caleb Crosby Closed
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on March 21, 2025 Caleb Crosby News Update --- On December 1, 2023, I published an article titled, “ Alabama Policy Institute’s Caleb Crosby Named as a Participant in a FEC Money Laundering Complaint .” A copy of the complaint was hyperlinked in the article. A check of the Docket Sheet in this Federal Election Commission (FEC) case today shows that Crosby's case is closed, as the Commission did not muster the four votes necessary to pursue an investigation into the allegations raised in the complaint. All actions taken by the Commission are reflected on the Docket Sheet. The complaint alleged that three political consultants illegally funneled at least $1.27 million in potentially illegal corporate contributions to federal and state political committees through a series of conduit corporations. The complaint’s allegations were primarily based on in-depth investigative reporting by the Orlando Sentinel -- a newspaper founded in 1876 and the recipient of multiple Pulitzer Prizes, including one for investigative reporting. The Sentinel’s reporting on this scheme was detailed and well-sourced, with the paper having internal emails and memoranda from the political consultants discussing the scheme in its possession. Two FEC Commissioners stated that the Sentinel’s reporting provided a credible allegation of a significant violation that the conduit corporations made contributions in the name of another, warranting further investigation into the true source of the funds. However, these Commissioners could not muster the four votes needed to pursue that investigation. In April 2024, a motion to dismiss the complaint failed on a 3-3 vote. The Commission also failed , on a 2-3 vote, to dismiss the allegation that Caleb Crosby violated 52 U.S.C. § 30122 and 11 C.F.R. § 110.4(b) by making contributions in the name of another. By a vote of 3-2, the Commission decided to take no further action against Caleb Crosby in his official capacity as treasurer of the Senate Leadership Fund and in his personal capacity A motion to close the file passed on a 6-0 vote. This FEC case now sits in the bizarre procedural posture of having an uninvestigated, active complaint against Caleb Crosby and the other named Respondents tucked away in a closed file.
- New Age Bigotry: The Pentagon's Erasure of Blacks, Women, and Native American Military Heroes
By : Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on March 19, 2025 Victorious Marines raising the American flag on Iwo Jima in 1945. An Editorial Opinion This year, America re-entered the old paradigm where the lives and history of Blacks, women, and Native Americans were devalued, along with their invaluable contributions to American society. This is U.S. policy, once again. Last week, Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth, the least qualified presidential appointee to hold this position in the modern era, scrubbed the valiant contributions of a trailblazing female pilot and two military icons of color from the Pentagon's website. These heroes included Brigadier General Charles Rogers, a Vietnam War Medal of Honor recipient , and Major General Jeannie Marie Leavitt, a Military Hall of Honor inductee. Army Brigadier General Charles Rogers Air Force Major General Jeannie Marie Leavitt The Pentagon also deleted the iconic photo of Marines hoisting an American flag on Iwo Jima in 1945 solely because one of the Marines in the photo was Pfc. Ira Hayes, a Native American from the Pima Tribe. Marine Pfc. Ira Hayes Additionally, the Pentagon ordered Arlington Cemetery's website to drop links for deceased Blacks, women, and Hispanic military heroes. In January, the Air Force's " Breaking Barriers " recruitment video was scrubbed from the Pentagon's websiite solely because it featured the famed Tuskegee Airman, who were World War II aviation heroes and America's first Top Gun winners in 1949 . The Pentagon's Purge of Non-White Male Military Heroes Has Been Met with Public Outrage The purge of Blacks, women, and Native American military heroes was ordered by President Donald Trump, whom many Americans view as a Vietnam War draft dodger. When Trump had his chance to show wartime valor, his father bought Trump's way out of military service via a private doctor's medical examination and bone spur medical excuse. These deliberate Pentagon erasures of this military history, along with others of a similar nature, have been met with public outrage. President Trump and Secretary Hegseth are literally attempting to whitewash American military history. They want to make it all-white, again. Due to the public outrage, the "Breaking Barriers" video has been restored. Gen. Rogers' website link has been reactivated , albeit with disparaging press statement by Hegseth, who never rose above the rank of major. Epilogue America has been here before -- many times. Throughout our nation's existence, there have been those in power who have sought to reimage, erase, and/or sanitize various chapters of American history to perpetuate a false narrative that portrayed White males soldiers in the most favorable light posssible. What is more, the Declaration of Independence designates Native Americans as “ merciless Indian savages . ” Additionally, between 1770 and1870, the U.S. government broke every treaty executed with 374 Native American Tribes . Yet, it was the brilliance of Navajo Code Talkers that broke the Japanese military codes. This seminal event helped America win World War II in the Pacific theater. The "thank you" that Native Americans got last week from President Trump and Secretary Hegseth for their wartime valor was the cold and callous removal of the flag-raising photo solely because Pfc. Hayes was one of the Marines featured in the flag-raising. The irony in today's new age bigotry is this: The people who were erased from our military history were true military heroes and icons, while the ones who erased them were not.
- The Injustice of This Moment Is Not an ‘Aberration’
Reprinted from the January 17, 2020 edition of The New York Times From mass incarceration to mass deportation, our nation remains in deep denial. By: Michelle Alexander Opinion Columnist White supremacists marched across the campus of the University of Virginia in Charlottesville. Ten years have passed since my book, “The New Jim Crow,” was published. I wrote it to challenge our nation to reckon with the recurring cycles of racial reform, retrenchment and rebirth of caste-like systems that have defined our racial history since slavery. It has been an astonishing decade. Everything and nothing has changed. When I was researching and writing the book, Barack Obama had not yet been elected president of the United States. I was in disbelief that our country would actually elect a black man to be the leader of the so-called free world. As the election approached, I felt an odd sense of hope and dread. I hoped against all reason that we would actually do it. But I also knew that, if we did, there would be a price to pay. Everything I knew through experience and study told me that we as a nation did not fully understand the nature of the moment we were in. We had recently birthed another caste system — a system of mass incarceration — that locked millions of poor people and people of color in literal and virtual cages. Our nation’s prison and jail population had quintupled in 30 years, leaving us with the highest incarceration rate in the world. A third of black men had felony records — due in large part to a racially biased, brutal drug war — and were relegated to a permanent second-class status. Tens of millions of people in the United States had been stripped of basic civil and human rights, including the right to vote, the right to serve on juries and the right to be free of legal discrimination in employment, housing, education and basic public benefits. Nevertheless, our nation remained in deep denial that a new caste system even existed, and most of us — even those who cared deeply about racial justice — did not seem to understand that powerful racial dynamics and political forces were at play that made much of our racial progress illusory. We had not faced our racial history and could not tell the truth about our racial present, yet growing numbers of Americans wanted to elect a black president and leap into a “colorblind” future. I was right to worry about the aftermath of Obama’s election. After he was inaugurated, our nation was awash in “post-racialism.” Black History Month events revolved around “how far we’ve come.” Many in the black community and beyond felt that, if Obama could win the presidency, anything was possible. Few people wanted to hear the message I felt desperate to convey: Despite appearances, our nation remains trapped in a cycle of racial reform, backlash and re-formation of systems of racial and social control. Things have changed since then. Donald Trump is president of the United States. For many, this feels like whiplash. After eight years of Barack Obama — a man who embraced the rhetoric (though not the politics) of the civil rights movement — we now have a president who embraces the rhetoric and the politics of white nationalism. This is a president who openly stokes racial animosity and even racial violence, who praises dictators (and likely aspires to be one), who behaves like a petulant toddler on Twitter, and who has a passionate, devoted following of millions of people who proudly say they want to “make America great again” by taking us back to a time that we’ve left behind. We are now living in an era not of post-racialism but of unabashed racialism, a time when many white Americans feel free to speak openly of their nostalgia for an age when their cultural, political and economic dominance could be taken for granted — no apologies required. Racial bigotry, fear mongering and scapegoating are no longer subterranean in our political discourse; the dog whistles have been replaced by bullhorns. White nationalist movements are operating openly online and in many of our communities; they’re celebrating mass killings and recruiting thousands into their ranks. White nationalism has been emboldened by our president, who routinely unleashes hostile tirades against black and brown people — calling Mexican migrants criminals, “rapists” and “bad people,” referring to developing African nations as “shithole countries” and smearing a district of the majority-black city of Baltimore as a “disgusting, rat and rodent infested mess.” Millions of Americans are cheering, or at least tolerating, these racial hostilities. Contrary to what many people would have us believe, what our nation is experiencing is not an “aberration.” The politics of “Trumpism” and “fake news” are not new; they are as old as the nation itself. The very same playbook has been used over and over in this country by those who seek to preserve racial hierarchy, or to exploit racial resentments and anxieties for political gain, each time with similar results. Back in the 1980s and ’90s, Democratic and Republican politicians leaned heavily on the racial stereotypes of “crack heads,” “crack babies,” “superpredators” and “welfare queens” to mobilize public support for the War on Drugs, a get-tough movement and a prison-building boom — a political strategy that was traceable in large part to the desire to appeal to poor and working-class white voters who had defected from the Democratic Party in the wake of the civil rights movement. Today, the rhetoric has changed, but the game remains the same. Public enemy No. 1 in the 2016 election was a brown-skinned immigrant, an “illegal,” a “terrorist” or an influx of people who want to take your job or rape your daughter. As Trump put it : “When Mexico sends its people, they’re not sending their best. … They’re sending people that have lots of problems, and they’re bringing those problems. … They’re bringing drugs. They’re bringing crime. They’re rapists.” He promised to solve this imaginary crisis through mass deportation and building a wall between the United States and Mexico. He also insisted that his political opponent, Hillary Clinton, wanted “millions of illegal immigrants to come in and take everybody’s jobs.” And he blamed domestic terroristic attacks in New Jersey and New York on “our extremely open immigration system,” which, he argued, allows Muslim terrorists into our country. The fact that Trump’s claims were demonstrably false did not impede his rise, just as facts were largely irrelevant at the outset of the War on Drugs. It didn’t matter back then that studies consistently found that whites were equally likely, if not more likely, than people of color to use and sell illegal drugs. Black people were still labeled the enemy. Nor did it matter, when the drug war was taking off, that nearly all of the sensationalized claims that crack cocaine was some kind of “demon drug,” drastically more harmful than powder cocaine, were false or misleading. Black people charged with possession of crack in inner cities were still punished far more harshly than white people in possession of powder cocaine in the suburbs. And it didn’t matter that African-Americans weren’t actually taking white people’s jobs or college educations in significant numbers through affirmative action programs. Getting tough on “them” — the racially defined “others” who could easily be used as scapegoats and cast as the enemy — was all that mattered. Facts were treated as largely irrelevant then. As they are now. Fortunately, a growing number of scholars and activists have begun to connect the dots between mass incarceration and mass deportation in our nation’s history and current politics. The historian Kelly Lytle Hernández, in her essay “ Amnesty or Abolition : Felons, Illegals, and the Case for a New Abolition Movement,” chronicles how these systems have emerged as interlocking forms of social control that relegate “aliens” and “felons” to a racialized caste of outsiders. In recent decades, the system of mass incarceration has stripped away from millions of U.S. citizens basic civil and human rights until their status mirrors (or dips below) that of noncitizen immigrants within the United States. This development has coincided with the criminalization of immigration in the United States, resulting in a new class of “illegal immigrants” and “aliens” who are viewed and treated like “felons” or “criminals.” Immigration violations that were once treated as minor civil infractions are now crimes. And minor legal infractions, ranging from shoplifting to marijuana possession to traffic violations, now routinely prompt one of the nation’s most devastating sanctions — deportation. The story of how our “nation of immigrants” came to deport and incarcerate so many for so little, Hernández explains, is a story of race and unfreedom reaching back to the era of emancipation. If we fail to understand the historical relationship between these systems, especially the racial politics that enabled them, we will be unable to build a truly united front that will prevent the continual re-formation of systems of racial and social control. In my experience, those who argue that the systems of mass incarceration and mass deportation simply reflect sincere (but misguided) efforts to address the real harms caused by crime, or the real challenges created by surges in immigration, tend to underestimate the corrupting influence of white supremacy whenever black and brown people are perceived to be the problem. “Between me and the other world, there is ever an unasked question,” W.E.B. Du Bois famously said back in 1897: “How does it feel to be a problem?” White people are generally allowed to have problems, and they’ve historically been granted the power to define and respond to them. But people of color — in this “land of the free” forged through slavery and genocide — are regularly viewed and treated as the problem. This distinction has made all the difference. Once human beings are defined as the problem in the public consciousness, their elimination through deportation, incarceration or even genocide becomes nearly inevitable. White nationalism, at its core, reflects a belief that our nation’s problems would be solved if only people of color could somehow be gotten rid of, or at least better controlled. In short, mass incarceration and mass deportation have less to do with crime and immigration than the ways we’ve chosen to respond to those issues when black and brown people are framed as the problem. As Khalil Gibran Muhammad points out in “The Condemnation of Blackness,” throughout our nation’s history, when crime and immigration have been perceived as white, our nation’s response has been radically different from when those phenomena have been defined as black or brown. The systems of mass incarceration and mass deportation may seem entirely unrelated at first glance, but they are both deeply rooted in our racial history, and they both have expanded in part because of the enormous profits to be made in controlling, exploiting and eliminating vulnerable human beings. It is tempting to imagine that electing a Democratic president or more Democratic politicians will fix the crises in our justice systems and our democracy. To be clear, removing Trump from office is necessary and urgent; but simply electing more Democrats to office is no guarantee that our nation will break its habit of birthing enormous systems of racial and social control. Indeed, one of the lessons of recent decades is these systems can grow and thrive even when our elected leaders claim to be progressive and espouse the rhetoric of equality, inclusion and civil rights. President Bill Clinton, who publicly aligned himself with the black community and black leaders, escalated a racially discriminatory drug war in part to avoid being cast by conservatives as “soft on crime.” Similarly, President Obama publicly preached values of inclusion and compassion toward immigrants, yet he escalated the mass detention and deportation of noncitizens. Obama claimed that his administration was focused on deporting: “Felons, not families. Criminals, not children. Gang members, not a mom who’s working hard to provide for her kids.” However, reports by The New York Times and the Marshall Project revealed that, despite Obama’s rhetoric, a clear majority of immigrants detained and deported during his administration had no criminal records, except minor infractions, including traffic violations, and posed no threat. Equally important is the reality that “felons” have families. And “criminals” are often children or teenagers. The notion that, if you’ve ever committed a crime, you’re permanently disposable is the very idea that has rationalized mass incarceration in the United States. None of this is to minimize the real progress that has occurred on many issues of race and criminal justice during the past decade. Today, there is bipartisan support for some prison downsizing, and hundreds of millions of philanthropic dollars have begun to flow toward criminal justice reform. A vibrant movement led by formerly incarcerated and convicted people is on the rise — a movement that has challenged or repealed disenfranchisement laws in several states, mobilized support of sentencing reform and successfully organized to “ban the box” on employment applications that discriminate against those with criminal records by asking the dreaded question: “Have you ever been convicted of a felony?” Activism challenging police violence has swept the nation — inspired by the courageous uprisings in Ferguson, Mo., the viral videos of police killings of unarmed black people, and #BlackLivesMatter . Promising movements for restorative and transformative justice have taken hold in numerous cities. Campaigns against cash bail have gained steam. Marijuana legalization has sped across the nation, with more than 25 states having partly or fully decriminalized cannabis since 2012. And “The New Jim Crow,” which some predicted would never get an audience, wound up spending nearly 250 weeks on the New York Times best-seller list and has been used widely by faith groups, activists, educators and people directly affected by mass incarceration inside and outside prisons. Over the past 10 years, I’ve received thousands of letters — and tens of thousands of emails — from people in all walks of life who have written to share how the book changed their lives or how they have used it to support consciousness-raising or activism in countless ways. Everything has changed. And yet nothing has. The politics of white supremacy, which defined our original constitution, have continued unabated — repeatedly and predictably engendering new systems of racial and social control. Just a few decades ago, politicians vowed to build more prison walls. Today, they promise border walls. The political strategy of divide, demonize and conquer has worked for centuries in the United States — since the days of slavery — to keep poor and working people angry at (and fearful of) one another rather than uniting to challenge unjust political and economic systems. At times, the tactics of white supremacy have led to open warfare. Other times, the divisions and conflicts are less visible, lurking beneath the surface. The stakes now are as high as they’ve ever been. Nearly everyone seems aware that our democracy is in crisis, yet few seem prepared to reckon with the reality that removing Trump from office will not rid our nation of the social and political dynamics that made his election possible. No issue has proved more vexing to this nation than the issue of race, and yet no question is more pressing than how to overcome the politics of white supremacy — a form of politics that not only led to an actual civil war but that threatens our ability ever to create a truly fair, just and inclusive democracy. We find ourselves in this dangerous place not because something radically different has occurred in our nation’s politics, but because so much has remained the same. The inconvenient truth is that racial progress in this country is always more complex and frequently more illusory than it appears at first glance. The past 10 years has been a case in point. Our nation has swung sharply from what Marc Mauer memorably termed “a race to incarcerate” — propelled by bipartisan wars on “drugs” and “crime” — to a bipartisan commitment to criminal justice reform, particularly in the area of drug policy. And yet, it must be acknowledged that much of the progress occurred not because of newfound concern for people of color who have been the primary targets of the drug war, but because drug addiction, due to the opioid crisis, became perceived as a white problem, and wealthy white investors became interested in profiting from the emerging legal cannabis industry. Some of the reversals in political opinion have been striking. For example, John Boehner, a former Republican speaker of the House of Representatives, stated in 2011 that he was “unalterably opposed to decriminalizing marijuana,” but by the spring of 2018 he had joined the board of a cannabis company. Growing sympathy for illegal drug users among whites and conservatives, and concern regarding the expense of mass imprisonment, helped to make possible a bipartisan consensus in support of the Trump administration’s First Step Act — leading to the early release of more than 3,000 people from federal prisons for drug offenses. This development, which benefits people of color subject to harsh and biased drug sentencing laws, is difficult to characterize as major progress toward ending mass incarceration, given that Trump continued to unleash racially hostile tirades against communities of color and his administration vowed to reinstate the federal death penalty. He also rescinded a number of significant reforms adopted by Obama and expanded the use of private prisons. Obama also has a complicated legacy with respect to criminal justice reform. Obama was the first sitting president to visit a federal correctional facility, the first to oversee a drop in the federal prison population in more than 30 years, and he granted clemency to nearly 2,000 people behind bars — the highest total for any president since Harry Truman. His administration enacted significant policy changes, including legislation reducing sentencing disparities involving crack and powder cocaine, a phasing out of federal contracts with private prisons, and limitations on the transfer of military equipment to local police departments. And yet it sometimes appeared that Obama was reluctant to acknowledge the depth and breadth of the structural changes required to address police violence and the prevailing systems of racial and social control. For example, when black Harvard professor Henry Louis Gates Jr. was arrested in his own home for no reason, Obama responded to the national furor and media frenzy by inviting Gates and the arresting officer to a “beer summit” at the White House to work things out over drinks and peanuts, as though racial profiling is little more than an interpersonal dispute that can be resolved through friendly dialogue. Most troubling, the modest criminal justice reforms that were achieved during the Obama administration coincided with the expansion of the system of mass deportation. Although the administration agreed to phase out federal contracts for private prisons, it made enormous investments in private detention centers for immigrants, including the granting of a $1 billion contract to Corrections Corporation of America, the nation’s largest prison company, to build a detention facility for women and children asylum seekers from Central America. Immigrant detention centers were exempted from the phaseout plan for private prisons, which meant that only about a quarter of the population held in private facilities in the United States was affected by the plan. The caging of immigrants for profit was allowed to continue without restraint. The reality is that, during both the Obama and Clinton years, highly racialized and punitive systems thrived under liberal presidents who were given the benefit of the doubt by those who might otherwise have been critics. Obama and Clinton’s public displays of affection for communities of color, the egalitarian values they preached and their liberal or progressive stances on other issues helped to shield these vast systems of control from close scrutiny. Many of us saw these presidents as “good people” with our best interests at heart, doing what they could to navigate a political environment in which only limited justice is possible. All of these factors played a role, but one was key: These systems grew with relatively little political resistance because people of all colors were willing to tolerate the disposal of millions of individuals once they had been labeled criminals in the media and political discourse. This painful reality suggests that ending our nation’s habit of creating enormous systems of racial and social control requires us to expand our sphere of moral concern so widely that none of us, not even those branded criminals, can be viewed or treated as disposable. If there is any silver lining to be found in the election of Donald Trump to the presidency, it is that millions of people have been inspired to demonstrate solidarity on a large scale across the lines of gender, race, religion and class in defense of those who have been demonized and targeted for elimination. Trump’s blatant racial demagogy has awakened many from their “colorblind” slumber and spurred collective action to oppose the Muslim ban and the border wall, and to create sanctuaries for immigrants in their places of worship and local communities. Many who are engaged in this work are also deeply involved in, or supportive of, movements to end police violence and mass incarceration. Growing numbers of people are beginning to see how the politics of white supremacy have resurfaced again and again, leading to the creation and maintenance of new systems of racial and social control. A politics of deep solidarity is beginning to emerge — the only form of politics that holds any hope for our collective liberation. The centuries-long struggle to birth a truly inclusive, egalitarian democracy — a nation in which every voice and every life truly matters — did not begin with us, and it will not end with us. The struggle is as old as the nation itself and the birth process has been painful, to say the least. My greatest hope and prayer is that we will serve as faithful midwives in our lifetimes and do what we can to make America, finally, what it must become.











