Search Results
Search this site
1309 results found with an empty search
- H. Lewis Gillis: The “Miracle Worker”
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted on October 13, 2026 Attorney H. Lewis Gillis, the "Miracle Worker." On December 10, 1990, Birmingham, Alabama Police Chief Arthur Deutcsh, police officers Bob Howell and Mike Lee, and Assistant Jail Administrator Robert Stone were indicted on state law felony charges of tampering with government records. The charges arose from an unsuccessful effort by one or more of these officers to alter jail records in an unsuccessful attempt to cover up the July 5, 1990, arrest of Erica Arrington, the daughter of then-Birmingham Mayor Richard Arrington, Jr. There was extensive publicity surrounding the attempted coverup of Eric Arrington's arrest, and it was overwhelmingly negative. Much of this publicity was sensational and undoubtedly prejudicial in the courts of public opinion and law. The publicity included highly inflammatory pre-indictment remarks by longtime Jefferson County, Alabama District Attorney David Barber. The indictments came at a time when Mayor Arrington was running for re-election in October of 1991 for his fourth consecutive term in office. Arrington’s strongest opponent was running largely on the jail records controversy, with David Barber surreptitiously supporting this opponent. Chief Arthur Deutcsh was tried first, and he was convicted on May 24, 1991. (Deutsch's conviction was later reversed on appeal, and he was never retried based upon a judicial determination that he was mentally incompetent to stand trial after a work-related accident). The negative publicity from Chief Deutcsh’s conviction spilled over into the political arena and was hurting Mayor Arrington’s chances for re-election, even though Arrington had no involvement in the jail records controversy. Officer Mike Lee's trial was up next. For a host of political reasons, we desperately needed a mistrial or acquittal. How Gillis Won Mike Lee’s "Unwinnable" Case Each of the four indicted police officers in the jail records case had a separate lawyer who was paid with city funds, as authorized under state law. Each officer had a separate trial. We assigned Lewis Gillis to represent Officer Mike Lee. Chief Deutsch and the other two defendants selected their own attorneys. Mayor Arrington and I asked Lewis Gillis to secure a mistrial, if possible, as the mayoral election was only two months away from the start of Mike Lee’s trial in August of 1991. After Chief Deutsch's conviction in May of 1991, we thought another conviction was likely and we did not need a second conviction as we approached the October election. The optics from a second conviction would further erode Mayor Arrington's chances for re-election. Under the circumstances, a mistrial would have been a good outcome. On the third day of the trial, Lewis Gillis asked to meet with Mayor Arrington and me after court to brief us on the progress of the trial. In his briefing, Gillis reminded us that we asked him to secure a mistrial, if possible. Then, Lewis Gillis asked us for permission to WIN officer Mike Lee's case. We were stunned by his request. We asked Gillis whether an acquittal was even possible, given the divisiveness in the community, the non-stop negative media coverage, and the circus-like political atmosphere surrounding Mike Lee's trial. Gillis’ answer was simple and direct. He would call District Attorney Barber as an adverse witness for Mike Lee's defense and fillet him in front of the jurors. He would expose Barber's political motivation for bringing the criminal charges against Lee. With the defense work Gillis had already performed during the prosecution's case, he thought this strategy would sway the jury towards an acquittal. The next day, Gillis called a stunned David Barber to the witness stand as his first defense witness. Gillis filleted Barber in front of the jurors, who were surprised to see the way Gillis firmly handled a member of the prosecution team as an adverse witness. Gillis kept Barber on a short leash and sliced him with razor-sharp leading questions about all his pre- and post-indictment comments. Barber was nervous, unprepared, and testy during his entire time on the witness stand. Gillis’ examination of Barber was masterful. It turned the tide from a possible mistrial to an outright and stunning victory on all charges. Epilogue When I retired from the legal profession, my win-loss record in the courtroom is 217 wins and 8 losses. One of those defeats came at the hands of Lewis Gillis when he was a Montgomery County assistant district attorney. After Gillis kicked my ass in the courtroom, I made it my business to get to know him and work with him when he entered private practice. With his stunning victory in the Mike Lee case, the members of my litigation teams started calling H. Lewis Gillis the “Miracle Worker.”
- Family Matters: The Generational Impact of Michael Daley's Deed of Land to Olivia Carmichael in 1887
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on December 12, 2023 The Olivia and William Carmichael Family. My maternal grandmother, Oda Etta Carmichael, was born on January 12, 1890. Etta is the little girl who is standing next to her mother Olivia (second from the left on the front row). My family’s story begins when Dougald A. Carmichael and his wife Katheryn Carmichael, both of whom were born in 1817 in Scotland, migrated to America in the late 1830s. The new immigrants initially settled in South Carolina. Dougald and Katheryn, who were white, had six sons -- James, George, John, Thomas, William and Robert -- and one daughter named Ann. As recorded in the 1850 U.S. Census, the Carmichael family was living and farrming in Hinds County, Mississippi. The Census records listed them as Dogold and Catherine Carmichael. However, their true names were Dougald and Katheryn Carmichael. The 1850 U.S. Census Slave Schedule for Dougold and Katheryn Carmichael shows that they owned two black female slaves. One was a 31-year-old slave and the other one was a 12-year-old child. Dougold and Katheryn's son, William Carmichael, who was born on December 5, 1838, met and fell in love with a beautiful “mulatto” girl in Hinds County named Olivia Williamson, who was born on April 20, 1847. Olivia's "mulatto" racial classification is confirmed in the 1870 U.S. Census, which was the first time African-Americans were counted in the census in Southern states as full citizens. Prior to 1870, blacks in slaveholding states were counted as "Slaves" or "Free Coloreds." Slaveowners listed the number and description of their slaves on U.S. Census Slave Schedules. The names of slaves were irrelevant for census counting purposes. Under the Three-Fifths Compromise of 1787, three out of every five slaves were counted when determining a state's total population for legislative representation and taxation. Olivia Williamson’s biological father was reputed to be Michael Daley, a white immigrant from Ireland who was born in 1798. [U.S. Census records for 1880 record Daley's name as "Michael Dailey"]. Daley, who was married but had no biological children with his wife Bridget, lived and farmed on land he owned in adjoining Madison County, Mississippi. There is evidence that Olivia Williamson was one of the 13 female "Free Coloreds" in Hinds County in 1850. The evidence also suggests that Michael Daley secured Olivia's freedom shortly after her birth in 1847. The First Interracial Marriage in the Carmichael/Varnado/Watkins Family Occurred in 1865 Olivia and William Carmichael married in Crawford Station, Mississippi, on March 25, 1865 -- about two weeks before General Robert E. Lee surrendered his 28,000 confederate troops to General Ulysses S. Grant at Appomattox. This young interacial couple lived in Canton (Madison County), Mississippi. Their love for each other was more powerful than the entrenched and prevailing racial customs in Mississippi at the time. Olivia and William Carmichael were my maternal great-grandparents. Olivia Williamson Carmichael, circa 1893. William Carmichael, circa 1893. During the next 36 years, Olivia and William Carmichael would start a large family and build bridges for a host of former Madison and Hinds County slaves and their descendants to help them get a basic education, secure good jobs, own land, and vote in Mississippi. On February 26, 1887, Olivia Carmichael broke the color barrier in Mississippi by becoming the first black female to own land in her name, alone. Michael Daley signed and recorded a Warranty Deed that transferred title to his Madison County property to Olivia. Daley's conveyance of land to Olivia Carmichael 136 years ago empowered her as a black woman and boosted the Carmichael family's socio-economic clout in Mississippi's property ownership-based society. Olivia and William Carmichael had nine children, one of whom was Oda Etta Carmichael (my maternal grandmother). All of their children engaged in a lifetime of bridge-building, as well. Etta, who stands at the knee of her mother Olivia in the featured photograph to this article, and her eight siblings attended local schools in Mississippi for “colored” children, where they excelled in academics. All of the Carmichael children did well in life. They eventually became highly successful land owners, businessmen, educators, service professionals, and homemakers. Olivia and William Carmichael and their progeny are credited with the rise of the black middle-class in Hinds County, Mississippi during the Reconstruction, Post-Reconstruction, Jim Crow, and Post-Jim Crow eras. There are also credited for giving our family a significant headstart in life. Finally, Olivia and William Carmichael taught our family that "love sees no color." As a result of this invaluable lesson, there are (and have been) a lot of interracial couples in the Carmichael/Varnado/Watkins extended family for many decades. The Huge Economic Impact of Carmichael Family Member Doris Louise Varnado Conic Nowhere is the impact of Olivia and William Carmichael's emphasis on economic empowerment clearer than the case of Doris Louise Varnado (1915 to 1998) and Frank N. Conic (1911 to 2005). Doris L. Varnado was Olivia's grand-daughter. Her mother was Oda Etta Carmichael. Doris and her husband Frank N. Conic owned and operated Conic Beauty and Barber Supply Company at 615 North Farish Street in Jackson, Mississippi from 1950 to 1975. They were also civil rights icons in Jackson from the 1940’s through the 1970s. Conic Beauty and Barber Supply Company operated in Jackson, Mississippi from 1950 to 1975. From left to right: Doris V. Conic, Myrtle C. Johnson, Frank N. Conic, and Jack Johnson. Frank Conic was the son of John Edgar Conic, Sr., a prominent black businessman in Jackson. Frank’s father operated the City Barber Shop and was the only independent distributor of the Chicago Defender and Pittsburg Courier newspapers in Jackson for 30 years. Both newspapers were influential black-owned weekly publications that called for improvements in housing, healthcare, and education for African-Americans. Long before Doris and Frank Conic retired in 1975, their business was delivering beauty supplies throughout the entire State of Mississippi. Their sales grossed more revenues than any other African-American business in Jackson. Doris and Frank Conic were the first African-American members of the Carmichael family who traveled the world and established an international network of business relationships. They served as our family's private mentors on international travel and global business in the 1950s, 60s, and 70s. Voting in Mississippi Prior to the Passage of the Voting Rights Act of 1965 In Southern states, very few African-Americans dared to exercise their right to vote during the Jim Crow era. Two Mississippians who did were Doris and Frank Conic. The Conics paid the poll taxes that white segregationist officials imposed upon blacks to discourage them from voting and did so each year from 1940 until the passage of the Voting Rights Act of 1965. Epilogue William Carmichael died on March 24, 1901. Olivia Carmichael died on June 20, 1927. In 2023, the Olivia and William Carmichael family commenced its eighth generation of family members with the birth of my great-granddaughter, Azayah Jordan Deese. Today, there are hundreds of immediate and extended Carmichael/Varnado/Watkins family members living, studying, and working in the United States and around the world. Every day, the bloodline of Olivia and William Carmichael is positively impacting the quality of life (in objectively measured ways) for millions of people in the fields of medicine, business, education, multimedia, finance, and energy. Since the 1830s, our family has overcome and/or outlasted every adversity we have encountered in America. Our familial foundation, business network, and interpersonal relationships are rock solid and truly global in nature. Because of Olivia and William Carmichael, our family has known since March 25, 1865 that "love sees no color." Michael Daley's conveyance of his land in Mississippi to his "mulatto" daughter Olivia (in her name only) in 1887 affirms that love trumps all.
- Dr. Levi Watkins, Jr., MD, Has Been Selected as a "Legacy Recognition Honoree" by the American Academy of Arts and Sciences
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted on October 10, 2026 Dr. Levi Watkins, Jr., MD. On October 9, 2026, renown heart surgeon Dr. Levi Watkins, Jr., MD (1945-2015), was selected as a "Legacy Recognition Honoree" by the American Academy of Arts and Sciences. Levi, who is my deceased brother, is the second member of the Carmichael/Varnado/Watkins family to become affiliated with the Academy. In 2017, my first-cousin, Dr. Beverly Guy-Sheftall, PhD, was elected as a member of the Academy. Dr. Beverly Guy-Sheftall, PhD. Our family is extremely proud to have two 5th generation family members -- Levi and Beverly -- prominently affiliated with the Academy. Close family friends Dr. Maya Angelou (1928-2014) and former Texas Congresswoman Barbara Jordan (1936-1996) are also "Legacy Recognition Honorees." Mrs. Lillian Watkins (left), the matriarch of the Watkins family, hugs Dr. Maya Angelou, aclose family friend. Dr. Levi Watkins, Jr., with close friend friends Coretta Scott King (left) and Dr. Maya Angelou (right). About the Academy The "Legacy Recognition Program," which was launched in 2023, recognizes individuals who were not members of the Academy and whose accomplishments were overlooked or undervalued due to their race, ethnicity, gender, or sexual orientation. The American Academy of Arts and Sciences honors excellence and convenes leaders from every field of human endeavor to examine new ideas, address issues of importance to the nation and the world and work together “to cultivate every art and science which may tend to advance the interest, honor, dignity, and happiness of a free, independent, and virtuous people.” More than 14,500 members have been elected to the Academy since it was founded on May 4, 1780. The 62 original incorporating fellows included John Adams, John Hancock, and Samuel Adams. Benjamin Franklin and George Washington were part of the first class of new members elected in 1781. About Dr. Beverly Guy-Sheftall Beverly is a pioneer in the field of black feminist thought and writing. In 1981, Beverly founded and became the first director of the Spelman College Women's Research and Resource Center, where she also instituted a Women's Studies program, both firsts for the college. Two years after opening the center, Beverly co-founded SAGE: A Scholarly Journal on Black Women. Beverly has written, edited, or co-edited ten books, including Sturdy Black Bridges: Visions of Black Women in Literature, in 1979. This book has become a classic in the field of African American and Women's Studies, along with her 1995 anthology Words of Fire: An Anthology of African American Feminist Thought (1995). She is past President of NWSA (National Women's Studies Association). In May 2017, Beverly established the Dr. Levi Watkins Jr. Scholars Program as well as a companion lecture series at Spelman to explore contemporary issues of race, gender and sexuality, beginning in 2018. The Scholars program and lecture series were launched with a pledge of $100,000. Epilogue Levi's "Legacy Recognition Honoree" status comes as the family continues to plan and prepare for its 200th year bicentennial anniversary in America in 2030.
- Donald J. Trump: A One-Man Wrecking Ball Encased in Gold Trappings
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on April 9, 2025 An Editorial Opinion Once upon a time, America was the most admired and respected country in the world. After 79 days in office, President Donald Trump has turned America into an international pariah. He is a one-man wrecking ball who has encased himself in gold trappings. Trump has spent his first 79 days in the White House designing the Trump Golden Statue, the Donald J. Trump Commemorative $5,000 Golden Dollar Bill, and the “Trump Gold Card.” Many Washington insiders say Trump is consumed with exercises in self-glorification. Trump has betrayed all of America’s allies, except for Israel and Hungary. Trump has repeatedly threatens Mexico and Canada -- our immediate neighbors, traditional allies, and trading parters in the Western Hemisphere. Trump is attempting to seize the Panama Canal, Greenland, and Canada under a modern-day version of “Manifest Destiny.” Trump has declared a trade war against 180 countries, including China (which holds $859 billion of America’s $36.2 trillion national debt). As a result, Wall Street is tanking. Trump pardoned 1,600 January 6th rioters because they were “patriots.” He is compensating them for being unfairly swept up in the federal criminal justice system after they destroyed property on the Capitol grounds and some of the rioters critically injured the police officers who defended the Capitol. Trump has cast the police officers, prosecutors, and judges who brought the rioters to justice as "very bad people." Trump has bullied every nation, except North Korea, Russia, Israel, and Hungary. Russia and Israel have pimped Trump like a $10 streetwalker in the 1972 Super Fly movie. Trump has reduced Congress and the U.S. Supreme Court to a group of mindless, "ass-kissing" sycophants. Trump has an obsession with reducing everybody to "ass-kissing" status. Last night, Trump attended the National Republican Congressional Committee’s annual fundraising dinner where he bragged that world leaders are “kissing my ass” as they try to negotiate trade deals. Trump has stacked his Cabinet and White House advisors with undistinguished, unqualified, and lightweight flunkies who spend more time with their plastic surgeons than their staffs. Trump has ignored the Constitutional “checks and balances” on presidential power much like he ignored the terms and conditions in the business contracts that were voided during his 6 bankruptcy filings. Trump has South African apartheid beneficiary Elon Musk and far-right white nationalist provocateur Laura Loomer openly advising him on domestic and international affairs. What is worse, Trump follows their unsound advice. Finally, Donald Trump has stripped once respected Republican members of Congress of their dignity, independence, and sensibilities. They must now join a Jim Jones-like MAGA cult that has elevated Trump to "Jesus Christ" status, or get primaried by a Trump-backed candidate.
- The Mount Rushmore of American Litigators
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted on October 5, 2026 An Editorial Opinion The four greatest litigators in American history are Thurgood Marshall, Johnnie Cochran, Bryan Stevenson, and Willie Gary. Each of these litigators was/is a strong, smart, brave, and extremely gifted gladiator in the courtroom. Each one knew/knows how to try cases and win jury verdicts or court judgments in his client's favor. If there was a Mount Rushmore for American litigators, the name, image, and likeness of these four men would be on it. Thurgood Marshall desegregated public schools, public accommodations, and public transportation systems throughout America during the 1930s, 40s, 50s, and 60s. In 1967, Marshall became the nation’s first black U.S. Supreme Court justice, where he used his extensive litigation background to usher in enhanced protections of constitutional and civil rights for disfavored Americans. Marshall died a national hero on January 24, 1993. In 1995, Johnnie Cochran became the first black lead defense attorney to try a very controversial, nationally televised, murder case and win it in the courtroom. The “Not Guilty” verdict in O.J. Simpson’s murder trial is still talked about today. Johnnie’s life and work have been featured in countless documentaries since his death on March 29, 2005. In 1989, Bryan Stevenson founded the Equal Justice Initiative in Montgomery, Alabama. He has used his considerable courtroom skills to win court-ordered relief, reduced sentences, or freedom for a record-breaking 140 clients who were wrongly convicted or sentenced to death. Bryan wrote the bestselling 2014 memoir “Just Mercy: A Story of Justice and Redemption,” which was adapted into an award-winning 2019 biographical drama film. Willie Gary turned courtroom litigation into an art form. Since 1974, Willie has used his mastery of complex litigation to win massive jury verdicts for tens of thousands of historically disadvantaged Americans. Willie’s nickname in the legal profession is “The Giant Killer.” He earned this nickname through high-profile courtroom victories against large companies like The Loewen Group (a major funeral conglomerate) and The Walt Disney Company. Willie’s legal career and famous case involving client Jeremiah Joseph O'Keefe were also depicted in the “The Burial” film starring Jamie Foxx as Gary. The two living litigation legends -- Bryan Stevenson and Willie Gary -- hold Martindale-Hubbell's top five-star "AV" rating. Martingale-Hubbell is the legal profession's most recognized and trusted peer review rating agency. Finally, these four master litigators won their cases in the most hostile racial environments imaginable. In the process, they never betrayed their clients or sold out their people. Above all, they had courage when it counted the most.
- District Attorney Danny Carr's VIP Treatment of Accused Strangler and Wife-Beater Christopher Drummond Has Drawn Surging Public Interest
By Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted on September 28, 2026 Jefferson County, Alabama District Attorney Danny Carr. Jefferson County, Alabama Danny Carr’s VIP treatment of accused strangler/wife-beater Christopher Drummond has drawn surging public interest. In September, alone, four of the top six feature articles on my Facebook page related to Christopher Drummond’s wife-beating case. These four articles produced 130,689 total views between September 5 and 28, 2026. This number is up from 15,026 total views for the first two related articles published in July. Days of after Christopher Drummond completed a 45-day sentence in a Monaco prison cell on a charge of intentional violence against his wife Alexis Drummond, he was arrested again on July 20, 2026, in Jefferson County on charges of strangling and beating Alexis. Christopher and Alexis Drummond. The inset photo is Drummond's most recent mugshot. From the moment Danny Carr received the case from police departments in Birmingham and Mountain Brook, Alabama, his office began to treat Drummond like a VIP guest, rather than an accused criminal with a documented history of physical violence against his wife. Drummond breezed in and out of the county jail in 3 hours, even though he had was fresh out of a prison in Monaco. Carr made no effort to detain Drummond pending his trial. In Alabama, the Drummonds Seem to Operate Above the Law In what appears to be substantial departures from standard prosecutorial practices in violent domestic abuse cases, Danny Carr’s prosecution team seems to be bending over backwards to make sure Christopher Drummond faces no prison time, if he is convicted of domestic abuse, again. What is shocking to many court observers is this well-documented fact: Christopher Drummond comes from a family whose company executives have long been associated with bribing judges and elected officials in Alabama whenever they were caught and/or charged with engaging in illegal conduct. Christopher Drummond, himself, bragged on videotape that he “owns” every judge in Alabama. What is more, Christopher Drummond’s family has owned the ABC Coke Company since 1977. Along with four other heavy industrial polluters, ABC Coke poisoned the air and ground in three North Birmingham communities and the city of Tarrant, Alabama. Their extremely toxic environmental poisons condemned about 4,000 Jefferson County residents to a long, slow, and painful death. An estimated 92% of these homicide victims were black. The polluters are all white. Combined, the polluters caused more deaths than the 9/11 terrorists. North Birmingham residents are still dying from these industrial poisons and there is no statute of limitations for murder. The killers can be charged with murder in state AND federal court. Donald Trump's Department of Justice has NOT charged any industrial polluter with the murder of these 4,000 local residents. Likewise, Danny Carr, who has been the local DA since 2017, has NOT charged a single Drummond Company executive, or a single ABC Coke executive, or a single Drummond family member with “murder by poisoning” for any one of the 4,000 intentional deaths that occurred in North Birmingham and Tarrant. Epilogue When a Drummond family member finally landed in Danny Carr’s lap in July on domestic violence charges, Carr engaged in unusually soft and weak prosecutorial actions in the case. His softness has raised red flags all over the place. Is Danny Carr compromised in this case? Does Christopher Drummond “own” Danny Carr, too? Why is Christopher Drummond, a criminal defendant with a violent domestic abuse in his background, receiving special VIP treatment from Danny Carr? Why has Carr failed to prosecute a single polluter for the mass killing of 4,000 Jefferson County residents by five known heavy industrial polluters, including ABC Coke? There is far more “insider” information about Christopher Drummond’s case than I have published today. There are many eyes watching this case.
- My First Legal Case was My Own and It was Fought Inside UA's Law School
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on May 30, 2024 Farrah Hall on the campus of the University of Alabama is where I argued and won my first case in 1972. As fate would have it, my first case was my own. My first legal case was my own. It occurred while I was a second-year student at the University of Alabama’s School of Law. It was an emotionally challenging, dramatic, and life-altering experience. Here is what happened: I graduated from a small racially segregated high school in Montgomery, Alabama in 1966. I attended college at Southern Illinois University in Carbondale, Illinois from 1966 to 1970. My SIU years were filled with boundless multiculturalism. I thrived in SIU’s fully integrated and highly competitive university environment of 25,000 students. College Days at Southern Illinois University. Donald V. Watkins (left), with Ted Williams (seated), Ronald Coleman, and Ronald Jackson, circa 1968. When I arrived on campus at UA for law school in September 1970, I knew right away that I was in for a much different experience. Remember, this was a year before there were any black athletes at UA, and only a small number of black undergraduate students were matriculating on campus. The welcoming collegiate environment I experienced at Southern Illinois was absent at UA. I was one of two black students in my freshman class of 150 law students. The other black student was George Jones from Miles College in Birmingham. I was attending the law school on a desegregation scholarship from the NAACP in New York. Donald Watkins (left) with George Jones (right) talking to a white law student during a break between classes. Our class was divided alphabetically into two sections. George was placed in one section, and I was assigned to the other one. I often refer to my law school days at UA from 1970 to 1973 as the longest and loneliest three years of my life. One of my classmates was John David Whetstone. He was my moot court partner during our second year of law school. I had studied David’s classroom performance during my freshman year. This guy was tough, smart, disciplined, and extremely mature. David was good on his feet and had a thundering voice with a strong Southern drawl. David was a 1963 graduate of Greenville High School, who served in the Air Force after high school. He was honorably discharged as a sergeant in 1968. David had worked his way through the University of West Florida and law school at UA using the G.I. Bill. As I entered my second year, I needed a moot court partner. I figured nobody was going to choose me, so I decided to approach David. The way he carried himself suggested to me that David had been exposed to black people and he had no problem treating them with dignity and respect. I approached David in the fall of 1971 and told him that I had studied his performance as a law student. He seemed startled. I also told David that I thought he was “good enough to be my moot court partner” and I stuck my hand out to shake his hand. He paused for a moment, smiled, and said “okay," as he shook my hand in return. That handshake meant the world to me. It was the start of an unbreakable and lifelong friendship between David and me. David and I competed ferociously in the moot court competition. All year long, we outscored and eliminated all of the teams we faced. I enjoyed being David’s teammate. He could research cases and write briefs very well; he would argue points of law with passion; and he rolled over opponents with ease. David was a warrior, and he was fighting side-by-side with me. In March of 1972, David and I had eliminated all of our competitors through the end of the semi-final round. We were slated to represent our class section as “finalists” in the annual Law Day competition against the team of George L. Galbraith and George W. Ashbee. This prestigious event would be held on Saturday, April 8, 1972, in front of a large crowd of students, faculty, and parents. Three distinguished Alabama judges would decide the Law Day winner. This was a huge event for any law student. I was very proud of what David and I had accomplished. I called my parents and told them we had made it into the Law Day final round of competition. My mother started crying because she knew how isolated and lonely my law school experience had been. My father, who was President of Alabama State University, was excited that David and I might win it all. I could feel my parents’ pride and excitement beaming through the phone. Our private celebration was short-lived. After winning our semi-final round, the student Moot Court Committee met secretly and changed the original criteria for advancing in the moot court competition. After making this change, the Committee designated the team we had just defeated as the “finalists” who would compete in the Law Day event against Galbraith and Ashbee. I was shocked, angry, and hurt beyond words. I told David that we could not let this unfair treatment go unchallenged and that I needed him to stand and fight with me on this issue. Suddenly, I watched the Air Force sergeant and patriot emerge in David. He snapped to attention, shook my hand, and told me we were in this fight together. On April 7, 1972, David and I filed a written challenge with Dean Thomas W. Christopher protesting our unfair elimination as finalists for Law Day. Dean Christopher wrote us a letter on the same day stating that he would investigate this matter. He also assured us that the Law Day competition on April 8th would be subject to the outcome of his investigation. University of Alabama Law School Dean Thomas Weldon Christopher, circa 1973. I did not go to the Law Day competition on April 8th. Instead, I sat inside my car outside of the law school building -- Farrah Hall -- and cried uncontrollably while the event was taking place. The emotional pain was unbearable. The person who found me in my car and consoled me that day was Mr. Ramus Rhodes, the janitor at the law school. He was my friend, confidant, academic coach, and mentor. He knew I was devasted. This was one of those days when Mr. Rhodes had to carry me because I did not have the strength to carry myself. On April 18, 1972, following an April 12th hearing before a five-person hearing panel of four professors and one outside attorney, Dean Christopher issued his decision. He sent a copy of his decision to my parents on April .21, 1972. Calling the Moot Court Committee’s action “an error in judgment," Dean Christopher took the following administrative actions: (1) he declared that David and I should have been selected as finalists using the criteria established at the beginning of the competition; (2) he announced to the entire student body and the Moot Court Board that we should have been selected to compete in the Law Day competition as finalists; (3) he wrote a personal letter to our parents to explain how well David and I had performed in the overall competition and stated in his letter that, “but for an error in judgment by the student Moot Court Committee, [David and I] would have been in the final argument itself”; (4) he ordered prize monies paid to David and me as if we were finalists; (5) he ordered a match between the winners of the Law Day round and our team; (6) he took full responsibility, as dean of the law school, for this “error in judgment”; and (7) he personally thanked David and me for our “constructive and fair attitudes in the resolution of this matter.” [Click Here to Read Dean Christopher's Memorandum Ruling.] David and I pondered Dean Christopher’s offer of a match between the team of Galbraith/Ashbee and us. We decided that Galbraith/Ashbee had done nothing wrong in this matter. They were two innocent competitors who had fairly won the Law Day round of competition against a team we had defeated. David and I decided that we would not take away the victory Galbraith/Ashbee had won in front of their parents and the crowd that had gathered to watch their winning performance. We did not have it in our hearts to subject Galbraith/Ashbee to the emotional pain that had been inflicted upon us. With that in mind, we waived our right to this matchup and allowed Dean Christopher to declare the Galbraith/Ashbee team the “winners” of the 1972 Moot Court Competition. David graduated in January 1973. I graduated in May of that year. David enjoyed a long and distinguished career as an assistant district attorney and later as the district attorney for Baldwin County, Alabama. As was the situation in law school, David was the consummate professional as a career prosecutor. He is the yardstick by which I measure all prosecutors. To this day, I have not met a federal or state prosecutor whose integrity matches David’s. God works in mysterious ways. I never thought my first case would be my own and that I would have to represent myself. My father taught me as a child that a man who will not fight for himself or his family, will not fight for others. David and I put it all on the line to fight against a painful injustice. In the process, we earned the respect of our dean, student peers, faculty and staff members, and larger communities. Out of a heartbreaking experience in law school came a friendship bond with John David Whetstone that has stood the test of time. In 2012, while going through one of my mother’s scrapbooks, I found Dean Christopher’s letter to my parents and a copy of his ruling in our moot court case. I immediately called David to reminisce about our moot court experience 40 years earlier. David asked me to send him a copy for his family. I told David it was important that his children and grandchildren know our story and know that he had tremendous courage when it was needed and counted. In my book, John David Whetstone has earned a permanent place on the right side of history. As for me, my friendship with David is one more example of why I never judge anyone based on his/her race, gender, age, political affiliation, sexual orientation, or any other artificial factor. I judge every individual solely on the content of his/her character. And, in many cases, a person’s true character is revealed only when he/she is faced with adversity. As life would have it, my legal career started with my own case in law school. In that case, David Whetstone and I experienced and overcame an awful injustice without causing harm to two innocent law students. After law school, I joined a Montgomery and Tuskegee-based law firm headed by famed civil rights attorney Fred D. Gray, whose nationally-known clients included Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., Rosa Parks, and the survivors of the Tuskegee Syphilis Study. My "Biography" page on this website tells the rest of the story! Left to right, Donald V. Watkins, Congresswoman Barbara Jordan (D-Texas), Dean Thomas W. Christopher, and Attorney Fred D. Gray.
- Reclaiming Our History: The Remarkable Story of Dr. Isaac Scott Hathaway
By Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on September 24, 2018; Updated on February 21, 2023 Dr. Isaac Scott Hathaway (right) with Levi Watkins, Jr., (left) and Emma Pearl Watkins (second from the right) on the campus of Alabama State University in Montgomery, circa 1950. Dr. Isaac Scott Hathaway (1872–1967) was an American educator and artist who was best known for creating more than 100 busts and masks of prominent African Americans. My siblings, Levi Watkins, Jr., and Emma Pearl Watkins, met Dr. Hathaway when our family first moved to Montgomery in the early 1950s. Along with their young classmates, Levi, Jr., and Emma Pearl loved interacting with Dr. Hathaway. I met Dr. Hathaway shortly after my father, Dr. Levi Watkins, Sr., became president of Alabama State University in 1962. Dr. Hathaway was the director of ceramics at Alabama State for many years. He also taught art and sculpturing classes at the university and in the Laboratory school. Remarkably, Dr. Hathaway also taught ceramics classes at Auburn University for six weeks during the summer of 1947. He broke the color barrier at Auburn by becoming one of the University's first African-American professors. Dr. Hathaway taught his ceramics class 16 years prior to Auburn’s admission of its first black student (Dr. Harold Franklin) in 1964. Dr. Hathaway teaching ceramics to his students at Auburn University in 1947. Dr. Hathaway's Phenomenal Contributions to American History I attended Alabama State’s Laboratory High School on campus. My interest in art brought me into direct contact with Dr. Hathaway on a frequent basis. About a year after Dr. Hathaway retired in 1963, I heard that he designed a coin for the U.S. Mint. I thought this was super cool and I tried to research this matter. However, I could not find anything in my textbooks or in the public library downtown that confirmed this fact. So, I asked my father whether this fact was true, and he told me the full story behind this historical event. Here is the suppressed history of Dr. Hathaway's greatness: In 1945, Dr. Hathaway was selected to design coins honoring two African-Americans, becoming the first African-American to design a coin for the U.S. Mint. The first coin was a half dollar bearing the likeness of Booker T. Washington. It was minted from 1946 to 1951. The second coin was a half dollar bearing the likeness of George Washington Carver and Booker T. Washington. It was minted from 1951 to 1954. My father told me the U.S. Post Office issued a 10¢ stamp in 1940 in Booker T. Washington’s honor. The stamp was affixed to a “First Day of Issue” envelope, dated April 7, 1940, from “Tuskegee Institute, Alabama.” My father also told me the Post Office issued a 3¢ stamp with George Washington Carver’s image on it. The stamp was affixed to a “First Day of Issue” envelope, dated February 12, 1948, from “Booker T. Washington Birthplace, Virginia.” This stamp was issued to celebrate Washington’s journey in life “From slave cabin to Hall of Fame." I was stunned. It seemed surreal in 1964 to confirm that the images of two distinguished African-Americans were actually printed on two sets of U.S. Postal stamps and engraved on two sets of half dollars in national circulation in the 1940s and 1950s. This remarkable achievement occurred many years before the birth of the civil rights era of the mid-1950s and 1960s. Yet, these historical events were completely omitted from the textbooks authorized by the Alabama State Board of Alabama in the 1960s for use in Alabama’s public schools. After I graduated from law school and passed the Alabama Bar exam, I commenced my long search to find and collect these four iconic pieces of American history. It took me nearly 20 years to secure two mint-condition, uncirculated Washington-Carver half dollar coins and two Washington-Carver stamps in a pristine condition and affixed to the “First Day of Issue” commemorative envelopes issued by the Post Office. By way of historical perspective, the Postal Service would not honor another African-American until 1979, when it issued a commemorative stamp honoring Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. The image of Rosa Parks would not appear on a U.S. Postal Service stamp until 2013. Words cannot describe the sense of pride and exhilaration I felt when I acquired the last of the four pieces of my Booker T. Washington-George Washington Carver coin and stamp collection. With this event, I reclaimed an important piece of history that had been suppressed in textbooks during my childhood. In the process, I secured tangible proof that white Americans of interracial goodwill thought enough of two African-American educators in Tuskegee to place their likeness on coins and stamps that circulated in the general population while racial segregation and Jim Crow racism reigned unchecked in the South. Dr. Hathaway made history by designing these two half dollar coins. Booker T. Washington and George Washington Carver made history by achieving greatness in higher education research and services at Tuskegee University. The American government honored Washington and Carver by commissioning these commemorative coins and stamps in the 1940s and 1950s. This unprecedented and positive gesture in American history was intentionally omitted from Alabama public school textbooks for decades. Thankfully, we have been able to reclaim and preserve this important chapter in African-American history. Thanks to the Internet and social media platforms, no politician will ever be able to suppress our history again. Dr. Isaac Scott Hathaway was selected to design half dollar coins honoring two African-Americans, becoming the first African-American to design a coin for the U.S. Mint.
- Justice for Nolan Wells May Be Slipping Away!
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted on September 25, 2026 Nolan Wells with his parents Elmore Wonsley and Christine Wells-Wonsley. Yesterday, I read the September 18, 2026, grand jury report on the death of Nolan Wells. As a former state prosecutor in homicide cases from murder to manslaughter and as a retired criminal defense attorney who holds a string of unbroken national litigation records, I viewed the report from the lens of what it takes for the Wells family to get justice in this case. [Click Here to Read the 9-Page Grand Jury Report]. I also hold the national record for solving the greatest number of law enforcement coverups in high-profile murder cases. This record started with what the April 3, 1977, edition of the Washington Post called “Alabama’s Watergate” and ended with my series of published articles in 2015 that solved the “Murder of Army Private Lavena Johnson" by her TRADOC Commander on a U.S. military base in Balad, Iraq in July 2005. Criminal Justice for Black Homicide Victims in Mississippi Has Always Been Challenging in Cases Where the Suspected Perpetrators are White Mississippi is a difficult place to obtain justice for black homicide victims, especially when the suspected perpetrators are well-connected local whites. We learned this valuable lesson with Emmett Till's murder case in 1955 and affirmed it with Medgar Evers' murder case in 1963. In Mississippi, the white power structure has never valued the lives of its black citizens. The same is true in Alabama and other Deep South states. Within this historical context, the pursuit of criminal justice for a black homicide victim in Mississippi where the perpetrators are likely well-connected whites must be strategic, relentless, and fought inside a courtroom. The grand jury in Nolan Wells case had 23 members, of whom 12 were white and 11 were citizens of color. There were five blacks on the panel, which makes it hard for the Wells family to claim racial bias in the grand jury review. The decision to return no indictments in the case was unanimous -- meaning 11 jurors of color concurred with 12 white jurors in the decision to NOT charge anyone with a crime in connection with Nolan Wells’ death. Angel Myers McIlrath, who has been a state prosecutor for 20 years and the Jackson County District Attorney for 7 years, did a great job in controlling the grand jury review process, in framing the narrative to achieve a predetermined outcome, and in writing a detailed grand jury report that supported her version of the “truth.” Jackson County, Mississippi District Attorney Angel Myers Mcllrath. I could tell from the report that McIIrath had plenty of experience in handling grand jury matters and in trying criminal cases. The report was a PR masterpiece. It left very little wiggling room for the Wells family to get justice in this case. Wells died on July 4th. An April 2026 grand jury was reconvened on September 14th to hear evidence in the case. The grand jury report was issued on September 18th. In Places Like Mississippi, the Families of Putative Black Crime Victims Must Be Very Proactive in Legal Proceedings The Wells family initiated no ligation in the case against any suspected wrongdoer between July 4th and the time McIllrath reconvened her grand jury on September 14th to review the case. Without litigation, the Wells were outsiders in the law enforcement investigatory process. They had no seat at the table. This left McIIrath free to run the criminal investigation and grand jury proceedings as she saw fit. McIIrath had plenty of time, opportunities, and discretion to guide the evidentiary presentation toward her desired outcome. McIIrath did not care about the litany of Wells family press conferences. Those were external events that impacted nothing inside of her grand jury room. From the beginning, the Wells family should have fought hard to remove McIIrath as the prosecutor in the case. I would have fought like hell to have the court appoint a special prosecutor acceptable to the Wells family to handle the DA's investigation, the grand jury review, and any possible indictments. In a place like Jackson County, Mississippi (population 147,666), a seasoned litigator can always find one or two legitimate conflicts of interest that would have mandated Mcllrath's recusal and supported the family’s request for a court-appointed special prosecutor. That motion should have been filed within 5-7 days of Wells’ death. In the absence of a recusal motion, Mcllrath proactively addressed the relationships of all parties, investigators, and prosecutors inside the grand jury room and the grand jury found (at page 2) there were "no conflicts of interest." This slick move amounted to an unchallenged self-certification of "no conflicts of interest" by the chief prosecutor in a grand jury room she controlled, rather than an independent inquiry and third-party presentation of "no conflicts of interest" in a contested court proceeding. Between July 4th and September 14th, there were about five other strategic legal maneuvers that would have gotten the Wells family a permanent seat inside of the DA’s investigation. It does not appear from the grand jury report that any of these maneuvers occurred. Without them, McIIrath had the clear advantage in shaping the narrative inside the grand jury room and spinning it outside the courthouse. Now, McIIrath’s narrative has been ratified by all 23 grand jurors. Absent a showing by clear and convincing evidence in a subsequent grand jury or court proceeding that these 23 jurors got it wrong, their review of the evidence will likely stand. Despite everything that has happened in this case to date, the Wells family must NOT ask the Trump Department of Justice to conduct any kind of separate grand jury review of this case. That will only make it harder to get to the truth in this case. Trump’s DOJ attorneys are coverup specialists. They have NEVER liberated the truth in any case where the victim was a person of color. What is more, the grand jury report (at page 6) affirms that federal investigators participated in Mcllrath's criminal investigation.
- "The Murder of Private LaVena Johnson" to Become a Movie
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on March 20, 2023 Army Private LaVena Johnson volunteered to participate in Operation Iraqi Freedom in July 2005. Army Private LaVena Johnson was only 19-years-old at the time of her death on a U.S. military base in Balad, Iraq in July of 2005. She was not a military intelligence officer working undercover. She was not killed carrying out a covert military operation against dangerous terrorists in Iraq. Private Johnson’s death was not an accident or a suicide. She was not killed by friendly fire. Private Johnson was not a spy for a foreign power who was killed by American soldiers to protect the potential exposure of “top secret” military information in a war zone. Private Johnson was executed at point-blank range in the back of her head solely because she stumbled upon four-star General Kevin P. Byrnes while he was engaging in prohibited extramarital affair in contravention of a direct order from a superior officer. By all accounts, Private Johnson was a great soldier and a wonderful human being. She was ready and willing to die for her country on the battlefield, but she was not prepared to become a murder victim at the hands of one of her commanders. Private Johnson did not deserve to die this way -- alone, unprotected, murdered, and betrayed by her country’s top Pentagon brass. May her soul rest in eternal peace while her family, friends, and supporters seek criminal justice for her murder. In 2016, my legal team issued a "Wanted" poster for a citizen's arrest of General Byrnes, as authorized under Alabama law. A team of citizens led by noted civil rights icon Joseph L. Cole attempted to arrest General Byrnes. This effort failed only because Byrnes sequestered himself for several days at the sprawling Huntsville, Alabama business complex of defense contractor Raytheon in order to evade his arrest. This is the Story the Pentagon Never Wanted Told in a Hollywood Film Despite coordinated efforts by the United States government to suppress LaVena Johnson's story for 18 years, "The Murder of Private LaVena Johnson” will finally become a Hollywood feature film and a Premium TV channel documentary. Team Ramsey Entertainment, a Los Angeles-based independent film production company, landed the project on March 18, 2023. The company is owned and operated by Eric B. Ramsey and his wife/business partner Nicole Nicke. This Hollywood power couple produces award-winning multimedia content for distribution in the U.S. and around the world. Eric Ramsey (left), Nicole Nicke (center), and Donald Watkins (right). Team Ramsey Entertainment produced the movie, "A Kidnapping on Asylum Hill," starring Tom Sizemore. In January and February of 2023, this movie won six film festival awards, including Best Drama and Best BLM Film (Liber International Film Festival), Best Human Rights Film (New York Tri-State International Film Festival), the International Gold Awards, and London Movie Awards. Eric Ramsey directed this movie. Audiences will be able to see and enjoy "A Kidnapping on Asylum Hill"upon completion of the company's U.S. and international distribution deals. Dr. John H. Johnson, Private LaVena Johnson’s father, will serve as one of the co-executive producers on this true story. "The Murder of Private Johnson" is expected to become a Hollywood blockbuster that is loaded with "A-list" talent. God Always Brings the Right People Together at the Right Time and for the Right Reason I first met Eric B. Ramsey in 1991. He was my first client to be featured in a CBS "60 Minutes" story. At the time, I knew Eric had all of the attributes of a superstar in business. The passage of time has proven me right. Eric and Nicole are the perfect team leaders and co-executive producers for the three film and documentary projects I intend to roll out in Hollywood. This is our first film project together. Team Ramsey Entertainment has access to the best screenwriters, on-camera talent, directors, pre and post-production facilities, film/documentary project financing options, advertising and promotional companies, and distribution channels in Hollywood and abroad. Eric and Nicole have empowerment connections with everyone who matters in the U.S. and international film industry. Legendary TV host/multimedia producer Rock Newman first introduced me to the LaVena Johnson story. In December 2015, Newman arranged a meeting between Dr. Johnson and me. Against tremendous pressure from the Pentagon to leave Private Johnson's death alone, a brave Rock Newman moved forward and aired a TV segment on Private Johnson's murder. Newman, whose commitment to civil rights and equal justice is unshakable, put it all on the line to expose the Pentagon's coverup in Private LaVena Johnson's case. Dr. John Johnson (center) and Donald Watkins (right) discuss Private LaVena Johnson murder case on the Rock Newman TV Show. Every Pentagon Cover-Up Has a Shelf Life; The One in Private Johnson's Case Has Expired The Army’s official version of Private LaVena Johnson’s death is that she committed "suicide." The forensic evidence, however, points to a murder that was committed by General Kevin P. Byrnes. Between the physical and forensic evidence in Iraq, the post-exhumation autopsy in the U.S., a personal notepad kept by Private Johnson, and the litany of cover-up activities by the Pentagon, all of the pieces of evidence needed to solve Private Johnson's homicide case were hiding in plain sight, albeit scattered in two countries that are nearly 7,000 miles apart. Two weeks after her death, the Commander for Iraqi Operations flew to Washington to brief President George W. Bush and Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld on Private Johnson's “suicide." Hers was the only one out of 83 suicides committed by soldiers in 2005 that required a presidential briefing. After this briefing, the Pentagon classified its investigative file in Private Johnson's homicide case as “Top Secret.” After the meeting, General Byrnes was promptly kicked out of the Army even though he was due to retire three months later. To this day, the Pentagon's investigative file remains sealed and classified as "Top Secret." The file can be accessed by the public only if the Secretary of Defense and Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff sign off on a declassification request, which they have not done in 18 years. Four U.S. Presidents -- George W. Bush, Barack Obama, Donald J. Trump, and Joe Biden -- have failed to seek justice in Private Johnson's murder case. All of them gave the Johnson family “bullshit” reasons for turning their backs on Private Johnson. General Kevin P. Byrnes remains free and protected by powerful Pentagon officials in Washington. We remain in hot pursuit of the truth, the murderer, and the culprits who orchestrated the coverup in this case. If Private Johnson's life does NOT matter, whose does? Army Private LaVena Johnson. Epilogue Team Ramsey Entertainment will bring my series of exclusive investigative articles on “The Murder of Private LaVena Johnson” to life on the Big Screen. These articles are linked below: https://www.donaldwatkins.com/post/the-murder-of-pfc-lavena-johnson-part-1 https://www.donaldwatkins.com/post/the-murder-of-pfc-lavena-johnson-part-2 https://www.donaldwatkins.com/post/the-murder-of-pfc-lavena-johnson-part-3 https://www.donaldwatkins.com/post/solving-the-murder-of-army-private-lavena-johnson https://www.facebook.com/donald.v.watkins/posts/pfbid0jzpg3NgEAKT9kh52ifjdK96CbNo7ymaTo4Jdr1Lf5BTqWtTZBJetiFsvYtLiv3MPl https://www.facebook.com/donald.v.watkins/posts/pfbid0R6F5s9k6ZXZUVGwZ3KDh2hKEHhXkg9gXwozkyJbpdna8rXhvK5B5A4NzAYzgqvfml https://www.facebook.com/donald.v.watkins/posts/pfbid021VWh98PdiNVMYW3a7wevebpwcXy99Tgh5RqrEKP76gRQgTWLDbBteLGcubbf9DR7l https://www.donaldwatkins.com/post/private-lavena-johnson-an-opportunity-for-justice https://www.donaldwatkins.com/post/will-dod-secretary-austin-seek-justice-in-private-lavena-johnson-s-murder-case https://www.facebook.com/donald.v.watkins/posts/pfbid02qUWm9iJTMd8pJ5Lps8Fb7CNr4e6Q4rScd8wKvv5HLhGPwx2qbYaVeuVwySJ83224l "The Murder of Private LaVena Johnson" has everything that movie audiences like in a dramatic film: sex, lies, violence in a conflict zone, deception by our government, political shenanigans in Washington, betrayal by those you trust, and suspense at every turn. I sincerely hope this film helps the Johnson family secure the criminal justice that has eluded them for 18 years. Only then can they have peace of mind and closure for Private Johnson's brutal murder. The funeral of Private Johnson.
- Parsons, Kansas Honored Former Douglass School Principal Levi Watkins with a Powerful Showing of Love, Admiration and Respect
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted and Published on June 22, 2025 Dr. Levi Watkins, Principal of the Douglass School for Colored Students in Parsons, Kansas (1940 to 1949). An Editorial Opinion Sontana “Tana” Johnson was waiting for me at the airport in Tulsa, Oklahoma. She drove me to Parsons, Kansas last Wednesday. Tana is the well-known, much-respected, community activist in Parsons who invited me to come back home for the city’s 2025 Juneteenth Celebration. This year's celebration honored my father, Dr. Levi Watkins. Sontana "Tana" Johnson, respected Parsons, Kansas community activist and distinguished head of the SEK Juneteenth Foundation. I have lived in many places during my 76 years in this world, but Parsons is the only place I have called my “home.” My birth certificate notes that I am the fifth child of Levi and Lillian Watkins, who were 37 and 31 when I was born. The certificate also states that my father was “Principal, Douglass School.” At the time, Douglas was the premier elementary and junior high school for “Colored” students in America. In 1940, the Douglass junior high division was the only accredited four-year separate junior high school in Kansas. In 1946, the Douglas junior high division became the home to Chapter No. 446 of the National Honor Society, commencing with seven honor students. By 1947, Douglass students outperformed their peers in Parsons’s ten public schools. Black Life in the "Free State" of Kansas On January 29, 1861, Kansas was admitted to the Union as a “free state." Whites in Kansas voted against becoming a slaveholding state. That vote favorably impacted the lives of Blacks in Kansas for over a century. The Kansas legislature never mandated racial segregation in housing, education, and public accommodations. Segregation existed, but it was mostly a byproduct of social pairings among ethnic communities. The Black community in Kansas, which was 16,250 residents in 1870 (the first time the U.S. census counted Blacks as citizens), rose to 168,279 residents (or 10% of the state's population) by 1950. The state's Black community was hard working, fiercely independent, courageous, deeply religious, and very committed to the education of its children. Between 1881 and 1949, Blacks in Kansas litigated 11 equal education cases all the way up to the Kansas Supreme Court and won an affirmance of the state's "equality mandate" in public education each time. By the time the U.S. Supreme Court decided Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka, Kansas in 1954, Blacks in Kansas were proficient in litigating and winning education-related cases that benefitted “Negro” students. The Douglass School was an Early Model of Education Innovation The Douglass School in Parsons, Kansas opened in 1908. By 1940, Douglass had earned a national reputation as the most advanced “Colored” school in America. When longtime Principal A.E. Clark announced his retirement in 1940, Parsons school superintendent Rees H. Hughes conducted a nationwide search for his successor. Hughes, who also founded Parsons Junior College, sought the "most promising young Negro educator” in America for the job. Dr. Rees H. Hughes, Parsons Superintendent of Schools (1922 to 1942). Dr. Harold Fawcett, a professor of education at Northwestern University identified Levi Watkins as that person and recommended him to Hughes. Watkins earned his Master's degree from Northwestern in Fawcett's Education Administration and Leadership program. Armed with Fawcett's recommendation, Hughes drove to Clarksville, Tennessee, where Dad was working as a teacher and assistant principal, and personally recruited him for the Douglass School principalship. Hughes described a comprehensive support system for Douglass School that was unmatched in other school systems in America. Douglass operated in an ecosystem that rested upon five pillars of strength: (a) a first class faculty and staff, (b) strong, entrenched, and persistent community activism, (c) support from the local chapter of the NAACP and the Parsons Community Services Fund, (d) Blacks in Parsons had perfected the use of court litigation to advance and protect educational opportunities for their children, and (e) the school made the relentlessly pursued educational excellence its standard operating procedure. In the 1940s, no other “Colored” school in America operated with this paradigm of collective advantages. At 30-years-old and married to my 24-year-old mom, with no children of their own, Dad accepted the job. He served as the principal of the Douglass School for 8 years. In April 1947, Dad organized, wrote, and published a "Parsons, Kansas Directory of Negro Residents and Organizations." In the Directory, Dad described Parsons this way: “Parsons, with an estimated 15,000 population, is . . . . a First Class city offering excellent schools, good churches, fair employment opportunities, and fine people with pleasant racial relations.” According to the Directory, Blacks accounted for 1,284 of the city’s population. Parsons had 603 “Negro families who maintained 403 homesteads.” This meant 403 of the Black families owned their home. Only 28% of the families were headed by females. Sixty-nine percent of these families had telephone service in their homes. Blacks owned and operated 42 thriving businesses in Parsons. Many of these businesses had White patrons. Blacks also held managerial jobs in the Parsons school system, at the M-K-T Railroad Company, the Kansas Ordnance Plant, and within the ranks of two large labor unions. Levi Watkins Took the Parsons, Kansas Model for Black Upward Mobility to Montgomery, Alabama Dad’s successful principalship at the Douglass School opened the door to three successful university presidencies in three different states. Alabama was one of them. In 1949, Dad brought the Douglass model for achieving academic excellence, fair employment opportunities, and social justice to Montgomery, Alabama. During his tenure at Alabama State College (ASC), Dad served in the following capacities: Veteran Affairs Officer, Assistant to the President, Business Manager, and President. Over time, Dad built the platform that was necessary to create, enhance, implement, and sustain the Douglass School model in Alabama. In the 1950s, Dr. E.D. Nixon, the local chapter president of the Brotherhood of Sleeping Car Porters, and my Dad introduced a young Rosa Parks and Martin Luther King, Jr., to the art of organizing peaceful civil rights protests and using court litigation to advance educational opportunities for Blacks in Alabama. In the 1960s, Dad helped to install ASC graduate Joe L. Reed as the young Executive Secretary of the 10,000 member Alabama State Teachers Association (ASTA). This organization, which merged into the 20,000 member Alabama Education Association (AEA) in 1969, litigated landmark civil rights cases for Blacks teachers (and others) throughout the state in the 1970s and 80s. Dad also leveraged ASC resources to fund a social justice network that included the Johnnie Carr's Montgomery Improvement Association, the NAACP and SCLC, the Alabama Center for Higher Education, and Montgomery’s Black churches. Dad personally mentored Joseph Cole, a former SGA president at Alabama State University, in the use of effective community leadership skills. After graduation from ASU, Cole became the Gadsden, Alabama Chapter SCLC president. Cole single-handedly desegregated every government body and agency in Gadsden through fearless protests and aggressive federal court litigation. Once this necessary civil rights infrastructure was in place, Dad used Joe Reed’s ASTA/AEA platform and its dedicated stable of skilled civil rights litigators to desegregate the faculty and staffs of nearly all of Alabama’s K-12 public schools in Alabama and all of the state-supported junior colleges and technical schools. In 1980, Dad organized, orchestrated, and launched the 25-year litigation that resulted in court-ordered doctoral programs, new undergraduate academic programs, and nearly $600 million in new funding (beyond the regular state appropriations), endowment money, and other tangible financial benefits for Alabama State University and Alabama A&M University. In 1981, Dad attacked and dismantled Alabama’s bogus and racially discriminatory teacher certification testing program. University of Kansas testing expert, Dr. John Poggio, won this landmark case for the Black plaintiffs in the case. Three decades later, under Dr. Poggio's close scrutiny and diligent oversight, Alabama's discredited teacher testing program was replaced with a unlawful and properly validated one. Unlike the “pleasant racial relations” Dad experienced during his civil rights activism in Parsons during the 1940s, he caught pure hell from the White guardians of the status quo in the "Cradle of the Confederacy" and "Heart of Dixie" for organizing, initiating, directing, and supporting the litigation that enhanced educational opportunities for Black public school, junior college, and university students and teachers in Alabama. Epilogue The Douglass School closed its doors in 1958. The building and grounds were sold to a private company. In 1962, the school was demolished, along with all its contents. Dad successfully transferred the Douglass School model of educational excellence to ASC’s Laboratory School and enhanced it with college-level course offerings for high school students. The Laboratory School closed in 1969 in the wake of federal court desegregation orders. The spirit and soul of Douglass School now resides within the walls of the impressive and growing Valiant Cross Academy in Montgomery, which was founded in 2015 by brothers Anthony and Fred Brock. Anthony Brock graduated from Alabama State University with a Master’s degree in Educational Leadership and Supervision. Valiant Cross Academy students in front of the Alabama State Capitol in 2025 In 2023, Valiant Cross Academy was named the winner of the prestigious Yass Prize. This award is often referred to as the "Pulitzer of Education Innovation." Along with national recognition, the Yass Prize included a $1 million cash award for Valiant Cross Academy. Valiant Cross Academy wins the $1 million Yass Prize in 2023. Last week, my Dad's work at the Douglass School was recognized and honored in Parsons by Tana Johnson, the SEK Juneteenth Foundation, Parsons School Board President Lou Martino and his wife Holly, Rees Hughes’s granddaughter, Megan Hughes, and a host of other community leaders and distinguished persons of interracial goodwill. The Watkins family proudly accepted this honor on behalf of our Dad, Mom, siblings, and all of the Douglass School faculty and staff members and students who made this small Kansas school one of the most iconic and transformative educational institutions in American history. Levi and Lillian Watkins with their children Marie, Pearl, and Levi, Jr., in front of the Douglass School.
- Judge Frank H. McFadden: The Case of Douglas L. Pope
By: Donald V. Watkins Copyrighted on January 16, 2022 Chief U.S. District Court Judge Frank McFadden, federal prosecutor Broward Segrest, and Winton Blount III. An Editorial Opinion On December 30, 2021, I published an editorial titled, "Joe Perkins: The Political Reincarnation of Alabama Power's Walter F. Johnsey." In the article, I described how Chief U.S. District Court Judge Frank H. McFadden (Birmingham) "fixed" the high-profile 1980 "Birmingham Coal Fraud Trial" to free Alabama Power Company and Drummond Company top executives from federal RICO conspiracy, fraud and and price-fixing charges. McFadden was rewarded for his rescue of these corporate executives from the firm grip of federal prosecutors by industrialist and former U.S. Postmaster General Winton Blount. After the last two defendants -- Walter Johnsey and state Senator Joe Fine -- were freed, McFadden resigned his federal judgeship and took a cushy, pre-arranged, high-paying job as Blount, Inc.'s general counsel. Years later, Broward Segrest, the lead prosecutor in the "Birmingham Coal Fraud Trial" case, privately confided in me that McFadden had "fixed" the case. Blount's son, Winton Blount, III, also told me about his dad's quid pro quo arrangement with McFadden during a meeting we had while the younger Blount was running for governor of Alabama. Another top executive at Blount, Inc, who was a personal friend of mine, also confirmed McFadden's improper actions in a private conversation with me. While researching and writing the Perkins-Johnsey article, I recalled one of my many judicial experiences with Judge McFadden when he was in full field-general mode for white supremacy in Alabama. I discussed this experience in two comments I posted under the Perkins-Johnsey article. I should have presented it as a stand-alone article to honor the exceptional courage of my client. This case involved Mr. Douglas L. Pope, a longtime distinguished educator in Pickens County. This brave man fought racial discrimination against the Pickens County, Alabama school system in the 1970s and endured years of personal humiliation and retribution that no human being should ever have to suffer. I also met Ms. Maggie Bozeman and Ms. Julia Wilder during Mr. Pope's fight for equal employment opportunity in Pickens County. These two women were courageous warriors for voting rights and equal justice in West Alabama. They fought with Mr. Douglas L. Pope and me, and they protected me from physical harm while I worked on Mr. Pope's case in Aliceville and Carrollton, Alabama. These two women risked their lives every day to help me develop Mr. Pope's case for trial. Law School Did Not Prepare Me For Judge McFadden's Brand of Judicial Racism Here is what Mr. Pope and I encountered in Judge McFadden's courtroom during Mr. Pope's trial. It was hardcore judicial racism -- something law school did not prepare me for: I had several school desegregation cases in Judge Frank H. McFadden's court from 1974 to 1979. McFadden, who grew up on a farm near Oxford, Mississippi during the Great Depression, was openly hostile and nasty to black plaintiffs in his courtroom. The worst treatment I experienced with McFadden occurred in the school desegregation case of Lee v. Pickens County School System, 563 F. 2d 143 (1977). During the process of implementing court-ordered desegregation of its teachers, staff and students between 1970 and 1973, the Pickens County Board of Education unlawfully demoted Mr. Douglas L. Pope from his principalship at Hopewell High School, where he served with distinction, and assigned him to the Carrollton Annex, which included grades 5-9. The following year, 1972-73, Mr. Pope's school was closed and he was assigned as a classroom teacher in one of the high schools. Mr. Pope's objective qualifications for a high school principalship far exceeded those of all nine white educators who held principalships. In some cases, the white principals did not even have the proper Alabama State Department of Education certification for the job. I filed suit against the Pickens County Board of Education on behalf of Mr. Pope, who was one of the bravest men I have ever met. Pickens County social justice activists Maggie Bozeman and Julia Wilder helped me prepare the case for trial and they provided a security detail for me in Carrollton and Aliceville, Alabama. For my personal safety, I stayed at Ms. Bozeman's guarded home with her and daughter Puntadeleste. Alabama's Black Belt region was extremely dangerous for civil rights lawyers and workers. Superintendent William W. Carpenter made a point to show me the "Face in the Window" of the black man who was lynched decades earlier. Lightening struck as this man looked down at the lynch mob that had come to the jail to kill him. It's said the image of his horrified face was permanently embedded in the glass window pane. Mr. Pope's trial started in 1977. McFadden was the trial judge. He could not stand to look at Mr. Pope or me. For two days, I was killing the Pickens County School System with evidence of intentional discrimination against Mr. Pope. McFadden, who was chief judge in the Northern District of Alabama, tried every judicial trick to gut my case, but the strong and direct evidence of the School System's racial discrimination against Mr. Pope was simply too overwhelming. McFadden suddenly stopped the trial and directed the lawyers and court reporter to come back in his private chambers. Once we were there, he just stared at me for about two minutes without saying a word. The veins in his red neck were popping. In a highly inappropriate move, McFadden ordered everybody out of his chambers, except me. That's when I knew something really bad was about to happen. After everybody exited his chambers, McFadden looked me in the eyes and said: "I don't give a shit what your evidence shows. I am not going to put that nigger in a principalship. By the time you appeal my ruling, win on appeal, and the case is remanded to me for further proceedings, Pope will be too old under state law to work in the School System. Now, get out of here!" My gut told me to put what McFadden said to me in private on the record once I went back into the courtroom. Before the trial restarted, I told McFadden I wanted to put something on the record. He just looked at me in disbelief. I dictated to the court reporter everything McFadden had told me privately. McFadden turned extremely red and was livid. McFadden started banging his gavel and threatened to get physical with me. There was pure hatred in his eyes for Mr. Pope and me. I won the case on appeal and it was remanded back to McFadden for further proceedings. Mr. Pope never got his principalship because McFadden strung out the case until Mr. Pope reached the mandatory retirement age of 70. In the end, all Mr. Pope won was his accrued back pay. As for me, I won the endearing love, admiration, and respect of Mr. Douglas L. Pope, Ms. Maggie Bozeman, and Ms. Julia Wilder. We remained close friends until their deaths. I had come face-to-face with evil in a chief federal judge. I was proud that I did not flinch or sell out Mr. Pope, as many lawyers would have done. Years later, I saw Broward Segrest, the lead prosecutor in the "Coal Fraud Trial." I knew and respected Broward. He told me what really happened with McFadden in the "Birmingham Coal Fraud Trial." Broward said McFadden was "dirty" and he fixed the case for Alabama Power Company, the Drummond Company, and the other defendants. McFadden's reward for fixing the case was his cushy, high-paying General Counsel's job at Blount, Inc. I was not shocked. Broward's story was later corroborated by Winton Blount's son and a friend of mine who served in a senior executive position at Blount, Inc. Chief Judge Frank H. McFadden (Birmingham) v. Chief Judge Frank M. Johnson, Jr. (Montgomery) If it seems like I am being hard on Chief U.S. District Judge Frank H. McFadden in Birmingham, maybe I am. I also had school desegregation cases in Chief U.S. District Judge Frank M. Johnson's courtroom in Montgomery during the same period of time. While McFadden was using his judicial acumen to deprive black litigants of their Constitutional rights, Judge Johnson was catching pure hell from white Alabamians for advancing and protecting our civil rights. McFadden lived a Mountain Brook life-style on a federal judge's modest salary. Johnson lived in a modest home in a transitional neighborhood. McFadden's hand was always out. Johnson's was not. Frank Johnson was ostracized by Alabama's white community. This ostracism, and the bullying that went along with it, caused Johnson's only son to commit suicide. Johnson had a cross burned in his front yard. His mother's home was firebombed. Governor Wallace proposed giving Johnson a "barbed-wire enema." In the face of this unrelenting racial hatred, Judge Johnson did more to break down the barriers of racism than any other white federal judge in Alabama. Today, many federal judges in Alabama tacitly compete to see who among them can screw over the most black litigants in their courts. Some of them have never ruled in favor of a black litigant in any case, and they never will.











